Nonlocal dielectric properties of water: the role of electronic delocalisation
Darka Labavic, Florian N. Brünig, Roland R. Netz, Marie-Laure Bocquet, Hélène Berthoumieux · 2025
Read Nonlocal dielectric properties of water: the role of electronic delocalisation by Darka Labavic, Florian N. Brünig, Roland R. Netz, Marie-Laure Bocquet, Hélène Berthoumieux (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-11101.txt.
Introduction
Water shields electric charge, but that shield acts in a way that shifts with distance in subtle ways. Darka Labavić and co-authors probe that shield with first-principles computer runs in a 2025 paper. They read the shield's strength from how charge jitters inside the liquid.
The true-to-physics runs gave a stronger, wider shield than the classic force models used in most such work. The gap comes from how charge spreads across molecules, a trait the classic models freeze in place. At gaps the size of one molecule, the classic models could miss the shield's strength by a factor of ten. The result warns chemists who model water at fine scales.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Darka Labavic, Florian N. Brünig, Roland R. Netz, Marie-Laure Bocquet, Hélène Berthoumieux |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-11101
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nonlocal dielectric properties of water: the role of electronic delocalisation Darka Labavic, Florian N. Brünig, Roland R. Netz, Marie-Laure Bocquet, Hélène Berthoumieux Abstract The nonlocal dielectric properties of liquid water are studied in the context of ab initio molecular dynamics simulations based on density functional theory. We calculate the dielectric response from the charge structure factor of the liquid using the fluctuation-dissipation theorem. We show that the dielectric response function of ab initio simulations differs significantly from that of classical force-fields, both qualitatively and quantitatively. In particular, it exhibits a larger amplitude and a wider range of responding wave numbers. We suggest that the difference is due to the localisation of the electronic charge density inherent in classical force files and Wannier post-treatment of DFT densities. The localised charge models do not reproduce the shape of the response function even for q q corresponding to intermolecular distances, and could lead to a significant underestimation of the dielectric response of the liquid by a factor of 10. I Introduction Characterizing the screening properties of water at microscopic scales is essential for understanding many interfacial dynamical phenomena at electrode surface like friction and its recently unveiled quantum counterpart, [ 1 ] like redox reactions entailing electron transfer. [ 2 , 3 ] A key observable to account for the water electrostatic contribution is the dielectric response function of bulk water from ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations that include the electronic density. The static dielectric constant of water, \epsilon , is well-known about 80 for macroscopic distances, i.e. the bulk regime. However, at nanometric range, the screening properties of the fluid deviates dramatically from the bulk environment. [ 4 , 5 ] A convenient way of describing this scale-dependent behavior is to introduce a non-local permittivity \epsilon(q) for liquid water which is a function of the wavenumber q in Fourier space. The shape of \epsilon(q) governs ion-water and ion-ion interaction at the nanoscale but also the structure of interfacial and confined solutions. [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] Using the fluctuation-dissipation theorem, \epsilon(q) can be expressed as a function of the charge structure factor S(q) , which is easily computed from classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. \epsilon(q) for water, firstly simulated in 1996 using the classical force-field BJH [ 11 ] reveals a range of wavenumbers q over which the permittivity \epsilon(q) is negative, which was referred to as an ”overscreening zone”. As an illustration, Fig. 1 a) represents \epsilon(q) for the SPC/E model of water and exhibits a range of negative screening values, and is flanked by diverging poles at low and high q . The dielectric response function \chi(q) , also called the dielectric susceptibility, is free of poles [ 11 , 12 ] and is a probe of water charge structure at the molecular level. It depends directly on the charge structure factor as \chi(q)=S(q)/q^{2}\epsilon_{0}k_{B}T and is related to \epsilon(q) by \chi(q)=(1-\epsilon(q))^{-1} . \chi(q) for