Uncertainties in the Estimation of Air Shower Observables from Monte Carlo Simulation of Radio Emission
Carlo S. Cruz Sanchez, Patricia M. Hansen, Matias Tueros, Jaime Alvarez-Muñiz, Diego G. Melo · 2025
Read Uncertainties in the Estimation of Air Shower Observables from Monte Carlo Simulation of Radio Emission by Carlo S. Cruz Sanchez, Patricia M. Hansen, Matias Tueros, Jaime Alvarez-Muñiz, Diego G. Melo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08920.txt.
Introduction
Cruz Sanchez and co-authors measure simulation error in cosmic ray radio work in a 2025 paper. Cosmic rays trigger air showers whose radio pulses reveal the starter particle's energy and type. Monte Carlo codes that fake those pulses must be trusted before data can be read.
Two leading codes, CoREAS and ZHAireS, were run on matched showers for comparison. Their predicted electric fields were lined up pulse by pulse. Differences between codes set the systematic error on key shower measures. Energy scale and mass mix both ride on those measures. A shared error budget keeps rival observatories honest with each other.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Carlo S. Cruz Sanchez, Patricia M. Hansen, Matias Tueros, Jaime Alvarez-Muñiz, Diego G. Melo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08920
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Uncertainties in the Estimation of Air Shower Observables from Monte Carlo Simulation of Radio Emission Carlo S. Cruz Sanchez, Patricia M. Hansen, Matias Tueros, Jaime Alvarez-Muñiz, Diego G. Melo Abstract The detection of extensive air showers (EAS) induced by cosmic rays via radio signals has undergone significant advancements in the last two decades. Numerous ultra-high energy cosmic ray experiments routinely capture radio pulses in the MHz to GHz frequency range emitted by EAS. The Monte Carlo simulation of these radio pulses is crucial to enable an accurate reconstruction of the primary cosmic ray energy and to infer the composition of the primary particles. In this work, a comprehensive comparison of the predicted electric field in EAS simulated with CoREAS and ZHAireS was conducted to estimate the systematic uncertainties arising from the use of different simulation packages in the determination of two key shower observables namely, the electromagnetic energy of the EAS and the depth of maximum development ( X max X_{\rm max} ). For this comparison, input parameters and settings as similar as possible were used in both simulations, along with the same realistic atmospheric refractive index depending on altitude, which is crucial for the prediction of radio emission properties of EAS. In addition, simulated EAS with very similar values of depth of maximum development were selected. Good agreement was found between CoREAS and ZHAireS, with discrepancies in the dominant electric field components generally remaining below 10% across the frequency range of a few MHz to hundreds of MHz, relevant for most radio detection experiments, translating into uncertainties in the determination of energy below 5 % 5\% and ≃ 10 g / cm 2 \simeq 10\,\mathrm{g/cm^{2}} in X max X_{\rm max} . Our work underscores the need for further studies to clarify their origin and impact on X max X_{\max} inference in composition analyses. 1 Introduction Ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) with energies in and above the EeV range initiate extensive air showers (EAS) upon interacting with the upper layers of the Earth’s atmosphere. Understanding the properties of EAS is essential to reveal the nature and origin of UHECRs [ 1 ] . Various detection techniques are used for this purpose. Arrays of particle detectors sample the shower front on the ground or underground, allowing measurements of particle densities and arrival times. Fluorescence detectors capture the fluorescence light resulting from the excitations of air molecules in the atmosphere, offering information about the longitudinal shower development. Additionally, arrays of radio antennas on the ground measure the electric field emitted in the MHz – GHz frequency range by the electromagnetic particles in the shower, offering a wealth of information [ 2 , 3 ] . This so-called radio technique has proven to be an invaluable method for EAS detection due to its almost 100% duty cycle and the negligible amount of atmospheric absorption that radio signals experience. In addition, it has been shown that using radio detection allows an accurate determination of shower energy [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] and the depth in the atmosphere ( X_{\text{max}} ) at which the shower reaches its maximum development [ 4 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . Radio signals in EAS primarily originate from the charged electromagnetic component. The motion of charged particles is akin to time-varying electric currents, resulting in coherent radiation for wavelengths greater than the typical dimensions of the shower [ 12 ] . Since air has a refractive index n>1 , particles in the shower can move with a speed larger than the local speed of light, inducing Cherenkov-like or relativistic effects in the emitted radiation [ 13 ] . Two main effects are responsible for the bulk of the emission in EAS in the MHz frequency range. The geomagnetic effect [ 14 ] involves a drift current resulting from charge separation within the magnetic field of the Earth \vec{B} , causing a polarization pattern approximately parallel to -\hat{v}\times\vec{B} (i.e., along the direction of the Lorentz force), where \hat{v} denotes the direction of the shower axis. The strength of the geomagnetically-induced field is directly proportional to the magnetic field magnitude |\vec{B}| and the sine of the “geomagnetic angle”, the angle between \vec{v} and \vec{B} . The Askaryan effect [ 15 ] arises from an excess of electrons compared to positrons within the shower, induced by particle physics processes such as Compton, Möller, and Bhabha scattering, as well as electron-positron annihilation [ 16 ] . The induced polarization is approximately in the direction \hat{u}\times(\hat{u}\times\hat{v}) , where \hat{u} is a unit vector from the emission point to the observer. The interpretation of data collected at experiments employing the radio technique requires accurate simulations of the EAS and the radio pulses produced. The two main Monte Carlo simulation programs used for this purpose are CoREAS [ 17 ] and ZHAireS [ 18 ] . In both, electrons and positrons are tracked using various approximations, and the resulting electric field is obtained from similar algorithms that are derived from first principles solving Maxwell’s equations (see for instance [ 19 ] for a review and references therein). The radio emission of the particle cascade arises naturally from these calculations, that do not assume any a priori emission mechanism or incorporate any free parameters. Simulations conducted using ZHAireS and CoREAS have demonstrated consistent results among themselves [ 20 ] and in relation to experimental data [ 21 , 5 , 22 , 23 ] . Further comparisons between CoREAS and ZHAireS have been recently made within the CORSIKA8 code [ 24 ] . However, comparisons between the two programs have focused on specific shower geometries [ 20 ] , different frequency bands [ 25 , 26 ] , or have only studied the effect on the energy emitted in radio waves [ 25 ] . A more detailed comparison that spans a broader range of primary particle types, shower geometries, and frequencies - and includes both radio energy measurements and the reconstruction of the depth of shower maximum - has yet to be fully conducted. This works seeks to contribute to these aspects. Complementing the work of [ 25 ] , in our study we provide a comparison of CoREAS and ZHAireS predictions on more fundamental observables, focusing on the lateral distribution of the different components of the electric field at ground level and their corresponding frequency spectra (Section 3 ). Rather than simulating a large number of showers and averaging results, as done in [ 25 ] , we simulate a smaller set of showers, all with identical energy, zenith and azimuthal angles, geomagnetic angles, and similar depths of maximum. This approach avoids the need to correct for geomagnetic and Askaryan contributions to the emission at different geomagnetic angles and varying atmospheric densities at X_{\text{max}} , allowing for a more direct comparison between the two simulation codes. A key novelty in our study is the use of a new version of ZHAireS which incorporates the refractive index model of the atmosphere based on the application of the Gladstone-Dale relation between atmospheric density and refractive index [ 27 ] (Section 2 ). In this way the same refractive index model is used in CoREAS and ZHAireS. This contrasts with