Bayesian Optimization of Pythia8 Tunes

Ali Al Kadhim, Harrison B Prosper, Stephen Mrenna · 2025

Read Bayesian Optimization of Pythia8 Tunes by Ali Al Kadhim, Harrison B Prosper, Stephen Mrenna (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-11675.txt.

Introduction

Ali Al Kadhim and two co-authors tune in 2025 the Pythia8 particle physics simulator with Bayesian optimization. Pythia models how particles shower and form hadrons after collisions, and its behavior hangs on a web of parameters. The six most important were handed to a Bayesian search that balances exploring new settings against refining good ones.

The new tune fits electron-positron data from the ALEPH experiment better than the shipping default. The authors describe it as the most thorough Bayesian tuning of a shower and hadronization model yet on that dataset. Better tunes sharpen every prediction that flows from the simulator, from detector design to the hunt for new particles.

Catalog record

CREATORAli Al Kadhim, Harrison B Prosper, Stephen Mrenna
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-11675

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bayesian Optimization of Pythia8 Tunes Preprint: AAPM/123-QED,FERMILAB-PUB-25-0323-CSAID Ali Al Kadhim, Harrison B Prosper, Stephen Mrenna Abstract A new tune (set of model parameters) is found for the six most important parameters of the Pythia8 final state parton shower and hadronization model using Bayesian optimization. The tune fits the LEPI data from ALEPH better than the default tune in Pythia8 . To the best of our knowledge, we present the most comprehensive application of Bayesian optimization to the tuning of a parton shower and hadronization model using the LEPI data. I Introduction and Motivation An understanding of confinement (for which there is a 1M dollar prize from the Clay Institute 1 1 1 https://www.claymath.org/millennium/yang-mills-the-maths-gap/ ) requires the identification of the mechanism by which colored partons become color singlet hadrons. This phenomenon is currently described by models that are inspired by the strong interaction, but are not derived from first principles. Motivated by evidence from QCD factorization theorems QCD_factorization_Collins , it is assumed that hadronization is a universal process that can be factorized from the perturbative calculations. If this is true, the same hadronization model can be used both in proton-proton collisions as well as electron-positron collisions: a model fit to LEPI electron-positron collision data can be applied to simulations at the LHC . An advantage of studying hadronization using LEPI data is that absence of phenomena associated with the break-up of the colliding beams. LEPI provided a nearly perfect environment to study hadronization effects ALEPH_1996_S3486095 , one characterized by a well-defined initial e^{+}e^{-} state and a high event rate at the Z mass DELPHI:1996sen . Furthermore, a large improvement in the quality of the data and a reduction of systematic errors was achieved at LEPI with respect to what was achieved in the era of PETRA and PEP QCD_Event_Generators . Finally, using one dataset from one experiment avoids the problem of having to correct for correlations that exist between different experiments and datasets. Currently, two phenomenological models of hadronization 2 2 2 “Hadronization” and “fragmentation” can be used almost interchangeably. are widely studied: cluster hadronization ORIGINAL_CLUSTER_MODEL and string fragmentation ANDERSSON198331 . The Lund string model ANDERSSON198331 (summarized in Sec. III ) is the basis for the hadronization model in Pythia8 . This model will be the subject of the current study. The task of studying the Lund model seems daunting, since it requires expensive simulations with many possible, different model parameters. The development of efficient tools to support the tuning of these parameters is a high priority for such studies. The choice of experimental data used to tune the Lund string model parameters is an important consideration. The experimental data should cover a wide range of physics so as not to miss the full implications of the model. Surveys have been conducted which conclude that model parameters are best determined by fitting the model to inclusive distributions, jet rates and shape distributions simultaneously DELPHI:1996sen . For these reasons, we chose to use the LEPI data for QCD observables collected by the ALEPH detector, published in Ref. ALEPH_1996_S3486095 , for the tuning of the Lund hadronization parameters. The data offer a rich set of