The Flea on the Magnetic Elephant

Pavel Exner, Léo Morin · 2025

Read The Flea on the Magnetic Elephant by Pavel Exner, Léo Morin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-12846.txt.

Introduction

Pavel Exner and Léo Morin study a small asymmetry with outsized effects in a 2025 physics paper. Their system is a particle moving in a plane under two round magnetic wells. When the wells mirror each other and tunneling between them is weak, the two lowest states spread evenly across both wells.

The authors show that an exponentially tiny break in the symmetry flips the picture. Each of the two states then piles up mainly in one well instead of sharing both. The effect echoes a known quirk of Schrödinger operators nicknamed the flea on the elephant. Their result proves the quirk has a purely magnetic twin.

Catalog record

CREATORPavel Exner, Léo Morin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-12846

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Flea on the Magnetic Elephant Pavel Exner, Léo Morin Abstract . We investigate a two-dimensional magnetic Laplacian with two radially symmetric magnetic wells. Its spectral properties are determined by the tunneling between them. If the tunneling is weak and the wells are mirror symmetric, the two lowest eigenfunctions are localized in both wells being distributed roughly equally. In this note we show that an exponentially small symmetry violation can in this situation have a dramatic effect, making each of the eigenfunctions localized dominantly in one well only. This is reminiscent of the ‘flea on the elephant’ effect for Schrödinger operators; our result shows that it has a purely magnetic counterpart. 1. Introduction One of the remarkable effects in quantum mechanics concerns the situation when a tiny violation of symmetry of a double well system may cause a dramatic change in the associated bound state wave functions. Barry Simon [ 19 ] gave it the name ‘flea on the elephant’ when he extended an earlier work done in [ 15 , 5 ] to a multidimensional setting; in his words the flea does not change the shape of the elephant but it can irritate the elephant enough so that it shifts its weight. The crucial element in understanding of this effect was an analysis of tunneling between symmetric wells, specifically the construction of an interaction matrix which effectively describes the bottom of the spectrum and the associated eigenfunctions. Tunneling in magnetic systems turned out to be more complicated, and for a long time only partial results were known [ 14 ] . This has changed by recent results which brought the first tunneling formulæ with magnetic field under the radiality assumptions on the wells [ 1 , 3 , 4 , 10 , 11 , 16 ] ; they involved new purely magnetic effects due to fast oscillations of the eigenfunctions. In [ 2 ] , the first example of tunneling between non-radial purely magnetic wells was obtained. The aim of the present note is to show that the ‘flea on the elephant’ effect has a purely magnetic counterpart which shares with the original the mechanism based on the tunneling between two sufficiently separated wells. Imposing the radiality assumptions on the wells, we adapt the techniques from [ 4 ] in order to study perturbations of a purely magnetic symmetric double-well, and show that tiny perturbations can again have a dramatic effect on the eigenfunctions. In the next section we formulate the problem and state our main result, Theorem 2.3 , reducing the semiclassical expansion at the bottom of the spectrum to a 2\times 2 matrix problem; we also apply it to the case of our interest when the symmetry of double-well system is slightly perturbed. Section 3 is devoted to the proof of Theorem 2.3 . 