Sensitivity of Trapping Efficiency and Relative Permeability to Experimental Methodology in Laboratory Core Flooding
Catherine Spurin, Catherine Callas, Takeshi Kurotori, Hamdi A. Tchelepi, Sally M. Benson · 2025
Read Sensitivity of Trapping Efficiency and Relative Permeability to Experimental Methodology in Laboratory Core Flooding by Catherine Spurin, Catherine Callas, Takeshi Kurotori, Hamdi A. Tchelepi, Sally M. Benson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-09044.txt.
Introduction
Catherine Spurin and four co-authors test, in 2025 work, how the way a lab test is run can skew what it says about storing carbon deep below ground. Teams flood rock cores to learn how much gas stays trapped and how freely fluids move. The standard test feeds gas and water in together, which keeps flow steady and trims edge effects.
The team ran that standard test against a single-fluid method on like terms. The two gave quite unlike trapping results and unlike pressure gaps across the core. That means the standard choice may hide real flow traits that matter in the field. Read with care, though, the gap could be turned to good use: field plans might trap more gas by design.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Catherine Spurin, Catherine Callas, Takeshi Kurotori, Hamdi A. Tchelepi, Sally M. Benson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-09044
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Sensitivity of Trapping Efficiency and Relative Permeability to Experimental Methodology in Laboratory Core Flooding Catherine Spurin, Catherine Callas, Takeshi Kurotori, Hamdi A. Tchelepi, Sally M. Benson Abstract Understanding the migration and trapping of CO 2 in the subsurface is vital to geologic carbon storage projects. Traditional characterization methods employ steady-state co-injection experiments to determine relative permeability and trapping efficiency. Although laboratory studies aim to replicate reservoir conditions, co-injection experiments are often selected because they facilitate steady-state flow and reduce capillary end effects. The fundamental influence of this experimental design choice on measured petrophysical parameters remains inadequately characterized. This study presents a comparative analysis between co-injection and single-phase injection experiments, specifically investigating how experimental methodology influences both trapping efficiency and pressure differential across the core sample (which is used to calculate relative permeability). Our results demonstrate significant variations in trapping behavior between these injection techniques, suggesting that the traditional focus on co-injection experiments may overlook important physical flow phenomena. Differences between injection techniques could be strategically exploited in field applications to enhance residual trapping capacity in subsurface CO 2 storage operations. This work highlights the importance of understanding experimental artifacts in core flooding studies and their potential applications for improving carbon storage efficiency. This manuscript is a pre-print and has not undergone peer review. We welcome any feedback. I Introduction The movement of multiple fluids through complex porous media is ubiquitous in nature and beyond. For example, the storage of CO 2 in porous subsurface rocks (geologic carbon sequestration) has been identified as a critical greenhouse gas mitigation technique Change et al. 2014 ; Bui et al. 2018 ; Benson et al. 2012 . Understanding the migration and trapping of CO 2 in subsurface reservoirs is vital to ensuring the safe, long-term storage of anthropogenic emissions Krevor et al. 2015 ; Krevor et al. 2011 ; Spurin et al. 2025 . Reservoir models are used to predict the propagation and trapping of CO 2 underground Ringrose et al. 2013 ; Bentham and Kirby 2005 ; Ampomah et al. 2016 . Key inputs for these models are relative permeability, capillary pressure, and trapping efficiency (the relationship between initial and residual CO 2 saturation) Kumar et al. 2005 ; Ajayi et al. 2019 . These properties are measured on core/centimeter-scale samples, and assumed to be representative of larger scale systems Spurin et al. 2025 ; Perrin and Benson 2010 . In fact, experiments are often conducted at high temperatures and pressures to be representative of reservoir conditions Krevor et al. 2016 ; Selem et al. 2021 ; Singh et al. 2018 ; Krevor et al. 2012 ; Kim et al. 2018 . These experiments are time consuming and expensive. While reservoir conditions are created in the core, typically steady-state experiments, with the co-injection of both phases, are conducted because saturation profiles are constant in time