Experimental demonstration of an analogy between optical non-coherence and irreversibility of heat transport
Aleksandr Meilakhs, Claudio Pastorino, Miguel Larotonda · 2025
Read Experimental demonstration of an analogy between optical non-coherence and irreversibility of heat transport by Aleksandr Meilakhs, Claudio Pastorino, Miguel Larotonda (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-09522.txt.
Introduction
Aleksandr Meilakhs, Claudio Pastorino, and Miguel Larotonda present a 2025 physics paper demonstrating, in an optics bench, why heat flows one way. Heat crossing the boundary between two materials never runs backward, a small-scale face of the arrow of time. The authors trace that one-way behavior to a loss of coherence at the interface.
The paper's own head gives the title as Irreversibility of heat transport and optical non-coherence. Waves crossing a boundary arrive with a spread of frequencies, since no real wave is perfectly pure. That spread turns tidy reversible transmission math into one-way distribution rules. The team built an optical setup whose behavior mirrors the mechanism, chose its settings from the theory, and ran it. Results matched predictions in full. They argue no other mechanism explains the boundary effect.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aleksandr Meilakhs, Claudio Pastorino, Miguel Larotonda |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-09522
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Experimental demonstration of an analogy between optical non-coherence and irreversibility of heat transport Aleksandr Meilakhs, Claudio Pastorino, Miguel Larotonda Abstract We probe experimentally a connection between coherence in the context of optical physics and the irreversibility present in heat transfer through an interface separating two media. The robustness of the experiment on the one hand, and the theoretical description taken from the statistical-mechanics treatment of the heat transfer problem, on the other hand allows for the study of the arrow of time’s problem within the clean and precise framework of experimental optical physics. The central aspect of the experiment is a light beam incident and split at an interface to produce a second common interaction point again at the interface. The experiment was carried out with two light sources that only differ in their coherence length. In the case of the highly coherent light source, we were able to combine the previously split parts of the light back into a single beam. This is indicative of the reversibility of the process of coherent light transmission through the interface. The light source with low coherence length, on the contrary, does not allow for such a recombination, thus producing an irreversible process. We explain how the latter case is analogous to the process of interfacial heat transport, thus establishing an important connection between optical non-coherence and irreversibility of transport phenomena. Our finding paves the way for the study of fundamental processes in heat transfer and the surge of irreversibility in the realm of optical physics. I Introduction One of the most intriguing problems in modern physics is the irreversibility of macroscopic processes. As it was first noticed in the context of thermodynamics, the transport of heat from a hot body to a cold one is gives rise to entropy production. Since entropy can only grow and never decrease such processes are irreversible Landau1994 ; Kondepudi2015 . Later, it was found that the Boltzmann equation, along with other kinetic equations governing the behavior of large ensembles of particles are irreversible Landau2013 . Thismarks a drastic contrast with the equations describing individual particles, whether in classical or quantum framework. The most widespread approach for the derivation of the Boltzmann equation from classical mechanics is the so-called BBGKY hierarchy Harris2004 . A serious drawback of this method is the postulate of molecular chaos, as a model for the two-particle distribution function, whose fundamentals are not properly explained. Another approach to explain entropy growth postulates an initial low entropy state for every process. Equivalently it postulates low-entropy initial states of the universe CARROLL2005 ; Wald2006 , which is an ad hoc hypothesis Cohen1960 and hence, not completely satisfactory. Some authors Maccone2009 propose modifications of the physical laws, to explicitly incorporate irreversibility. Most modern approaches propose the emergence of irreversibility from a time-asymmetric process, which is an inherent feature of quantum physics Ghirardi1986 . The most studied of such mechanisms is decoherence Schulman1997 ; Joos2003 . However, serious intrinsic difficulties are present in the decoherence theory Adler2003 . In one of our previous works meilakhs2024transmission , the problem of irreversibility of heat transport through an interface between two media was addressed. It is known that a temperature jump occurs at the interface when heat flows through two different media. The proportionality coefficient between the heat flux and the temperature jump is usually called the Kapitza resistance. Currently, the Kapitza resistance has become a wide area of research, not only for its theoretical interest, but also for its technological relevance in a wide variety of thermal management applications. Some works investigate the dynamics of the crystal lattice at the interface through computer simulations Saeaeskilahti2014 ; Yang2015 ; Bi2016 ; Alkurdi2017 ; Kakodkar2017 ; Huang2018 , while there is also a great number of works with analytical approaches Young1989 ; Zhang2011 ; Meilakhs2016 . Other studies deal with phonon kinetics at the interface with Boltzmann theory Majumdar2004 ; Merabia2012 ; Alaili2019 ; Varnavides2019 or the nonequilibrium Green’s function method Tian2012 ; Wang2007 ; Wang2008 . Measurements of values of Kapitza resistance for different pairs of materials were also performed Costescu2003 ; Ye2017 . Additionally, the problem of Kapitza resistance was studied in a broader context than phonon transport, such as electron transport between semiconductors Meilakhs2023 and molecular transport at a liquid-vapor interface Pastorino2022 . After the discovery of the Kapitza resistance, it was very soon realized that the temperature jump is due to the reflection of phonons at the interface Khal . Since phonon reflection at a solid-solid interface is a linear process, the Kapitza resistance effect can be used as a testbed to shed light on the mechanism that leads to irreversibility. In contrast with the time-dependent and highly non-linear Boltzmann equation, its analog at the interface between two materials, the matching equation for the distribution functions, Meilakhs2015 ; Meilakhs2021 is linear and static. In Ref. meilakhs2024transmission the interfacial phenomenom of Kapitza resistance was related to the concept of non-coherence. It was suggested that if particles incident on the interface from different sides are phase-correlated (coherent regime) then their transmission through the interface occurs reversibly. On the contrary, if there is no phase correlation between particles at both sides of the interface (non-coherent regime), which is the naturally occurring situation, the transmission becomes irreversible. In that work, an optical experiment was proposed to clearly establish this connection between non-coherence and ireversibility. In the present manuscript we perform the suggested experiment and we empirically show the validity of this connection and the prediction of the theory meilakhs2024transmission . The time irreversibility shown by non-coherent transmission through an interface is put to test with photons incident on an interface between two media and a two-mirror arrangement, in a conceptually simple optical experiment that implements a Mach-Zehnder interferometer hariharan2010basics ; soler1997multiple ; prikhodko2024effects : an input light beam is split into two according to the Fresnel reflection and refraction coefficients of an air-glass interface. Different outcomes arise from the interaction of these two light beams at the same interface, determined by the coherence properties of the initial beam. With a highly coherent input beam, complete recombination into a single output beam can be achieved. In contrast, if a non-coherent source is used, a constant fraction of the light is transmitted and reflected at the interface, respectively, regardless of the prior evolution of the interacting beams 1 1 1 We refer to light sources as highly coherent and non-coherent when their coherence lengths are much longer and much shorter, respectively, than the optical path difference between the two interacting beams born2013principles . . In section II we present the theoretical framework within the context of light transport, an ideal experiment and a feasible experimental realization. In section III , the experimental setup is described in detail. Finally, we devote section IV to present the results and a final discussion is provided in section V . II Theory II.1 Preambula We studied the light transport through an interface of two materials under two different coherence conditions of the input field, as sketched in Fig. 1 . A light beam is split at a partially reflecting interface S . The reflected part of the light travels through one of the optical media and bounces