High-resolution, high-efficiency narrowband spectroscopy with an s-p -phased holographic grating in double pass
C. Farret Jentink, F. Pepe, C. Lovis, C. Schwab, F. Wildi, A. Clawson · 2025
Read High-resolution, high-efficiency narrowband spectroscopy with an s-p -phased holographic grating in double pass by C. Farret Jentink, F. Pepe, C. Lovis, C. Schwab, F. Wildi, A. Clawson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-11147.txt.
Introduction
Casper Farret Jentink and co-authors test a holographic grating setup that reaches very fine spectral detail while keeping most of the light, in a paper from 2025. Astronomy spectrographs that split light finely, for hunting planets by star wobble, usually waste much of the light they collect. That loss hurts studies of planet atmospheres.
Their design passes light twice through a tuned volume phase holographic grating with dense fringes. With a tunable laser, they measured a resolving power above 140,000 and a peak efficiency of 79 percent for unpolarized light. Based on what factories can now make, they estimate efficiency above 50 percent with resolving power past 200,000, from visible light into the near infrared. Detector size is the main limit left.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | C. Farret Jentink, F. Pepe, C. Lovis, C. Schwab, F. Wildi, A. Clawson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-11147
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
High-resolution, high-efficiency narrowband spectroscopy with an s-p -phased holographic grating in double pass C. Farret Jentink, F. Pepe, C. Lovis, C. Schwab, F. Wildi, A. Clawson Abstract Context. High-resolution spectroscopy (R¿50,000) in astronomy is typically done with echelle-type spectrographs. The science for which these instruments have proven very effective is the detection of exoplanets through the radial velocity method, and characterizing their atmospheres. However, for atmospheric characterization, it has proven tedious to detect these signals, mostly due to sensitivity constraints. While echelle-type spectrographs provide the necessary large bandwidth for radial velocity measurements, they compromise total throughput. Additionally, the need for spectral order sorting complicates the optical design and reduces throughput further. A high spectral resolution and a limited bandpass is required to measure exoplanet atmospheric absorption from the ground. Therefore, we propose a new method to achieve very high spectral resolution with significantly higher throughput within a limited bandpass, focused on a specific spectral line or set of spectral lines of interest. Aims. We describe and test a novel method for reaching a high spectral resolution with very high unpolarized diffraction efficiency in first-order employing a tuned, high fringe-density volume phase holographic (VPH) grating in double pass. Additionally, we provide lab tests highlighting the potential of such a setup. Methods. We use a wavelength-tunable laser to measure the dispersion and diffraction efficiency of a tuned VPH grating. We compare a single-pass and double-pass setup to verify the expected results. Besides, we image the resulting spectrum to assess optical quality. Results. We find that the VPH grating we tested can reach a diffraction-limited resolving power of ¿140,000 in double pass, with a peak double-pass diffraction efficiency of 79% for unpolarized light. We tested the grating at a more modest resolution of 38,000 given sampling constraints. Based on current manufacturing abilities, we estimate double-pass diffraction efficiencies over 50% with diffraction-limited resolving powers ¿200,000 should be within reach from the visible to near-infrared, where the bandwidth is limited by detector size. Conclusions. For specific science cases where a relatively narrow wavelength regime at (ultra-)high spectral resolution is required, a double-pass VPH setup can prove to be very efficient. As the grating operates in first order, there is no need for cross-dispersion, allowing for very high total system throughputs and overall, less complicated optics. This could bring ground-breaking science to smaller class telescopes, with relatively compact instruments, and can be of special interest for exoplanet atmospheric characterization, as these observations typically require a large amount of observing time, high signal-to-noise, and high spectral resolution. 