SPC/E water model is plotted in Fig. 1 b). We observe a zone of ”overresponse” ( \chi\gg 1 ) corresponding to the overscreening range for \epsilon(q) . \chi(q) has a continuous resonant form that reaches a sharp maximum for q = $30\text{\,}\mathrm{n}\mathrm{m}$^{-1} , indicating a typical length \lambda=2\pi/q\simeq 20\text{\,}\mathrm{n}\mathrm{m} for the charge organisation: the H-bond length (indeed the distance O-O in O-H…O hydrogen bound ranges from 3 to 3.5 Å). Both \epsilon(q) and \chi(q) observables have been computed via MD atomistic simulations of bulk water for rigid, [ 8 , 13 ] flexible [ 11 ] and polarizable [ 14 ] classical force-field models, showing consistently a phenomenon of ”overscreening”/”oversponse”. Figure 1: Dielectric permittivity \epsilon(q) (a) and dielectric response function \chi(q) (b) of bulk water as a function of the wavenumber q from classical force-field SPC/E simulations of water. Simulation methods are given in ref [ 9 ] . \epsilon(q) and \chi(q) are calculated from the radial distribution function for large q (solid line) and for discrete wavenumbers at low q (data points). Up to now, the effect of the delocalised electronic charge on \chi(q) is not included in such models although it is expected to be important, in particular at high wavenumbers, [ 15 ] i.e. at sub-angstrom distances. The study of the dielectric properties of water using AIMD simulations initially targets macroscopic and static properties of liquid water such as the molecular dipole [ 16 ] and the dielectric constant. [ 17 ] But in recent years, AIMD simulations have been applied to investigate nanoconfined water within graphene slits. [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] For the analysis of the charge distributions in AIMD simulations, the electronic density of water is usually treated using the maximally localized Wannier function formalism. This post-processing treatment assigns the 8 valence electrons of water molecule to localized chemical bonds: 2 electrons for each OH bonds and 2 electrons per oxygen lone pair. [ 21 ] In most cases, the resulting Wannier dipole moment (computed from the charges Wannier centers and the nuclei) is the only observable output which is sufficient for getting the total \epsilon(q\to 0) that is compared to measurements. It is well-studied that the dielectric properties of water calculated with ab initio simulations show important differences when compared to the classical MD simulations, both for bulk [ 22 ] and confined water, [ 19 ] for nonlocal and for frequency-dependent properties. [ 22 , 19 ] Moreover, AIMD simulations better agree with experimental data than the classical force-fields. [ 22 , 19 ] This is due in particular to a better representation of hydrogen bonding, which leads to an improved description of the collective effects of the H-bond network. All these charge correlation effects are encoded in the dielectric response function \chi(q) , which has not yet derived from AIMD. In this work, we compare bulk liquid water’s nonlocal dielectric response function for SPC/E classical force-field and for quantum DFT simulations.The results between AIMD and classical MD simulations differ significantly, quantitatively and qualitatively. To understand this unexpected result, we compute the dielectric response for different classical force fields to tackle the effect of the charge distribution inside a water molecule. For sake of comparison, we renormalise the \chi(q) spectra of the different models by the total electronic charge per molecule and obtain a ”master” response function plot. We use this plot to discuss the effects of structural flexibility and electronic delocalisation included in the DFT-based AIMD method that are missing in rigid classical models. We show that the susceptibility \chi(q) associated with the Wannier center yields spurious results, due to non-physical high values of localized electronic charges. On the contrary, the response function obtained from the Wannier-derived dipoles alone can be compared very well with the SPC/E spectrum. Finally, we show that more advanced classical force fields as flexible or polarisable models do not describe the electronic correlations significantly better than SPC/E. Taken together, this work shows that AIMD with direct electronic density is the only way to get the correct dielectric response of water, in the width and amplitude of the response function. II Simulation methods Figure 2: Snapshot of the classic and quantum simulation boxes of bulk water. Size of the box: L =2 nm. (a)