Density perturbations in nonminimally coupled gravity: symptoms of Lagrangian density ambiguity

Miguel Barroso Varela, Orfeu Bertolami · 2025

Read Density perturbations in nonminimally coupled gravity: symptoms of Lagrangian density ambiguity by Miguel Barroso Varela, Orfeu Bertolami (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-10291.txt.

Introduction

Miguel Barroso Varela and Orfeu Bertolami wrote this cosmology paper, published in 2025. It shows that a quiet bookkeeping choice in a modified gravity theory, how to write the matter term in the action, changes how cosmic structure grows.

The theory couples matter directly to curvature, and for a perfect fluid two writings of the matter term compete. The authors compare their effects on the effective strength of gravity as density ripples evolve. One choice, reviewed under a simplifying approximation, can drive that strength to a wild divergence in late-time models. Full equations avoid the blow-up but squeeze the allowed size of modifications hard. The other choice dodges both problems at late times, because ordinary matter then has almost no pressure. Predictions follow for sample models, sharpening how such theories can be tested.

Catalog record

CREATORMiguel Barroso Varela, Orfeu Bertolami
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-10291

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Density perturbations in nonminimally coupled gravity: symptoms of Lagrangian density ambiguity Miguel Barroso Varela, Orfeu Bertolami Abstract The evolution of density perturbations is analysed in a modified theory of gravity with a nonminimal coupling between curvature and matter. We consider the broken degeneracy between the choices of matter Lagrangian for a perfect fluid, ℒ m = − ρ \mathcal{L}_{m}=-\rho and ℒ m = p \mathcal{L}_{m}=p , and determine the differences between their effects on the effective gravitational constant. We review the result for ℒ m = − ρ \mathcal{L}_{m}=-\rho in the quasistatic approximation and show how it can lead to unphysical singular behaviour for late-time dominating models. This divergent regime can be avoided when considering the fully non-quasistatic perturbative equations, although the higher-order nature of the nonminimally coupled theory and the requirement of a physically viable effective gravitational constant strongly constrains the magnitude of these modifications to the action. We find that both of these issues can be removed when considering ℒ m = p \mathcal{L}_{m}=p at late times due to the pressureless nature of non-relativistic matter and provide predictions for inverse power-law models. 1 Introduction The emergence of precision cosmology has provided evidence for some of the most recent paradigm shifts in modern physics. Abnormal galaxy rotation curves pushed for the need of dark matter Bertone et al. (2005) ; Oks (2021) , while the observed accelerated expansion of the Universe brought the need for dark energy Riess and others (1998) . Although many of the detected effects are accounted for by the standard model of cosmology ( \Lambda CDM), this long-standing belief is now critically endangered by the ever-growing quality and quantity of cosmological data. Efforts from collaborations such as the Dark Energy Survey (DES) Abbott and others (2024) ; Camilleri and others (2024) and the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) Adame and others (2025) ; Rebouças et al. (2024) have consistently tightened the constraints on the late-time properties of the Universe’s expansion. Indeed, the latest data release from DESI indicates that the present accelerated expansion may be driven by evolving dark energy, which directly contradicts the cosmological constant included in \Lambda CDM at around (1.7-3.3)\sigma depending on the supernovae data that is paired with BAO Abdul Karim and others (2025) . Although this conclusion is not yet statistically significant enough to securely indicate a new discovery, the possibility of such a paradigmatic turn has further motivated research into alternatives to the current standard model. Modifications of \Lambda CDM typically alter the matter content of the Universe, the underlying gravitational theory or a combination of both. In terms of the former, some examples include considering massive neutrinos Rebouças et al. (2024) , axions Rogers et al. (2023) , a quintessence field with a Higgs portal Bertolami and Rosenfeld (2008) and the generalised Chaplygin gas Bilić et al. (2002) ; Kamenshchik et al. (2000) ; Bento et al. (2002) , among many others. More importantly for what concerns this work, modifications of General Relativity (GR) have been thoroughly researched in the literature as