and capillary end effects are less prominent Pini and Benson 2017 ; Bertels et al. 2001 ; Avraam and Payatakes 1995 ; Berg et al. 2024 . Capillary end effects are defined as a strong saturation gradient caused by the non-wetting phase preferentially leaving the core and occupying the metallic end piece. Other methods to discount strong saturation gradients have included removing the end section from analysis Pini and Benson 2017 ; Perrin and Benson 2010 , correcting for end effects prior to analysis Archer and Wong 1973 ; Jackson et al. 2018 ; Krause and Benson 2015 ; Reynolds et al. 2018 , and adding a porous plate or other rock core in sequence to the rock of interest Honarpour and Mahmood 1988 ; Avraam and Payatakes 1995 ; Persoff and Pruess 1995 . Steady-state co-injection experiments have been shown to have different underlying pore scale dynamics than unsteady-state co-injection experiments, with the unsteady-state dynamics leading to more mobile CO 2 Spurin et al. 2020 . However, it is typical to do steady-state co-injection experiments, with resulting values applied uniformly across the entire plume, regardless of the differing dynamics that may be present. It is also assumed that the residual trapping measured in these experiments can be used to parameterize models for hysteresis in relative permeability and capillary pressure constitutive functions Krevor et al. 2015 . The difference between co-injection experiments, where both fluids are injected simultaneously, and single phase injection experiments, where a single fluid is injected, must be understood. While excluding the core’s end section from analysis can eliminate the saturation drop caused by capillary end effects, this approach fails to address how these effects influence pressure data used in relative permeability calculations, potentially resulting in inaccurate saturation-pressure relationships. Corrections for capillary end effects have been successfully applied to homogeneous sandstone samples, but they have failed to correct end effects in heterogeneous sandstone and carbonate samples Manoorkar et al. 2021 ; Wenck et al. 2021 . Thus, the link between heterogeneities and capillary discontinuities is still missing. A porous plate, or additional rock core can reduce end effects. But, as with cropping, it does not untangle the role of end effects in the pressure data, instead the properties of the other samples or the porous plate are now included. If the constraints of an experiment or the difference between different injection techniques is unknown, then utilizing the data at the field scale will lead to large uncertainties in plume migration and trapping. With single phase injection more likely to be employed in practical CO 2 storage operations, it is critical to quantify the impact of injection methods on fluid displacement dynamics and residual trapping behaviour. If significant time and effort are being invested into conducting core-scale experiments to understand flow dynamics at the field scale, it must be certain that the experiments are representative of what is occurring at the larger scale. In this work, the difference between co-injection and single phase injection experiments is presented. Experiments were conducted using two distinct fluid pairings—gas/water and oil/water—enabling an investigation of the differences between the conventional framework (originally developed for the oil industry) and the adaptations necessary for geologic carbon sequestration applications. II Materials and Methods II.1 Rocks Cylindrical Indiana limestone samples, 5 cm in diameter and 12 cm in length were used in this work. The same sample was used in all gas/water experiments, with the porosity along the core increasing slightly with distance along the core, as shown in Figure 1 (Indiana core 1). For the oil/water experiments, the same Indiana core was used for the co-injection experiment. A different Indiana core (Figure 1 Indiana core 2) was used for the single phase injection experiment. This was because removing oil from the system is time-consuming and difficult, and any remaining oil would affect the trapping efficiency reported in this work. Indiana is a heterogeneous limestone with a bimodal porosity distribution; the heterogeneities manifest at the millimeter scale, which is below the resolution of the images acquired in this work Manoorkar et al. 2021 . Figure 1 : Porosity profile for the Indiana samples used in this work. Indiana core 1 was used for the gas experiments, and the oil co-injection experiment. Indiana core 2 was used for the oil single phase injection experiment. II.2 Fluids, Interfacial Tension and Viscosity Two fluid pairings were used in