Positioning Monocular Optical See Through Head Worn Displays in Glasses for Everyday Wear
Parth Arora, Ethan Kimmel, Katherine Huang, Tyler Kwok, Yukun Song, Sofia Vempala, Georgianna Lin, Ozan Cakmakci, Thad Starner · 2025
Read Positioning Monocular Optical See Through Head Worn Displays in Glasses for Everyday Wear by Parth Arora, Ethan Kimmel, Katherine Huang, Tyler Kwok, Yukun Song, Sofia Vempala, Georgianna Lin, Ozan Cakmakci, Thad Starner (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-09047.txt.
Introduction
Parth Arora and co-authors advise where to place a small display inside smart glasses in a 2025 paper. Waveguide lenses now make everyday glasses with a see through screen feasible, but the image can sit center gaze, where it interrupts, or off to the side.
Pooling recent studies on one eye displays, the team weigh interruption, comfort, task speed, and how odd wearers look to others. For text tasks they suggest a modest field of view in the right lens, level in height but shifted earward. Glanceable bits can sit farther out for short checks. The guide balances use against social ease.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Parth Arora, Ethan Kimmel, Katherine Huang, Tyler Kwok, Yukun Song, Sofia Vempala, Georgianna Lin, Ozan Cakmakci, Thad Starner |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-09047
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Positioning Monocular Optical See Through Head Worn Displays in Glasses for Everyday Wear Parth Arora, Ethan Kimmel, Katherine Huang, Tyler Kwok, Yukun Song, Sofia Vempala, Georgianna Lin, Ozan Cakmakci, Thad Starner Abstract Head-worn displays for everyday wear in the form of regular eyeglasses are technically feasible with recent advances in waveguide technology. One major design decision is determining where in the user’s visual field to position the display. Centering the display in the principal point of gaze (PPOG) allows the user to switch attentional focus between the virtual and real images quickly, and best performance often occurs when the display is centered in PPOG or is centered vertically below PPOG. However, these positions are often undesirable in that they are considered interruptive or are associated with negative social perceptions by users. Offsetting the virtual image may be preferred when tasks involve driving, walking, or social interaction. This paper consolidates findings from recent studies on monocular optical see-through HWDs (OST-HWDs), focusing on potential for interruption, comfort, performance, and social perception. For text-based tasks, which serve as a proxy for many monocular OST-HWD tasks, we recommend a 15° horizontal field of view (FOV) with the virtual image in the right lens vertically centered but offset to +8.7° to +23.7° toward the ear. Glanceable content can be offset up to +30° for short interactions. K eywords Head Worn Displays \cdot Augmented Reality \cdot Wearable Computing \cdot Smart Glasses \cdot Heads Up Displays \cdot Head Mounted Displays 1 Introduction Head-worn displays (HWDs) [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] are wearable virtual displays integrated into eyeglasses or head mounts that present data directly within the user’s visual field [ 5 ] . They encompass a diverse range of devices, from bulky headsets like the Magic Leap [ 6 ] , HoloLens [ 7 ] , and Apple Vision Pro [ 8 ] to glasses-like devices such as Meta Orion [ 9 ] and Snap Spectacles [ 10 ] , which resemble regular eyewear although still bulkier than standard glasses. They also include devices like Google Glass, launched over a decade ago, which introduced mainstream consumer monocular optical see-through head-worn displays. These devices, often referred to as peripheral HWDs [ 11 ] , feature a see-through display positioned in front of one eye. They can present a wide range of information, including video footage, text notifications [ 12 ] , micro-interactions [ 13 , 14 , 15 ] , and contextually relevant suggestions from intelligent agents [ 16 , 17 ] . Recent advancements in waveguide technologies have spurred a resurgence of these devices. This growth has sparked interest in exploring how HWDs can seamlessly integrate into daily activities [ 18 ] . Smaller companies, such as Vuzix with the Z100 (Figure 1 ) and Even Realities with the G1, introduced lightweight HWDs for everyday wear weighing less than 40g in 2024 [ 19 , 20 ] , demonstrating the technical feasibility of these devices and paving the way for more products to be introduced in 2025. Figure 1: Google Glass in 2014 and Vuzix Z100 in 2024. Designing HWDs involves balancing a complex set of parameters within the constraints of manufacturing resources [ 21 , 22 ] . One critical design decision is determining where the HWD’s virtual image should appear in the user’s visual field. Virtual image position affects eye movement during use, as some positions are more comfortable than others due to eye motor functions and habitual behavior [ 23 ] . Gaze shifts extending over 25^{\circ} tend to involve both head motion and eye movement [ 24 , 25 , 26 ] , as opposed to just eye movement. Eyes prefer to stay within a comfortable range (approximately 15 degrees left and right of center) relative to the head [ 21 ] . Hence, there is a range of eye motion beyond which it may become uncomfortable to consume content. Positioning the content in a central position would make sense intuitively. It also allows the user to switch attentional focus between the virtual and real images quickly. However, positioning the display at the center of the user’s visual field can sometimes be interruptive. Such disruption is particularly true when content is displayed without being explicitly triggered, such as notifications or proactive AI suggestions. Research on head-up displays (HUDs) in aviation has identified a phenomenon called cognitive capture. In this condition, users focus on virtual information rather than the physical world, and their attention is tunneled into the virtual realm [ 27 ] . Studies on HUD use while driving or walking have examined how interruptions, such as sudden notifications or system errors, can be uncomfortable for users. Shifting the display from the user’s point of gaze (PPOG) can reduce the likelihood of cognitive capture and interruptions [ 28 , 27 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 ] . Hence, positioning the image too centrally to the PPOG could be interruptive for a device designed for all day wear. Another effect that could cause discomfort in monocular HWDs is binocular rivalry , a phenomenon that occurs when each eye is presented with a different image [ 34 , 4 , 35 , 36 ] . When the brain receives conflicting signals from both eyes, dominance alternates between the two, leading to an unstable visual state. For a period, one eye’s image suppresses the other before the roles reverse. This continuous alternation can cause visual confusion. Laboratory studies have shown that high binocular rivalry conditions significantly reduce the efficiency of participants when quickly referring to lists of text at the PPOG [ 37 ] . However, the common use of Google Glass (2012-2023) in users’ everyday lives suggests that the effect may not be as worrisome as expected, at least when the image is above the user’s PPOG. Furthermore, laboratory studies with Glass showed that the difference in efficiency between transparent and opaque versions of the display was small (-3%), which also supports the hypothesis that binocular rivalry is less of a concern if the display is outside of PPOG [ 38 ] . Furthermore, Hershberger and Guerin’s research showed that placing displays below the PPOG significantly reduced binocular rivalry [ 39 ] , and Peli and Hakkinen recommend positioning displays outside the user’s direct line of sight [ 40 , 41 ] , Additional factors, such as a user’s performance on tasks supported by HWDs, are influenced by display position. If content is too central, it may interfere with tasks by being constantly in the way. Conversely, if it is positioned too far away, accessing information can become slower and less comfortable. Social perception is another critical factor. For instance, if the wearer is constantly looking over a conversational partner’s head to read the display, the partner may have the impression that the wearer is less engaged with the conversation, much in the way that looking at one’s watch may unintentionally signal impatience to a conversational partner. Some software techniques can also improve user comfort. For example, Orlosky et al. [ 42 , 43 ] found that users prefer having text in passive backgrounds and positions not blocking the main action in the scene. Furthermore, using