2. Perturbations of Symmetric Magnetic Wells 2.1. The problem setting and preliminaries As indicated, we will be concerned with purely magnetic double wells; our system is two-dimensional and exposed to magnetic field perpendicular to the plane. Specifically, we consider a pair of radial magnetic wells centered at x_{\ell}=\big(-\frac{L}{2},0\big) and x_{r}=\big(\frac{L}{2},0\big) ; the respective left and right fields are given by \mathscr{C}^{\infty} -smooth functions B_{\ell} and B_{r} , such that - B_{\star}>0 is a radial function of x-x_{\star} , - B_{\star} has its unique minimum at x_{\star} which is non-degenerate, - B_{\star}(x)=b_{1} holds for |x-x_{\star}|\geqslant a , where \star\in\{\ell,r\} , and a\in\big(0,\frac{L}{2}\big) and b_{1}>0 are some constants. The double-well magnetic field B is then defined as superposition of the two single wells, (2.1) B(x)=\begin{cases}B_{\ell}(x)&{\textrm{if}}\quad x_{1}\leq 0,\\ B_{r}(x)&{\textrm{if}}\quad x_{1}\geq 0.\end{cases} With each of the fields B_{\ell} and B_{r} we associated a vector potential satisfying \nabla\times A_{\star}=B_{\star} ; we choose for them the circular gauge, A_{\star}(x)=\int_{[x_{\star},x]}B_{\star}(y)(y-x_{\star})^{\perp}\mathrm{d}y,\quad y^{\perp}=(-y_{2},y_{1}),\quad\star\in\{\ell,r\}. Let us first recall some known facts about single-well system properties. The operators describing the individual wells are then given by \mathscr{L}_{\star}=(ih\nabla+A_{\star})^{2},\quad\star\in\{\ell,r\}. Since each of the magnetic fields B_{\star} have by assumption a unique and non-degenerate minimum, it is well known [ 6 , 12 , 18 ] that the bottom of the spectrum of \mathscr{L}_{\star} is discrete and asymptotic expansion for the low eigenvalues can be obtained explicitly. In particular, according to [ 6 , Theorem 1.2] we have Theorem 2.1 . For \star\in\{\ell,r\} , the ground state of \mathscr{L}_{\star} is a radial function of x-x_{\star} . Moreover, the eigenvalues at the bottom of the spectrum of \mathscr{L}_{\star} satisfy \mu_{\star,j}(h)=h\min B_{\ell}+h^{2}\big(2jd_{\star}+d^{\prime}_{\star}\big)+\mathscr{O}(h^{3}), with d_{\star}=\frac{\sqrt{\det H_{\star}}}{\min B_{\star}},\qquad d^{\prime}_{\star}=\frac{\big({\mathrm{tr}}H_{\star}^{\frac{1}{2}}\big)^{2}}{2\min B_{\star}},\qquad H_{\star}=\frac{1}{2}\,{\rm{Hess}}B_{\star}(x_{\star}). In the following we will use for simplicity the symbol \mu_{\star}:=\mu_{\star,1} for the ground state energy of \mathscr{L}_{\star} and by \Psi_{\star} we denote the corresponding ground state eigenfunction. Since it is a radial function, the eigenvalue equation becomes the 2D radial Schrödinger equation, -\frac{1}{r}\partial_{r}r\partial_{r}\Psi_{\star}+\frac{1}{r^{2}}\Big(\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{D(x_{\star},r)}B_{\star}\mathrm{d}x\Big)^{2}=\mu_{\star}\Psi_{\star}, in the coordinate r=|x-x_{\star}| . In view of this observation, we can construct WKB approximations of \Psi_{\star} in the spirit of [ 9 , 13 ] . Note that such expansions can also be obtained in a magnetic non-radial setting [ 7 , 6 ] , however, these are not known to be exponentially good approximations. Proposition 2.2 . For \star\in\{\ell,r\} , we put d_{\star}(s):=\int_{0}^{s}\frac{1}{2\pi v^{2}}\left(\int_{D(x_{\star},v)}B_{\star}\mathrm{d}x\right)v\mathrm{d}v\,. There exists a sequence of smooth functions (a_{j})_{j\geqslant 0} on \mathbb{R}^{2} , radial with respect to x-x_{\star} , with a_{0}>0 such that the following holds: for any given p\in\mathbb{N} , setting a_{h,\star}(x)=\sum_{j=0}^{p}h^{j}a_{j}(x) , and considering \Psi^{\mathrm{WKB}}_{\star}(x)=h^{-\frac{1}{2}}a_{h,\star}(x)e^{-d_{\star}(|x-x_{\star}|)/h}\,, we have e^{d_{\star}(|x-x_{\star}|)/h}\left(\mathscr{L}_{\star}-\mu_{\star}\right)\Psi_{\star}^{\mathrm{WKB}}=\mathscr{O}(h^{p+1})\,. Moreover, for all \epsilon\in(0,1) , there exist positive C,h_{0}>0 such that, for h\in(0,h_{0}) , (2.2) \|(-ih\nabla-{A}_{\star})(e^{(1-\epsilon)d_{\star}}\Psi_{\star})\|\leqslant Ch\|\Psi_{\star}\| holds for all h\in(0,h_{0}) , and we also have the approximation e^{d_{\star}(|x-x_{\star}|)/h}(\Psi_{\star}(x)-\Psi_{\star}^{\mathrm{WKB}}(x))=\mathscr{O}(h^{p+1})\,. In particular, the inequality ( 2.2 ) provides us with exponential decay estimates on the eigenfunction \Psi_{\star} . 2.2. Magnetic double wells Let us now turn to our proper topic. For the double-well magnetic field ( 2.1 ) we choose a vector potential A such that \nabla\times A=B and the system dynamics is governed by the self-adjoint realization of \mathscr{L}=(ih\nabla+A)^{2}\;\;\text{ on }\;\mathbb{R}^{2}\,; in contrast to the previous subsection we do not need to fix a particular gauge. The central object here is the subspace associated with the spectral projection \Pi=\mathbf{1}_{(-\infty,\Lambda]}\big(\mathscr{L}\big) , where \Lambda:=\min\big(\frac{\mu_{\ell}+\mu_{\ell,2}}{2},\frac{\mu_{r}+\mu_{r,2}}{2}\big) . If the two ground state energies are close to each other, one can construct a basis of {\rm{Ran}}\,\Pi using the corresponding left and right well eigenfunctions, \Psi_{\ell} and \Psi_{r} . Theorem 2.3 . Assume that \mu_{\ell}-\mu_{r}=o(h^{2}) and L>(2+\sqrt{6})a . Then there exists an orthonormal basis (e_{\ell},e_{r}) of {\rm{Ran}}\,\Pi such that e_{\ell}=\Psi_{\ell}+\mathscr{O}(h^{\infty}),\quad e_{r}=\Psi_{r}+\mathscr{O}(h^{\infty}), and the matrix representing \mathscr{L} in this basis is M=\begin{pmatrix}\mu_{\ell}&w\\ \overline{w}&\mu_{r}\end{pmatrix}+o(w) with w=c_{0}h^{\nu}e^{-\frac{S}{h}}(1+o(1)) as h\to 0 for some constants c_{0}\neq 0 and \nu\in\mathbb{R} . Here (2.3) S=d_{\ell}\left(\textstyle{\frac{L}{2}}\right)+d_{r}\left(\textstyle{\frac{L}{2}}\right)+I, where the d_{\star} are defined in Theorem 2.1 , I is a positive number given by I=\frac{M}{2}-\frac{b_{1}L^{2}}{8}+\frac{b_{1}L}{2}\sqrt{\frac{L^{2}}{4}-\frac{M}{b_{1}}}-M\ln\left(1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4M}{b_{1}L^{2}}}\right), and M=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{2}}(2b_{1}-B_{\ell}-B_{r})\,\mathrm{d}x . We postpone the proof to Section 3 below and focus first on the consequences of the theorem. It is easy to diagonalize the 2\times 2 matrix M ; as a corollary we deduce asymptotic behavior of the eigenfunctions of \mathscr{L} . The instability of these eigenfunctions we are interested in is then a consequence of the instability of the eigenvectors of M . Corollary 2.4 . Assume \mu_{\ell}-\mu_{r}=o(h^{2}) and L>(2+\sqrt{6})a . (1) If |\mu_{\ell}-\mu_{r}|\ll w , then the normalized eigenfunctions \Psi_{1} and \Psi_{2} of \mathscr{L} are localized in both

Read the complete text