Some Algebraic Properties of ASM Varieties
Ilani Axelrod-Freed, Hanson Hao, Matthew Kendall, Patricia Klein, Yuyuan Luo · 2025
Read Some Algebraic Properties of ASM Varieties by Ilani Axelrod-Freed, Hanson Hao, Matthew Kendall, Patricia Klein, Yuyuan Luo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-10480.txt.
Introduction
Ilani Axelrod-Freed and co-authors study the geometry of spaces built from alternating sign matrices, in a 2025 paper. Alternating sign matrices are grids of zeros, ones, and minus ones with row and column rules, long loved by combinatorialists. Intersecting classical matrix Schubert varieties produces a newer family, ASM varieties, whose basic properties are far harder to pin down than their parents'.
The paper focuses on two questions: how large these varieties are, and when they enjoy the Cohen-Macaulay property that makes their algebra well behaved. The key tool is studying how a pair of matrices and their direct sum relate. The authors also reinterpret ASM pattern avoidance geometrically. Their results narrow the gap between the tidy Schubert theory and these wilder intersections.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ilani Axelrod-Freed, Hanson Hao, Matthew Kendall, Patricia Klein, Yuyuan Luo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-10480
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Some Algebraic Properties of ASM Varieties Thanks: All authors were partially supported by RTG grant NSF grant DMS-1745638. PK was partially funded by NSF grant DMS-2246962 and by the Travel Support for Mathematicians gift MP-TSM-00002939 from the Simons Foundation. PK worked on this project while she was a member at the Institute for Advanced Study with support from the Bob Moses Fund. She also worked on this project while she was a long-term visitor at the Fields Institute. She thanks both the IAS and Fields for their hospitality and support. Ilani Axelrod-Freed, Hanson Hao, Matthew Kendall, Patricia Klein, Yuyuan Luo Abstract . Fulton’s matrix Schubert varieties are affine varieties that arise in the study of Schubert calculus in the complete flag variety. Weigandt showed that arbitrary intersections of matrix Schubert varieties, now called ASM varieties, are indexed by alternating sign matrices (ASMs), objects with a long history in enumerative combinatorics. It is very difficult to assess Cohen–Macaulayness of ASM varieties or to compute their codimension, though these properties are well understood for matrix Schubert varieties due to work Fulton. In this paper we study these properties of ASM varieties with a focus on the relationship between a pair of ASMs and their direct sum. We also consider ASM pattern avoidance from an algebro-geometric perspective. 1. Introduction Much of modern Schubert calculus centers on Schubert varieties in the complete flag variety. These Schubert varieties are closely related to affine varieties called matrix Schubert varieties, introduced by Fulton [ Ful92 ] . Specifically, Schubert polynomials, introduced by Lascoux and Schützenberger [ LS82 ] , form an additive basis of the cohomology ring of the complete flag variety. Expanding products of Schubert polynomials in this basis is arguably the major open problem in Schubert calculus today. Knutson and Miller [ KM05 ] showed that Schubert polynomials are also the multidegrees of matrix Schubert varieties. Moreover, a Schubert variety and its associated matrix Schubert variety share a codimension [ Ful92 ] ; the Cohen–Macaulay property of all Schubert varieties can be inferred from the Cohen–Macaulay property of all matrix Schubert varieties [ Ful92 , KM05 ] ; a Schubert variety is Gorenstein if and only if its associated matrix Schubert variety is [ WY06 ] . In the course of studying matrix Schubert varieties, one is naturally led to study intersections of several of them, for example as they arise in Gröbner degenerations and in inductive computations [ KW ] . Weigandt [ Wei17 ] showed that arbitrary intersections of matrix Schubert varieties are indexed by what are called alternating sign matrices (ASMs), a generalization of permutation matrices. Permutation matrices index Schubert varieties and matrix Schubert varieties. ASMs were not invented in order to perform this indexing. Rather, they are combinatorial objects with their own rich history: In 1983, Mills, Robbins, and Rumsey [ MRR83 ] gave a conjecture for a closed form for the number of n\times n ASMs. The original proof was given by Zeilberger [ Zei96 ] , and a second proof was given by Kuperberg [ Kup96 ] using the six-vertex model of statistical mechanics. Matrix Schubert varieties are Cohen–Macaulay and admit a codimension formula which can be read easily from their indexing permutation [ Ful92 ] . These facts are regularly exploited in studying the Schubert and Grothendieck polynomials of their associated permutations and in recent computations of Castelnuovo–Mumford regularity (see, e.g., [ RRR+21 , PSW24 ] ). ASM varieties do not in general enjoy either of these advantages. The purpose of this paper is to study the codimension and potential Cohen–Macaulayness of ASM varieties. Let X_{A} denote the ASM variety associated to A . We focus on the embeddings \asm(n)\hookrightarrow\asm(n+1) determined by A\mapsto 1\oplus A and, more generally, on ASMs obtained as direct sums of other ASMs. This embedding is natural in light of the role its restruction to S_{n} plays in the theory of Stanley symmetric functions ( [ Sta84 , Mac91 ] ). Let X_{A} denote the ASM variety determined by the ASM A . We show the following: Theorem 1.1 ( Theorem 3.19 ) . (1) \codim(X_{A_{1}\oplus A_{2}})=\codim(X_{A_{1}})+\codim(X_{A_{2}}) . (2) X_{A_{1}\oplus A_{2}} is equidimensional if and only if X_{A_{1}} and X_{A_{2}} are both equidimensional. We conjecture that (2) holds if equidimensional is replaced with Cohen–Macaulay ( Conjecture 3.15 ). We prove one direction of the conjuncture and provide empirical evidence for the other ( Theorem 3.19 ). We give examples to show that the method used by Knutson and Miller [ KM05 ] to show that matrix Schubert varieties are Cohen–Macaulay, recovering a result of Fulton [ Ful92 ] , does not extend to the Cohen–Macaulay ASMs ( Example 3.6 and Figure 1 ). We also give data suggesting that the property of being Cohen–Macaulay becomes increasingly rare as the size of the ASM grows ( Figure 2 ). These data motivate the study of ASM pattern avoidance from an algebro-geometric perspective. We argue that the naive notion of pattern avoidance does not explain the eventual rarity of Cohen–Macaulay ASMs ( Example 4.2 and Proposition 4.3 ) but that there is still some algebro-geometric control enforced by this notion ( Proposition 4.6 ). We hope that this will provide context for future studies of pattern avoidance of ASMs from an algebro-geometric perspective. 2. Background Throughout this document, \kappa will denote an arbitrary field. For k\leq n\in\mathbb{Z}_{+} , let [n]=\{1,2,\ldots,n\} and [k,n]=\{k,k+1,\ldots,n\} . Let S_{n} denote the symmetric group on [n] . We identify w\in S_{n} with the n\times n permutation matrix with 1 s in positions (i,w(i)) , i\in[n] , and 0 s elsewhere. Definition 2.1 . An alternating sign matrix (ASM) is square matrix with the following properties: (1) Each entry is taken from the set \{-1,0,1\} . (2) The entries in each row (resp. column) sum to 1. (3) The nonzero entries in a row (resp. column) alternate between 1 and -1 . Let \asm(n) denote the set of n\times n ASMs. The ASMs whose entries all lie in \{0,1\} are exactly the permutation matrices. For A\in\asm(n) , note that the sum of entries along each row (resp. column) is 1 and that the sum of all entries of A is n . 2.1. ASM varieties and ideals We now outline the process for associating a variety and an ideal to an alternating sign matrix. Fix A=(A_{a,b})\in\asm(n) . Define a rank function \rk_{A} on [n]\times[n] by \rk_{A}(i,j)=\sum_{a=1}^{i}\sum_{b=1}^{j}A_{a,b}. The rank matrix of A is the n\times n matrix whose (i,j) entry is \rk_{A}(i,j) . (Note that \rk_{A}(i,j) is typically not the rank of the submatrix of A consisting of the first i rows and first j columns, unless A\in S_{n} .) THroughout this paper, we will let Z=(z_{i,j}) denote an n\times n generic matrix, i.e., a matrix of distinct variables, and we will let R denote the polynomial ring over \kappa in the entries of Z . For i,j\in[n] , let Z_{[i],[j]} be the submatrix of Z consisting of the first i rows and j columns. For k\in\mathbb{Z}_{+} , let I_{k}(Z_{[i],[j]}) denote the ideal of R generated by the k\times k minors of Z_{[i],[j]} . Definition 2.2 . For A\in\asm(n) , let I_{A}=\sum_{(i,j)\in[n]\times[n]}I_{\rk_{A}(i,j)+1}(Z_{[i],[j]}). We call I_{A} the ASM ideal of A . Let X_{A}