A possible correction of the Saha curve for non-equilibrium states

L. L. Sales, F. C. Carvalho, H. T. C. M. Souza · 2025

Read A possible correction of the Saha curve for non-equilibrium states by L. L. Sales, F. C. Carvalho, H. T. C. M. Souza (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08972.txt.

Introduction

Sales, Carvalho, and Souza propose a tweak to a classic plasma formula for settings out of balance, in a 2025 paper. The Saha equation describes how atoms ionize in a hot gas at rest. It fails for plasmas that are not in equilibrium. The early universe's hydrogen plasma, as it cooled and combined, is one such case.

Their fix draws on a generalized form of statistics with a tuning value. They suggest that value could drift over time, tracking the changing state of the plasma. In that view, the value stands in for a shifting effective temperature. Recombination from excited states is part of the picture. The proposal offers a new way to fit the history of that cosmic event.

Catalog record

CREATORL. L. Sales, F. C. Carvalho, H. T. C. M. Souza
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08972

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A possible correction of the Saha curve for non-equilibrium states L. L. Sales, F. C. Carvalho, H. T. C. M. Souza Abstract It is widely known that the Saha equation is not suitable for describing plasmas out of thermodynamic equilibrium. The primordial hydrogen recombination plasma is an example of this. In this work, we propose a theoretical modification to the standard Saha curve motivated by Tsallis statistics. In particular, we explore the possibility that a time-dependent q q -parameter may serve as an effective proxy for the evolving thermodynamic conditions during recombination, especially considering that hydrogen recombination occurs from excited states. Within this framework, the q q -parameter could be interpreted as encoding departures from equilibrium and could play the role of effective time-dependent temperature. This indicates that the time evolution of the q q -parameter could provide a phenomenological mechanism for incorporating non-equilibrium effects into the recombination history. Our findings suggest that the Tsallis parameterization provides an alternative path to fit the distribution of free electrons by using an effective temperature. The implications of this approach might go beyond its immediate applications, as the Saha equation is widely used in various scientific fields like astrophysics, cosmology, plasma physics, and condensed matter physics. Journal: Physics Letters B 1 Introduction The Saha equation describes the ionization of atoms in plasmas under thermal equilibrium conditions [ 1 ] . Within the Boltzmann–Gibbs (BG) statistical framework, it relates the free electron fraction to the temperature, and has been widely applied to problems in astrophysics and cosmology, from neutrino production in stellar interiors to primordial hydrogen recombination [ 2 ] . It also plays a role in Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), where it is used to estimate the abundances of light nuclei such as 4 He. Despite its versatility, the Saha equation is strictly valid only for systems in thermodynamic equilibrium [ 3 , 4 ] , which limits its applicability to dynamical situations. In the literature, it is well established that both BBN and primordial hydrogen recombination are more accurately described by kinetic approaches, such as the Boltzmann equation for annihilation [ 5 , 3 , 4 , 6 ] . This is because the relevant processes in the early Universe evolved from near-equilibrium to genuinely non-equilibrium conditions. As a result, the traditional Saha equation alone cannot provide a reliable description of hydrogen recombination. Peebles argued that direct recombination to the hydrogen ground state produces photons capable of reionizing other atoms, yielding no net change. Instead, he suggested that recombination proceeds mainly through excited states [ 5 ] . This further undermines the applicability of the Saha equation, which assumes recombination directly to the ground state. More fundamentally, the limitation of Saha’s approach lies in its reliance on chemical equilibrium, which breaks down during certain stages of the Universe’s thermal history. Following Peebles’ pioneering work, successive studies refined the description of cosmological recombination by incorporating multi-level atom models, radiative transfer effects, and helium recombination, leading to more accurate predictions of the ionization history and the Cosmic Microwave Background anisotropies (see, e.g., [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] ). The interactions in the early Universe are primarily determined by electromagnetic reactions, which exhibit long-range interactions. In 2018, J.L. Cirto et al. investigated the Validity and Failure of the Boltzmann Weight in the context of long- and short-range interactions ( \alpha/d ) for potentials of the type \Phi(r)\propto 1/r^{\alpha} ( \alpha\geq 0 ) in a d -dimensional space [ 11 ] . Accordingly, for short-range interactions ( \alpha/d>1 ), numerical analysis indicates Maxwellians for the momenta and the Boltzmann weight for the energies. Nevertheless, for long-range interactions ( \alpha/d<1 ), numerical analysis strongly suggests q -Gaussians for the time-averaged momenta, as well as q -exponential distributions for the Boltzmann weight, hence undoubtedly falling out of the scope of Boltzmann-Gibbs (BG) statistical mechanics. Since the Saha equation is proportional to the Boltzmann weight in the realm of BG statistics, it cannot accurately depict the physical phenomena in the presence of long-range interactions, such as electromagnetic interactions. Besides, the presence of long-range interactions or significant statistical correlations often drives the system away from equilibrium [ 12 ] . Since the BG statistics is not well-suited to describe such non-equilibrium scenarios, modifications to the Saha equation become necessary to incorporate effects that lie beyond the BG paradigm. The Tsallis statistics is relevant in studying systems out of thermodynamic equilibrium that exhibit strong statistical correlations or long-range interactions [ 13 ] . In particular, several studies have shown that space plasmas often display non-Maxwellian velocity distributions that can be accurately described by q -Gaussian distributions (also called kappa distributions), which are typical of the S_{q} -formalism [ 14 ] . This provides a robust physical motivation for exploring the role of non-extensive statistics in ionization–recombination processes. The limitations of the Saha equation have opened up a way to investigate its applicability in the early Universe under a generalized context. Motivated by this issue, we develop a strategy to correct the Saha ionization curve for primordial hydrogen recombination using Tsallis statistics [ 15 ] . Our main hypothesis is that a time-dependent q -index can act as an effective temperature, capturing the evolving thermodynamic conditions of the primordial plasma. This evolution is physically motivated by the fact that recombination occurs predominantly through excited states, a condition that the standard Saha equation does not contemplate. To this end, we shall employ the Saha ionization equation determined in Ref. [ 16 ] . This modified version is distinct from the others because it does not include chemical potentials in its functional form, a common issue in alternative formulations (see [ 17 , 18 ] ). This work is structured as follows. In Sect. 2 , an overview of primordial hydrogen recombination is presented. We discuss considerations on a parameterized model of recombination and a strategy to correct the Saha curve in Sect. 3 . In Sect. 4 , the results and discussion are shown. Finally, the conclusions are presented in Sect. 5 . Unless otherwise specified, we will adopt the following system of natural units throughout the paper: c=k_{B}=\hbar=1 . 2 Primordial hydrogen recombination: an overview In the context of cosmology, recombination is a process where electrons and protons combine to form neutral hydrogen atoms in the early Universe. This is one of the most significant transitions in the thermal history of the Universe, which took place at approximately 378000 years after the Big Bang. At the end of this era, nearly 99% of the matter was combined with a significant amount of neutral hydrogen, with radiation temperature T\sim 2500~{\rm K} [ 3 , 5 ] . The remaining radiation from the last scattering surface was first detected in 1965 by radio astronomers Penzias and Wilson [ 19 ] . This radiation is commonly called the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). In exploring the period of recombination in the early Universe, there are two distinct approaches for analysis: the Saha equation and the Boltzmann kinetic approach. Assuming that the reaction e^{-}+p\leftrightarrow H+\gamma remains in equilibrium, the free electron fraction is calculated using the Saha equation [ 4 ] : \frac{x_{e}^{2}}{1-x_{e}}=\frac{1}{n_{b}\lambda_{e}^{3/2}}e^{-\varepsilon_{0}/T}~, (1) where \lambda_{e}=2\pi/(m_{e}T) is the thermal electron wavelength with m_{e}

Read the complete text