Agency Problems and Adversarial Bilevel Optimization under Uncertainty and Cyber Threats
Thibaut MASTROLIA, Haoze YAN · 2025
Read Agency Problems and Adversarial Bilevel Optimization under Uncertainty and Cyber Threats by Thibaut MASTROLIA, Haoze YAN (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08989.txt.
Introduction
Thibaut Mastrolia and Haoze Yan model, in a 2025 paper, how a parent firm should pay a subsidiary to guard a risky project against accidents and hackers. The setup is an agency problem: the leader designs incentives, and the follower picks effort and cyber defenses in reply. Both face deep uncertainty about swings in value and about attacks. The pair frame it as a worst-case, two-level control problem.
They show the follower's side reduces to a hard equation with jumps, and the leader's side to a still harder one that mixes those jumps with local rules. A proof method borrowed from stochastic control brackets the leader's value between two envelopes. When a comparison rule holds, the envelopes meet and pin the value down. Simulations show how the contract shifts with the threat.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thibaut MASTROLIA, Haoze YAN |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 113 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08989
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Agency Problems and Adversarial Bilevel Optimization under Uncertainty and Cyber Threats Thibaut MASTROLIA, Haoze YAN Abstract We study an agency problem between a leader (the principal) seeking to design an optimal incentive scheme to a follower (the agent) to increase the value of a risky project subjected to accidents and volatility uncertainty. The agency problem is formulated as a max-min bilevel stochastic control problem with accidents and ambiguity. We show that the problem of the follower is reduced to solve a second order BSDE with jumps, reducing the problem of the leader to solve an integro-partial Hamilton–Jacobi–Bellman–Isaacs (HJBI) equation. By extending stochastic Perron’s method to our setting, we obtain viscosity sub- and supersolution envelopes for the Principal’s integro-HJBI equation. Under an additional comparison principle in a suitable polynomial-growth class, these envelopes coincide and the Principal’s value is identified with the unique viscosity solution. The holding company seeks to design an optimal incentive scheme to mitigate these losses. In response, the subsidiary selects an optimal cybersecurity investment strategy, modeled through a stochastic epidemiological SIR (Susceptible-Infected-Recovered) framework. The cyber threat landscape is captured through an L-hop risk framework with two primary sources of risk, internal risk propagation via the contagion parameters in the SIR model, and external cyberattacks from a malicious external hacker. The uncertainty and adversarial nature of the hacking lead to consider a robust stochastic control approach that allows for increased volatility and ambiguity induced by cyber incidents. We illustrate our results with numerical simulations showing how the contracting mechanism enhances the quality of a cluster under cyber threats. 1 Introduction According to Governor Michael S. Barr, speaking at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York on April 17, 2025 “Cybercrime is on the rise, and cybercriminals are increasingly turning to Gen AI to facilitate their crimes. Criminal tactics are becoming more sophisticated and available to a broader range of criminals. Estimates of direct and indirect costs of cyber incidents range from 1 to 10 percent of global GDP. Deepfake attacks have seen a twenty-fold increase in the last three years”. Governor Barr’s remarks underscore the growing severity of cyber threats fueled by the hyper-connectivity of modern society. Individuals, businesses, public institutions, and critical infrastructure are increasingly interconnected through digital networks—creating vulnerabilities across virtually every sector. From social media platforms and private messaging services to healthcare systems, governments, and financial institutions, no domain is immune. These threats are not geographically confined either; cyberattacks are now a global concern, affecting nations and industries worldwide. Recent geopolitical developments—such as the Russia-Ukraine war—have further intensified cyber threats, particularly across Europe and NATO member states. Likewise, the COVID-19 pandemic, which accelerated the digitalization of services and online interaction, has expanded the attack surface for cybercriminals. However, cyber threats have been growing increasingly sophisticated over the past few decades, making it urgent to develop a strong agenda to address it as one of the main challenge of the 21st century (see, e.g., Tatar et al. (2014) ; Karabacak and Tatar (2014) ; Eling et al. (2021) ; Amin (2019) ; Ghadge et al. (2020) ). To address these