Quantum Statistical Mechanics of Electronically Open Molecules: Reduced Density Operators

Jacob Pedersen ‡, Bendik Støa Sannes, Ida-Marie Høyvik · 2025

Read Quantum Statistical Mechanics of Electronically Open Molecules: Reduced Density Operators by Jacob Pedersen ‡, Bendik Støa Sannes, Ida-Marie Høyvik (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-10893.txt.

Introduction

Jacob Pedersen, Bendik Støa Sannes, and Ida-Marie Høyvik wrote a paper in two thousand twenty-five about molecules that trade electrons with their surroundings. Standard quantum statistical mechanics treats a molecule as closed, yet open molecules share electrons with an environment. That sharing breaks the usual way of tracing out the environment to get the molecule's own state.

The authors build a clear definition of that partial trace for fermions, where a known ambiguity had lingered. They split the combined system into molecule, environment, and interaction parts on a shared orbital base. Their reduced state rests on an approximation that drops some transfer channels. It generalizes the grand canonical state and yields a matching notion of chemical potential that can allow fractional transfer.

Catalog record

CREATORJacob Pedersen ‡, Bendik Støa Sannes, Ida-Marie Høyvik
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE73 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-10893

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum Statistical Mechanics of Electronically Open Molecules: Reduced Density Operators Jacob Pedersen ‡, Bendik Støa Sannes, Ida-Marie Høyvik Abstract We present a reduced density operator for electronically open molecules by explicitly averaging over the environmental degrees of freedom of the composite Hamiltonian. Specifically, we include the particle-number non-conserving (particle-breaking) interactions responsible for the sharing of electrons between the molecule and the environment, which are neglected in standard formulations of quantum statistical mechanics. We propose an unambiguous definition of the partial trace operation in the composite fermionic Fock space based on composite states in a second quantization framework built from a common orthonormal set of orbitals. Thereby, we resolve the fermionic partial trace ambiguity. The common orbital basis is constructed by spatial localization of the full orbital space, in which the full composite Hamiltonian naturally partitions into a molecule Hamiltonian, an environment Hamiltonian, and an interaction Hamiltonian. The new reduced density operator is based on the approximation of commutativity between the subsystem Hamiltonians (i.e., molecule and environment Hamiltonians) and the interaction Hamiltonian, which we show corresponds to excluding certain electron transfer channels and neglecting electron transfer relaxation effects. The reduced density operator can be viewed as a generalization of the grand canonical density operator. We are prompted to define the generalized chemical potential, which aligns with the standard interpretation of the chemical potential, apart from the possibility of fractional rather than strictly integer electron transfer in our framework. In contrast to standard approaches, our framework enables an explicit consideration of the electron occupancy in the environment at any level of theory, irrespective of the model used to describe the molecule. Specifically, our reduced density operator is fully compatible with all possible level-of-theory treatments of the environment. The approximations that render our reduced density operator identical to the grand canonical density operator are (i) restriction of excitations to occur within the same orbitals and (ii) assumption of equal interaction with the environment for all molecule spin orbitals (i.e., the wide-band approximation). † † affiliation: Department of Chemistry, Technical University of Denmark, DK-2800 Kongens Lyngby, Denmark † † affiliation: Department of Chemistry, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, N-7491 Trondheim, Norway † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Department of Chemistry, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, N-7491 Trondheim, Norway 1 Introduction An open quantum system exchanges information, that being energy and/or particles, with its environment, Breuer and Petruccione (2002) ; Nitzan (2006) ; May and Kühn (2023) ; Mukamel (1999) and we advocate viewing molecules as open quantum systems. Meanwhile, we are not interested in explicitly describing the composite system (molecule and environment). Instead, we pursue reduced descriptions aiming at explicitly treating the molecule with the environmental effects included implicitly. In such reduced description perspectives, information about the