Imaging the Acceptor Wave Function Anisotropy in Silicon
Manuel Siegl, Julian Zanon, Joseph Sink, Adonai Rodrigues da Cruz, Holly Hedgeland, Neil J. Curson, Michael E. Flatté, Steven R. Schofield · 2025
Read Imaging the Acceptor Wave Function Anisotropy in Silicon by Manuel Siegl, Julian Zanon, Joseph Sink, Adonai Rodrigues da Cruz, Holly Hedgeland, Neil J. Curson, Michael E. Flatté, Steven R. Schofield (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13041.txt.
Introduction
Manuel Siegl and co-authors present in this 2025 paper the first microscope images of acceptor wave functions in silicon. Acceptors, defects that take electrons, are candidate building blocks for quantum devices, yet their wave shapes had never been pictured. Bismuth blasted into a silicon wafer left near-surface defects that show up in scanning tunneling images as square rings.
Spectroscopy confirmed the surface turned p-type. Two levels of theory, effective-mass and tight-binding, reproduce the square rings well, tying the shape to the matched light- and heavy-hole bands of silicon. Knowing acceptors' energy and spread so directly, the authors argue, is groundwork for building acceptor-based quantum hardware.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manuel Siegl, Julian Zanon, Joseph Sink, Adonai Rodrigues da Cruz, Holly Hedgeland, Neil J. Curson, Michael E. Flatté, Steven R. Schofield |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13041
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Imaging the Acceptor Wave Function Anisotropy in Silicon Manuel Siegl, Julian Zanon, Joseph Sink, Adonai Rodrigues da Cruz, Holly Hedgeland, Neil J. Curson, Michael E. Flatté, Steven R. Schofield Abstract We present the first scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) images of hydrogenic acceptor wave functions in silicon. These acceptor states appear as square ring–like features in STM images and originate from near-surface defects introduced by high-energy bismuth implantation into a silicon (001) wafer. Scanning tunneling spectroscopy confirms the formation of a p p -type surface. Effective-mass and tight-binding calculations provide an excellent description of the observed square ring–like features, confirming their acceptor character and attributing their symmetry to the light- and heavy-hole band degeneracy in silicon. Detailed understanding of the energetic and spatial properties of acceptor wave functions in silicon is essential for engineering large-scale acceptor-based quantum devices. Shallow defects associated with substitutional impurities in semiconductors are known to be stable and reproducible localized quantum systems. These shallow states, with binding energies of a few tens of meV in silicon Yu, Pater and Cardona (2010) , are well described using a hydrogen-like wave function that extends over many atoms, couples to electric and magnetic fields, and provides access to both charge and spin degrees of freedom. The spin states associated with these defects provide an exceptionally stable platform for quantum technologies, especially quantum computing. When housed in the pristine environment of isotopically purified and low defect density silicon, these spin states exhibit notably long coherence times and high resistance to noise Muhonen et al. (2014) ; Kobayashi et al. (2020) . These properties, combined with the fact that each qubit is naturally identical, position dopants in semiconductors as an arguably superior choice compared to other physical qubit implementations Weber et al. (2010) ; Koenraad and Flatté (2011) . In silicon, nanometer positioning of individual phosphorus Schofield et al. (2003) , arsenic Stock et al. (2020) ; Stock et al. (2024) , and boron Škereň et al. (2020) donor and acceptor impurities has been achieved via scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). This has led to the fabrication of remarkable atomic-scale electronic devices, including the single-atom transistor Fuechsle et al. (2012) and few-donor qubit gates He et al. (2019) ; Thorvaldson et al. (2025) . In order to fully utilize these devices in technologies, such as in the qubit array of an error corrected quantum computer Hill et al. (2015) , the fabrication process will need to be scaled to produce millions of deterministically placed dopants with predetermined and/or gate tunable couplings. This will require not only exquisite control over the positioning of these dopants, but also a detailed understanding of the spatial properties of single defects and their interactions with each other and their environment. In compound semiconductors, like