challenges, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s Science and Technology Directorate has launched the Cyber Risk Economics (CyRiE) project. This initiative promotes research into the legal, behavioral, technical, and economic dimensions of cybersecurity. A key component of CyRiE focuses on designing effective incentives to optimize cyber-risk management, aiming to guide organizations in allocating resources toward the most impactful and valuable defenses. This work contributes to that objective by exploring how a parent (holding) firm can design optimal incentives and compensation mechanisms for its subsidiaries operating under cyber threat conditions. The goal is to ensure efficient monitoring and management of both the subsidiary’s portfolio and its cybersecurity strategies. 1.1 Incentives and agency theory Turning now to incentive mechanism, it has been investigated since the 1960s in economy and known as contract theory or agency problem, model with a Principal-Agent framework with information asymmetry. Holmstrom and Milgrom’s 1987 pioneer work Holmstrom and Milgrom (1987) has set the paradigm in a continuous-time framework with continuous controlled process. It has then regained interest in the mathematical community in the last decades with the work of Sannikov Sannikov (2008) and Cvitanic, Possamai and Touzi Cvitanić et al. (2018) ; Cvitanić et al. (2017) . In our model, the holding firm (the principal) monitors indirectly the action of the subsidiary (the agent) by proposing a compensation for its activities. The holding firm does not have a direct access to the activities of its subsidiary and only observes the result of its work through its wealth and corrupted devices in the SIR system. This asymmetry of information arises in a moral hazard situation in which the principal must anticipates the best reaction of the agent to propose an optimal incentives scheme. This problem is equivalent to solve a Stackelberg game in continuous time, see for example Li and Sethi (2017) ; Hernández-Santibáñez (2024) ; Hernández et al. (2024) . We usually address this problem as a bilevel stochastic optimization, in which the problem of the agent is embedded into the problem of the principal, known as the incentive compatibility condition of the compensation offers by the principal to the agent ensuring the existence of a best reaction activity, see e.g. Mastrolia and Zhang (2025) ; Dempe and Zemkoho (2020) . We refer to Tirole (2010) ; Cvitanic and Zhang (2012) for a more detailed overview of principal-agent, Stackelberg games and agency problem. Stochastic control contributions. The bilevel optimization investigated is {\ \begin{aligned} V_{0}^{P}:=&\sup_{\xi\in\Xi}\sup_{\hat{\alpha}(\xi)}\inf_{(\mathbb{P},\eta)\in\mathcal{H}^{(\widehat{\alpha}(\xi))}(0,x_{0})}\mathbb{E}^{\mathbb{P}}\Big[F^{P}(X_{T})-\xi-\int_{0}^{T}C^{P}\big(s,X_{s},\widehat{\alpha}_{s}(\xi),\eta_{s}\big)ds\Big]\\ \text{subject to }\quad&\text{(IC)}\ \ \widehat{\alpha}(\xi)\ \text{is an agent best response in \eqref{eq:agent-value}},\\ &\text{(IR)}\ \ V_{0}^{A}(\xi)\ \geq R_{0},\end{aligned}} where the risky project is solution to the following equation dX_{t}=b(t,X_{t-},\alpha_{t},\eta_{t})dt+\sigma(t,X_{t-},\eta_{t})dW^{(\alpha,\eta)}_{t}+\int_{E}\beta(t,X_{t-},e)\tilde{\mu}^{(\alpha,\eta)}(dt,de), driven by the agent’s control \alpha under volatility uncertainty \eta leading to an uncertain family of controlled probability \mathcal{P}^{\alpha} . Our work is the first one proposing (i) an applications to second order BSDE with jumps to stochastic control and volatility ambiguity resolving the agent’s problem ( 2.4 ) below embedded in the leader-follower problem; (ii) extending stochastic Perron’s method to stochastic control and max-min optimization with volatility uncertainty and jumps; (iii) developing a self-contained framework tractable for diverse applications including cyber risk management. Cyber risk and L-hop propagation under ambiguity Cyberattacks vary widely in form and mechanism (see, e.g., Uma and Padmavathi (2013) ; Hathaway et al. (2012) ; Hillairet et al. (2023) ; Grove et al. (2019) ; Boumezoued et al. (2023) ; Hillairet et al. (2024) ), but L-hop propagation models are particularly useful for capturing the dynamics of both external and internal threats. The term L-hop refers to the number of network connections (or ”hops”) an attack can traverse before reaching its target. External threats originate outside the network such as direct hacking attempts, modeled using a point process with exogenous intensity. Internal threats emerge from within the network, typically through infected nodes spreading malware or viruses. These internal dynamics are modeled using compartmental epidemiological models, such as the SIR (Susceptible-Infectious-Recovered) framework, see e.g. Capasso (1993) ; Britton (2010) ; Elie et al. (2020) , in the context of cyber risk (see, e.g., Del Rey et al. (2022) ; Hillairet et al. (2022) ; Hillairet et al. (2024) ).