solutions to the present cosmological tensions and possible alternatives to explain dark energy and dark matter. These include f(R) Odintsov et al. (2021) ; Wang (2021) ; D’Agostino and Nunes (2020) , f(T) Hashim et al. (2021a) ; Hashim et al. (2021b) and f(Q) gravity Mandal et al. (2020) , along with nonminimally coupled matter-curvature models Barroso Varela and Bertolami (2024) ; Barroso Varela and Bertolami (2025b) . Although the main focus of the alternative models is to provide theoretical explanations of background quantities such as the expansion rate, most of these models also imply modified predictions for the dynamics at perturbation level, which affect cosmological aspects such as the formation of large scale structure. In fact, at this scale there is also uncertainty in the community, as measurements of the clustering of structures in the Universe by early and late methods give rise to the \sigma_{8} tension Abdalla and others (2022) ; Poulin et al. (2023) . This is yet another putative shortcoming of \Lambda CDM, again leaving space for modified theories of gravity to patch this observational incoherence. It is therefore as crucial for any theory’s ambition to explain the background as it is for it to explain the perturbative dynamics of the Universe. In this work, we analyse the late-time evolution of cosmological density perturbations in a modified theory of gravity with a nonminimal coupling (NMC) between matter and curvature and their implications on the viability of late-time dominating versions of the theory, as well as what this imposes as constraints on the choice of perfect fluid Lagrangian density. The nonminimally coupled f(R) model was originally considered in Ref. Bertolami et al. (2007) in the context of introducing an extra force that provided an alternative explanation to the effects of dark matter on galaxy rotation curves. However, it is important to note that non-linear couplings of matter with gravity had previously been analysed in the context of cosmic acceleration and the cosmological constant problem Dolgov and Kawasaki (2003c) ; Dolgov and Kawasaki (2003b) ; Nojiri and Odintsov (2004b) ; Nojiri and Odintsov (2004a) ; Allemandi et al. (2005) . Since the proposal of the NMC f(R) theory, several extensions of these functional nonminimal couplings have emerged, such as f(R,\mathcal{L}_{m}) Harko et al. (2025) , f(R,T) Harko et al. (2011) and f(R,T^{\mu\nu}T_{\mu\nu}) Roshan and Shojai (2016) theories of gravity. The present work builds on the research conducted in Refs. Nesseris (2009) ; Bertolami et al. (2013) in the context of the NMC f(R) model Bertolami et al. (2007) , where the dynamics of density perturbations were analysed on sub-Hubble scales by assuming a quasistatic approximation and choosing the perfect fluid Lagrangian \mathcal{L}_{m}=-\rho . The NMC f(R) theory has also been extensively researched in the context of reproducing the late-time acceleration of the Universe Bertolami et al. (2010) , mimicking the dark matter profile observed in galaxy rotation curves Bertolami et al. (2012) ; Bertolami and Páramos (2010) , fitting the latest low-redshift background data Barroso Varela and Bertolami (2025b) , proposing a solution to the open Hubble tension Barroso Varela and Bertolami (2024) and modifying the propagation of gravitational waves Bertolami et al. (2018) ; Barroso Varela and Bertolami (2025a) . Throughout this work, we consider a background Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson–Walker (FLRW) metric in comoving coordinates ds^{2}=a^{2}(\eta)(-d\eta^{2}+dx^{2}+dy^{2}+dz^{2}), (1) where the conformal time \eta is related to cosmic time through dt=a(\eta)d\eta . We denote derivatives with respect to \eta with primes, derivatives with respect to t with dots and define the comoving Hubble parameter \mathcal{H}=aH=a^{\prime}/a , keeping H=\dot{a}/a . For simplicity, we perturb the background metric as g_{\mu\nu}=\bar{g}_{\mu\nu}+a^{2}(\eta)h_{\mu\nu}=a^{2}(\eta)(\eta_{\mu\nu}+h_{\mu\nu}) , where we have denoted the unperturbed metric with a bar, although this notation will be dropped when the distinction is clear, as in the case where a quantity is already multiplied by a first-order perturbation. We focus our analysis on the scalar sector of perturbations, which we choose to fix in the Newtonian gauge such that the total line element reads \displaystyle ds^{2}=a^{2}(\eta) \displaystyle\big[\left.-(1+2\Phi)d\eta^{2}+(1-2\Psi)\delta_{ij}dx^{i}dx^{j}\big]\right., (2) which aligns with the typically chosen convention in the literature. This gauge choice has the added benefit of providing a clear analogy to the Newtonian limit of GR, where \Psi and \Phi act

Read the complete text