observables to tune these parameters, and comprises a collection of \mathcal{O}(30) event-shape variables such as thrust, sphericity, aplanarity, and inclusive distributions such as p_{T}^{in},p_{T}^{out} and the rapidity with respect to the thrust axis. See Ref. ALEPH_1996_S3486095 for descriptions of these observables. The investigations reported in this paper have two goals: 1. Investigate the use of Bayesian optimization for tuning Pythia8 parameters by minimizing an objective function. In principle, Bayesian optimization is ideally suited for such a problem because of the high computational cost of evaluating the objective function, which requires simulating a large number of events at each tune parameter point. 2. Assess whether Bayesian‐optimized tuning converges to the same parameter point as obtained with methods such as Professor professor or Apprentice krishnamoorthy_apprentice_2021 . The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we briefly review tuning methods and how our approach differs from them. In Sec. III the six Pythia8 parameters, which are the focus of the tuning, are reviewed. Section IV briefly describes the LEPI event datasets employed and the objective function used in the tuning. Section V describes implementation details of the Bayesian optimization framework. The results of the Bayesian optimization of the six tune parameters are presented in Sec. VI and compared with the tune results from Professor / Apprentice ‐based fits. Finally, Sec. VII provides our conclusions. The interested reader can follow the directions in Sec. A to reproduce all results presented in this paper. II Monte Carlo tune methods II.1 Professor and Professor -like tunes Professor professor is the main event generator tuning method used by CMS , ATLAS and other large collaborations. Recently, new tools for event generator tuning have become available, including Apprentice krishnamoorthy_apprentice_2021 , Autotunes autotunes , and machine learning (ML) methods such as MLHAD MLHAD ; Modelling_had_with_ML and HAD-ML NNs_for_Reweighting_Tuning . While Professor (and Professor -like tuning methods such as Apprentice ) have produced excellent results there is still room for improvement: • the estimated uncertainties are based on the Hessian inverse, consequently, there is no guarantee that the confidence sets have valid coverage; • the polynomial fit to the Monte Carlo (MC)-based predictions is adequate for well-behaved distributions, but may fail for more singular distributions, (though see Austin:2019uci for a rational polynomial fitter available in Apprentice ) and • the choice of the weights in these methods is done manually (though see Wang:2021gdl for algorithms to select these weights). II.2 CMS CUET Tunes and MPI considerations CMS has determined tunes, dubbed CUET CMS_CUET , which focus on the modeling of multi-parton interactions (MPI) in event generators. Multi-parton interactions are 2\rightarrow 2 parton scatterings that occur within the same hadron-hadron collision, but are softer than the hard scattering ( p_{T}<3 GeV). Like the hadronization models, MPI models are also phenomenological with free parameters determined by fits to data. CMS has recently evolved beyond this and now uses the CPX family of tunes that use NLL \alpha_{s} and NNLO parton distribution functions (PDF) CMS:2019csb . II.2.1 Tuning with Bayesian Optimization The tuning of an event generator involves generating a sufficient number of events at any given tune point, which is computationally costly. Optimization of a costly objective function is the kind of problem for which Bayesian optimization BayesOptOverview is, in principle, well suited. Bayesian optimization (BayesOpt) has been attempted before Ilten:2016csi to tune event generators, but this paper presents a more thorough investigation of BayesOpt and its application to the tuning of Pythia8 . Since BayesOpt remains unfamiliar to many particle physicists, Sec. V presents the necessary background before the tune results obtained for Pythia8 are presented in Sec. VI . III Lund Fragmentation Model Parameters The central assumption of the Lund model is that a quark-antiquark pair is subject to the QCD potential V_{\mathrm{QCD}}(r)\approx-\frac{4}{3}\frac{\alpha_{\mathrm{s}}}{r}+\kappa r , where r is the distance between the quark and the antiquark and \alpha_{s} is the strong coupling parameter. For an energetic quark and antiquark pair traveling in opposite directions, the linear term is most relevant. The Lund model views the confining force between colored charges as a flux tube

Read the complete text