Monotone three-dimensional surface and equivalent formulations of the generalized bathtub model
Wen-Long Jin, Irene Martinez · 2025
Read Monotone three-dimensional surface and equivalent formulations of the generalized bathtub model by Wen-Long Jin, Irene Martinez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-10014.txt.
Introduction
Wen-Long Jin and Irene Martinez study city-wide traffic congestion through the bathtub model, in this 2025 paper. The model treats a road network like a tub, where the outflow of trips depends on how many trips are inside. Unlike single-road models, it breaks the first-in-first-out rule, which makes its math hard to picture.
The authors order trips by a combined distance measure and build a rising three-dimensional surface from the counts. From that surface they derive matching forms of the model in other coordinates, covering older special cases. They also show computing methods and discuss use in pricing and planning.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wen-Long Jin, Irene Martinez |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-10014
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Monotone three-dimensional surface and equivalent formulations of the generalized bathtub model Wen-Long Jin, Irene Martinez Abstract In the Lighthill-Whitham-Richards (LWR) model for single-lane traffic, vehicle trajectories follow the first-in-first-out (FIFO) principle and can be represented by a monotone three-dimensional surface of cumulative vehicle count. In contrast, the generalized bathtub model, which describes congestion dynamics in transportation networks using relative space, typically violates the FIFO principle, making its representation more challenging. Building on the characteristic distance ordering concept, we observe that trips in the generalized bathtub model can be ordered by their characteristic distances (remaining trip distance plus network travel distance). We define a new cumulative number of trips ahead of a trip with a given remaining distance at a time instant, showing it forms a monotone three-dimensional surface despite FIFO violations. Using the inverse function theorem, we derive equivalent formulations with different coordinates and dependent variables, including special cases for Vickrey’s bathtub model and the basic bathtub model. We demonstrate numerical methods based on these formulations and discuss trip-based approaches for discrete demand patterns. This study enhances understanding of the generalized bathtub model’s properties, facilitating its application in network traffic flow modeling, congestion pricing, and transportation planning. Keywords : Generalized bathtub model; Relative space; Monotone three-dimensional traffic surface; Inverse function theorem; Equivalent formulations. 1 Introduction Describing how vehicles and trips move in a road network is essential for urban traffic management and planning ( Cascetta,, 2009 ) . In the celebrated Lighthill-Whitham-Richards (LWR) model ( Lighthill and Whitham,, 1955 ; Richards,, 1956 ) for a single-lane road, vehicle trajectories are described in the traditional absolute space with respect to the traveling distances on a road, as shown in Figure 1 (a), where three trips (solid red, dashed blue, and dotted green) start from different origins, end at different destinations, and use different routes. The LWR model can be represented by a three-dimensional surface in terms of the cumulative number of vehicles passing a location by a time instant ( Makigami et al.,, 1971 ) . In this model, vehicles follow the first-in-first-out (FIFO) principle and are ordered by the car-following rule. As a result, the corresponding three-dimensional surface is monotone: increasing in time and decreasing in space. Then, from the inverse function theorem, one can derive equivalent formulations in flow, trajectory, and schedule coordinates ( Leclercq et al.,, 2007 ; Laval and Leclercq,, 2013 ) , which form the basis for developing more sophisticated models for human-driven and automated vehicles and managing traffic flow on a road segment ( Jin,, 2016 ) . Figure 1 : Illustration of trips in different spaces: (a) Absolute space within a grid network; (b) Relative space based on remaining distances to individual trip destinations The LWR model has been extended to describe traffic dynamics in a road network via the Cell Transmission Model ( Daganzo,, 1995 ; Lebacque,, 1996 ) and the Link Transmission Model ( Yperman et al.,, 2006 ) . Incorporating merging and diverging rules, they are systems of partial or delay differential equations ( Jin,, 2017 ; Jin,, 2015 ) , respectively. Therefore, the calibration, computation, and analysis of these models are costly. In the past decades, a new approach emerged by viewing the whole network as a single reservoir or bathtub ( Vickrey,, 1991 ; Vickrey,, 2020 ; Small and Chu,, 2003 ; Daganzo,, 2007 ; Arnott et al.,, 2016 ; Jin,, 2020 ) . A key idea is to describe all trips’ trajectories in the unified relative space with respect to their remaining distances, as illustrated in Figure 1 (b), where the three trajectories (solid red, dashed blue, and dotted green) correspond to those in Figure 1 (a). Comparing the two presentations of the trips in two spaces, we can see that the absolute space tracks the origins, destinations, and routes of individual trips, but cannot easily describe the traveling speeds. In constrast, the relative space ignores the exact locations of the origins, destinations, and routes, but tracks the entering times, the exiting times, and the remaining distances to the destinations of individual trips, from which we can derive the traveling speeds at specific times. In the two representations, the trip lengths should be consistent with each other, but all other information is complementary. In particular, the relative space offers a unified approach to describing traveling speeds of individual vehicles and congestion dynamics in a road network. Therefore, the bathtub models have been applied to study departure time choice and design network-wide or cordon congestion pricing, traffic control, and other management and planning schemes ( Vickrey,, 2020 ; Geroliminis et al.,, 2013 ; Jin et al.,, 2021 ; Balzer et al.,, 2023 ; Martínez and Jin, 2024a, ) . Refer to ( Johari et al.,, 2021 ) for a comprehensive review of such models and their applications. In particular, assuming that all trips share the same travel speed and that the speed is given by a network fundamental diagram ( Godfrey,, 1969 ; Geroliminis and Daganzo,, 2008 ) , ( Jin,, 2020 ; Jin,, 2021 ) derived a generalized bathtub model for travel demands given by general distributions of trips’ entering times and distances. This is a nonlocal partial differential equation in the cumulative number of trips at a time instant with a remaining distance not smaller than a value. It was shown that Vickrey’s bathtub model ( Vickrey,, 1991 ; Vickrey,, 2020 ; Small and Chu,, 2003 ; Daganzo,, 2007 ) is a special case of the generalized bathtub model with a time-independent negative exponential distribution of trip distances; and that the basic bathtub model ( Arnott et al.,, 2016 ; Arnott and Buli,, 2018 ) is a special case where all trips have the same distance. However, different from the LWR model, the generalized bathtub usually violates the FIFO principle, and the three-dimensional surface in the cumulative number of trips at a time instant with a remaining distance not smaller than a value is not monotone in time. Thus, one cannot obtain similar equivalent formulations as those for the LWR model with the inverse function theorem. Inspired by the monotone three-dimensional surface representation of the LWR model, and recognizing the many potential applications of the generalized bathtub model in network traffic flow modeling and control, in this article we aim to develop an analogous monotone three-dimensional surface and equivalent formulations for the generalized bathtub model despite its violation of the FIFO principle. First, building on the previously established characteristic distance ordering from ( Jin,, 2020 ) , we observe that, in the generalized bathtub model, trips in a network can be ordered with respect to their characteristic distances, which equal the remaining trip distances plus the network travel distances. Thus, we refer to those with smaller characteristic distances as being ahead of others. Even though the cumulative number of trips passing a location by a time instant on a virtual road was defined for the basic bathtub model in ( Jin,, 2020 ) , the FIFO principle is satisfied in this case, and the variable is the same as that for the LWR model ( Makigami et al.,, 1971 ) . In this study, we then define a cumulative number of trips ahead of a trip with