Energy Dissipation in Cyclic Strain of Amorphous Solids

Itamar Procaccia, Tuhin Samanta · 2025

Read Energy Dissipation in Cyclic Strain of Amorphous Solids by Itamar Procaccia, Tuhin Samanta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-13035.txt.

Introduction

Itamar Procaccia and Tuhin Samanta trace energy loss in strained amorphous solids to broken symmetry in this 2025 paper. Glasses and other disordered solids can respond to strain in two ways. Some cycles give the energy back, while others waste it as heat.

The team study just one slow cycle of strain to expose the source of loss. A sharp switch between the two behaviors depends on how the solid was prepared. The switch comes with breaking of shift and rotation symmetry, plus screening effects. They solve one case exactly with a middle-scale theory. Matching micro-scale simulations confirm the picture. The result guides models of damping in glasses and gels.

Catalog record

CREATORItamar Procaccia, Tuhin Samanta
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-13035

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Energy Dissipation in Cyclic Strain of Amorphous Solids Itamar Procaccia, Tuhin Samanta Abstract The study of the response of amorphous materials to oscillatory strain is traditionally performed with many repeated cycles. We argue that it pays to consider carefully just one cycle (and may be a second), to reveal the rich physics that characterizes cyclic strain. The response can be conservative or dissipative, with a sharp transition between these options as a function of preparation parameters, accompanied by symmetry breaking and the onset of screening. We choose an example for which the mesoscopic theory can be solved exactly, and the microscopic physics can be revealed by numerical simulations. The mechanism of energy dissipation (when it exists) is explored in detail, shedding light on the reason why repeated cycles exhibit ever decreasing dissipation per cycle, which is often consistent with a universal law. Introduction : Engineers were concerned with the fatigue that results from cyclic applied strains for many decades Miles 1954 ; Dowell 1966 ; Dietmann et al. 1989 ; Klevtsov and Crane 1994 . Physicists and material scientists use cyclic driving to study mechanical properties of materials, like self-organization Corte et al. 2008 ; Regev et al. 2013 , memory effects Paulsen and Keim 2024 ; Fiocco et al. 2014 ; Bandi et al. 2018 ; Mungan et al. 2019 ; Shohat and Lahini 2023 , emergent computational capabilities Bense and van Hecke 2021 ; Liu et al. 2024 ; Kwakernaak and van Hecke 2023 , and yielding Das et al. 2020 ; Bhowmik et al. 2022a . In amorphous solids, every cycle can result in dissipation, rearrangement of configurations and a complicated exploration of the complex energy landscape that is associated with microscopic disorder. Nevertheless, notwithstanding the immense effort and considerable progress, the precise microscopic mechanisms that play a role in cyclic strain protocols still remain elusive. In an early paper Freudenthal, Gumbel and Gough Freudenthal et al. 1953 wrote as follows: “The interpretation of the results of engineering tests of specimens subjected to repeated load cycles is made difficult by the fact that progressive damage, which finally leads to fatigue failure, is a process that is essentially determined by happenings on the submicroscopic scale….Practically all existing fatigue theories … operate on the assumption that fatigue can be explained in terms of a single mechanism. The fact is not considered that one mechanism alone can hardly be expected to describe a phenomenon that is the result of force- and time-dependent processes on the microscopic and submicroscopic level, which are associated with the existence of highly localized textural stress fields, defects and anomalies….”