GaAs, there is a long history of dopant investigations using cross-sectional STM where the semiconductor is cleaved in situ Ebert (2003) . Notable successes include mapping the spatial structure of manganese Tang and Flatté (2004) ; Yakunin et al. (2004) ; Marczinowski et al. (2007) and zinc acceptors Loth et al. (2006) , observing binding energy shifts as a function of dopant depth Garleff et al. (2010) , and manipulating the charge state of individual donors Teichmann et al. (2008) . However, in silicon this cleavage method works well only for the (111) surface whose surface states have hindered attempts to image subsurface dopant wave functions Studer et al. (2012) . Efforts to image dopant wave functions in silicon have focussed on thermally-prepared silicon (001) surfaces. Early measurements reported imaging the screened Coulomb potential of ionized arsenic and boron defects at room temperature Liu et al. (2001) ; Liu et al. (2002) ; Nishizawa et al. (2008) . Later, measurements of phosphorus and boron dopants at 4.2 K reported tunneling through neutral donor and acceptor states, respectively Miwa et al. (2013) ; Mol et al. (2013) . In both cases, no spatial structure of the hydrogenic state was observed, possibly due to the shallow depths of the dopants beneath the surface. Nevertheless, subsequent experiments observed highly anisotropic localized features attributed to the hydrogenic donor wave functions of the substitutional arsenic Sinthiptharakoon et al. (2014) ; Usman et al. (2016) . Within the top 12 layers ( \sim 1.5 nm) of the surface, the observed features are strongly influenced by the 2\times 1 reconstruction of the hydrogen-terminated silicon (001) surface Brazdova et al. (2017) . For arsenic donors deeper beneath the surface ( \sim 2.5 nm), the observed features consist of a 1s type envelope function modulated by a high frequency Bloch component observable due to the effect of valley interference in the silicon conduction band Salfi et al. (2014) ; Voisin et al. (2020) . Here we present the first STM observations of hydrogenic acceptor state wave functions in silicon. The observed features are large, sometimes exceeding 10 nm in lateral extent, and are highly anisotropic, exhibiting a square-shaped enhancement with edges aligned to the \langle 001\rangle directions, and a central depression, giving an appearance that we describe as a “square ring” (Fig. 1 b,d,f). Using the effective‑mass approximation (EFMA) and atomistic tight‑binding (TB) calculations, we show that the observed anisotropy is consistent with its origin in the ground‑state multiplet of a hydrogenic acceptor in silicon. Our theory takes into account both the degeneracy of the light and heavy hole bands at the \Gamma -point as well as the local tetrahedral symmetry of the host crystal lattice Yakunin et al. (2004) . A slightly larger spatial extent of the observed features is accounted for in the EFMA theory by a small change in the effective mass of the (assumed isotropic) heavy hole band, which we attribute to strain in the near-surface region. The best fits for our EFMA and TB calculations are obtained for different acceptor depths. This discrepancy is due to differing symmetry and accuracy of the two band structure models and impurity potential models. Acceptor states were created by ion implanting a 15 \Omega cm arsenic-doped Si(001) wafer using five implantation energies (0.25–2.0 MeV) and corresponding fluences (Supporting Table S1) to produce a bismuth density of \sim 1\times 10^{20}\,\text{cm}^{-3} extending from 20 to 550 nm into the sample bulk (Supporting Fig. S1). The sample was annealed at 500 ∘ C overnight under ultrahigh vacuum ( <2\times 10^{-10} mbar), followed by a 10 s flash anneal at 1150 ∘ C by direct current heating, which repairs implantation damage and produces an atomically flat surface suitable for STM imaging. This bismuth implantation and annealing protocol is known to produce a high concentration of near-surface acceptor centers that persist even after thermal treatment, resulting in a p -type surface atop a deeper n -type region Peach et al. (2018) . Prior to STM imaging, the surface was passivated with hydrogen by being exposed to an atomic hydrogen beam (chamber background 5\times 10^{-7} mbar for 5 minutes) while the sample was maintained at 340 ∘ C. STM images were taken at 77 K. Filled and empty-state STM images of the same region of an implanted sample are shown in Fig. 1 a,b and we have highlighted the location of six acceptor states. In the filled-state image (Fig. 1 a), the acceptors are barely noticeable, producing only