1 Introduction High-resolution spectroscopy (R¿50,000) in astronomy is typically done with cross-dispersed Echelle spectrographs for the UV to near-infrared (near-IR) regime. First described by Nagaoka & Mishima 1923 , well-known instruments are for example STIS on the Hubble Space Telescope ( Woodgate et al. 1998 ) , CRIRES & ESPRESSO on the Very Large Telescope ( Kaeufl et al. 2004 ; Pepe et al. 2010 ) , and HIRES on Keck ( Vogt et al. 1994 ) . Echelle spectrographs combine a low groove density and high spectral order, as the maximum (diffraction-limited) spectral resolving power R is given by the spectral order M , multiplied by the number of illuminated grating lines N (Eq. 1 ): R=M\times N. (1) R thus depends on the size of the incident beam falling on the grating and its angle-of-incidence (AOI). It is the total optical path difference imposed by the grating that counts. The groove density, spectral order(s), and resolving power are typically matched to satisfy the instrument requirements. Another important factor to consider here is the free spectral range (FSR). The FSR of a single order M_{i} is defined as the spectral distance from its maximum intensity peak to the peak of the adjacent order M_{i\pm 1} and is given by \mathrm{FSR}_{i}=\frac{\lambda}{M_{i}}. (2) Typically, at high orders (M¿20), to cover a broad wavelength range (like the full visible regime, 380\mathrm{nm}<\lambda<750\mathrm{nm} ), some method is required to split these spatially overlapping orders. To do this, one typically introduces a cross-disperser – a secondary dispersive element, like a grating or prism, with a dispersion axis perpendicular to the dispersion axis of the echelle, to separate overlapping orders ( Nagaoka & Mishima 1923 ) . As an echelle setup relies on additional optics to separate overlapping spectral orders, the total throughput of the system suffers and overall complexity increases. Besides, given echelle gratings are mechanically ruled, they are prone to suffering from manufacturing errors. For example, they can produce significant amounts of stray light because of random errors on the grating surface and can suffer from optical ghosts as a result of periodic ruling errors ( Gao et al. 2021 ) . Large echelle gratings are also challenging to manufacture, and hence commercial options are limited. A different type of grating that has gained popularity in the world of astronomical instrumentation is the volume phase holographic (VPH) grating ( Barden et al. 1998 ; Arns et al. 1999 ) . These immersed gratings have become popular because they: • Are easily tunable in groove density, size, and glass type for specific applications. • Provide very high first-order diffraction efficiencies. • Barely suffer from periodic or random errors, eliminating ghosts and greatly reducing scattered light. • Are well protected due to their immersion in between two glass plates, allowing for easy handling and cleaning. In a direct comparison, VPH gratings typically surpass echelle gratings in terms of efficiency, scattered light performance, and spectral resolution ( Kielkopf 1981 ; Farret Jentink et al. 2023 ) . VPH gratings generally operate in first order. According to Eq. 1 , achieving high spectral resolution requires a greater number of illuminated lines on the grating to match the resolutions provided by echelle gratings. Thanks to their manufacturing process, VPH gratings can accommodate this need, as they can be produced with up to ¿6000 lines/mm ( Barden et al. 1998 ) , significantly exceeding the line densities of typical echelle gratings. However, as the groove density increases, the angle of incidence (AOI) required to achieve maximum efficiency in the first spectral order also changes. At very high groove densities, where the AOI exceeds 36^{\circ} , VPH gratings become significantly less efficient for light in the s -polarized state ( Baldry et al. 2004 ) . Note that for the remainder of this paper we adopt the definition in which the s -polarization has an electric vector that is perpendicular to the grating lines, similar to Baldry et al. 2004 . For measurements of unpolarized light, which are common in astronomy, the efficiency advantages of VPH gratings can be less apparent when compared to echelle gratings in high spectral resolution configurations. However, to achieve high first-order diffraction efficiency for unpolarized light at high groove densities, one can optimize the grating thickness and refractive index modulation to align the efficiency curves of s - and p -polarized light within a narrow wavelength range. This technique was initially described by Dickson et al. 1994 , and such specially optimized VPH gratings are often referred to as Dickson gratings. To achieve very high spectral resolution while maintaining high throughput, a new instrument named NIGHT ( Farret Jentink et al. 2023 ) will utilize this