. In this Letter we propose that light can be shed on the physics of cyclic strain by considering just one cycle, and studying what is happening from both microscopic and mesoscopic viewpoints. We choose a cycle for which the mesoscopic theory can be described analytically, whereas its microscopic aspects are revealed by numerical simulations. The system that we have in mind is an amorphous solid that is contained in an annulus, between an outer boundary of radius r_{\rm out} and inner boundary of radius r_{\rm in} . First the material is brought to mechanical equilibrium, and then the inner boundary is inflated by some chosen percentage. The system is brought again to mechanical equilibrium, and the inner boundary is deflated to its original radius, and the system is again brought to mechanical equilibrium. The entire process is one cycle, which is shown graphically in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: Schematic diagram of the cycle. (a) Equilibrated before inflation. (b) Equilibrated after inflation. (c) Equilibrated after deflation. In spite of the elementary nature of this protocol, we will see that it involves rich and complex physics, including screening, symmetry breaking, dissipation and phase transitions. Due to its relative simplicity it can serve as an analog of the harmonic oscillator in molecular physics - an analytically tractable example with lots to learn from. The cycle : The system that we employ below consists of assemblies of small frictionless disks confined in a circular two-dimensional area with a fixed outer circular wall, prepared in mechanical equilibrium, with a desired packing fraction \Phi above the jamming packing fraction \Phi_{j} . Open-source code (LAMMPS) Plimpton 1995 is used to perform the simulations. The studied cycle begins with a configuration of N=80,000 bi-dispersed disks of mass m=1 , randomly placed in a circular area with a radius r_{\text{out}}=172 in dimensionless units. Half of the small disks have a radius R_{1}=0.45 and the other half have a radius R_{2}=0.65 . One large disk of size R_{2} is not placed randomly, but is rather fixed in the center of the coordinates. The normal contact force is Hertzian with force constant k_{n}=2\times 10^{5} , following the Discrete Element Method of Ref. Cundall and Strack 1979 . The system is relaxed to mechanical equilibrium by solving Newton’s second law of motion with damping. This process is carried out until the resultant force on each disk is minimized to values smaller than 10^{-6} . The energy and pressure E_{b} and P_{b} (with the subscript standing for “before” inflation) are then calculated. Once a mechanically stable configuration is reached, the central disk is inflated r_{\rm in}\to r_{\rm in}+d_{0} by some percentage 5\%\ldots 25\% , and subsequently, mechanical equilibration follows, and the resulting displacement field {\bm{d}}(r,\theta) is measured. Afterward, the central particle is deflated back to its original radius, the mechanical equilibration procedure is performed again, and the system’s energy and pressure, termed as E_{f} and P_{f} (final) is calculated. In this step, we further measure the resulting displacement field (between the initial configuration (before inflation) and the final configuration (after deflation) . Finally, the energy difference between the final and the initial configurations \Delta E\equiv E_{b}-E_{f} is calculated and reported here. The cycle is schematically represented in Fig. 1 . One of our aims is to understand when and why the cycle is dissipative with \Delta E\neq 0 . Simulation Results: In spite of the simplicity of this cycle, the observed results can vary widely, primarily due to the sensitive dependence on the pressure. There exists a critical pressure P_{c} , such that for P_{b}>P_{c} the response to the inflation is quasi-elastic, and the whole cycle is basically conservative, without dissipation. At P_{c} one has a transition in the mechanical response of the system, associated with divergent correlation length and non-trivial exponents Jin et al. 2024 ; Fu et al. 2025 , and see the Supplementary Material for a physical explanation of the existence of a critical pressure. It had been shown before Lemaître et al. 2021 ; Bhowmik et al. 2022b ; Kumar et al. 2022 ; Mondal et al. 2022 ; Charan et al. 2023 ; Kumar and Procaccia 2024 that in this regime the displacement field after inflation satisfies the classical equation \Delta\mathbf{d}+\left(\tilde{\lambda}+1\right)\nabla\left(\nabla\cdot\mathbf{d}\right)=0\ , (1) where \tilde{\lambda} is the ratio of the Lamè coefficients, \tilde{\lambda}\equiv\lambda/\mu . Plastic events in this regime, if they occur, are small in extent and can at most renormalize the elastic moduli \lambda and \mu Lemaître et al. 2021 ; Charan et al. 2023 . Consequently, in the present radial geometry one predicts that the radial component of the dissipation field,

Read the complete text