molecule will be irreversibly lost to the environment, and the state of the molecule will be accompanied by some degree of uncertainty. Hence, quantum statistical mechanics becomes mandatory to make predictions about the molecule and its properties. Fano (1957) The standard formulation of quantum statistical mechanics is based on (reduced) density operators derived under the approximation of an additively separable composite Hamiltonian, which means that the interaction between the molecule and the environment has been neglected. Zubarev (1973) ; Balescu (1975) ; Feynman (2018) However, this is a crude approximation, since this includes the terms responsible for the sharing of electrons between the molecule and the environment. Therefore, we will in this work derive a reduced density operator for electronically open molecules, i.e., molecules able to share electrons with the environment, by explicitly averaging out the environmental degrees of freedom of the composite Hamiltonian. This new reduced density operator can be viewed as a generalization of the grand canonical density operator. In the quantum chemistry community, the standard practice for modeling energetically open molecules, i.e., molecules interacting with the environment through electrostatic interactions, is to incorporate the effect of the environmental interaction into the model of the molecule by means of effective Hamiltonians. Guido et al. (2020) ; Csizi and Reiher (2023) ; Sun and Chan (2016) ; Bakowies and Thiel (1996) ; Olsen and Kongsted (2011) ; Kongsted et al. (2003) ; Kongsted et al. (2002) ; Kongsted et al. (2003) ; Steindal et al. (2011) ; Nielsen et al. (2007) ; Aidas et al. (2008) ; Olsen et al. (2015) ; Barone et al. (2022) ; Curutchet et al. (2009) ; Wesolowski et al. (2015) ; Höfener and Visscher (2012) ; Folkestad et al. (2024) ; Chulhai and Goodpaster (2017) ; Jacob and Neugebauer (2014) ; Lee et al. (2019) ; Chulhai and Goodpaster (2018) ; Sæther et al. (2017) ; Høyvik (2020) ; Giovannini and Koch (2020) ; Myhre et al. (2013) ; Myhre et al. (2014) ; Myhre and Koch (2016) ; Folkestad and Koch (2019) ; Folkestad et al. (2021) The use of such effective Hamiltonians can be viewed as facilitating energy dissipation into the environment during an energy minimization (i.e., energetic equilibration) of the molecule. However, it is not yet standard practice to consider electronically open molecules. In response to that, we have recently presented wave-function-based Matveeva et al. (2023) ; Paul née Matveeva et al. (2024) ; Pedersen et al. (2025) and density-operator-based Sannes et al. (2025) formalisms targeting electronically open molecules by combining standard electronic structure theory Helgaker et al. (2000) with open quantum system theory Breuer and Petruccione (2002) ; Nitzan (2006) ; May and Kühn (2023) ; Mukamel (1999) . Although our approaches are developed to allow molecules to be electronically open with respect to their environment, there is a direct connection to electron transfer theory. In the seminal Marcus electron transfer theory, Marcus (1956) the electron transfer rates are related to the electronic coupling elements between the donor and acceptor. Marcus and Sutin (1985) ; Hush (1961) ; Hush (1968) Central to the calculation of these electronic coupling elements is the Hamiltonian matrix element which couples two diabatic (or rather, quasi-diabatic) states. Subotnik et al. (2008) ; Blumberger (2015) ; Hsu and Marcus (1997) ; Kurnikov and Beratan (1996) In the so-called direct methods, these coupling elements are evaluated using states obtained by diabatization of the corresponding adiabatic states Pacher et al. (1988) ; Cave and Newton (1996) ; Cave and Newton (1997) ; Valeev et al. (2006) ; Biancardi et al. (2017) ; Biancardi and Caricato (2016) ; Biancardi and Caricato (2018) or computed directly, e.g., from constrained density functional theory. Wu and Van Voorhis (2006) ; Van Voorhis et al. (2010) ; Oberhofer and Blumberger (2010) ; Oberhofer and Blumberger (2009) ; de la Lande and Salahub (2010) The concepts used to develop the theory for electronically open molecules may similarly be used to calculate such coupling elements since the formalism is based on the construction of quasi-diabatic states for the molecule. Hence, for the application in electron transfer theory, one may construct quasi-diabatic states for the donor and the acceptor, rather than considering a molecule and the environment. This is discussed in more detail by Folkestad and Høyvik in Ref. 63 , where they present electronic coupling elements computed using charge-localized electronic states. The many-electron basis consisting of these charge-localized states enables the formal integration of electronic structure theory with

Read the complete text