FareShare : A Tool for Labor Organizers to Estimate Lost Wages and Contest Arbitrary AI and Algorithmic Deactivations
Varun Nagaraj Rao, Samantha Dalal, Andrew Schwartz, Amna Liaqat, Dana Calacci, Andrés Monroy-Hernández · 2025
Read FareShare : A Tool for Labor Organizers to Estimate Lost Wages and Contest Arbitrary AI and Algorithmic Deactivations by Varun Nagaraj Rao, Samantha Dalal, Andrew Schwartz, Amna Liaqat, Dana Calacci, Andrés Monroy-Hernández (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08904.txt.
Introduction
Varun Rao and co-authors present a tool for gig drivers who lose access to their work apps in a 2025 paper. Ride share drivers can be deactivated by automated decisions with little explanation. That loss can ruin a driver income, and some state laws now grant appeals and pay for wrongful removal.
The tool, FareShare, automates the estimate of lost wages for deactivated drivers. It grew from a six month partnership with the largest ride share union in Washington state. In a three month field run, 178 people signed up. The team reports that wage math time fell by more than 95 percent and hand entry errors vanished. Legal teams could also build reports ready for dispute hearings faster, though trust and consent issues arose.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Varun Nagaraj Rao, Samantha Dalal, Andrew Schwartz, Amna Liaqat, Dana Calacci, Andrés Monroy-Hernández |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 83 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08904
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
FareShare : A Tool for Labor Organizers to Estimate Lost Wages and Contest Arbitrary AI and Algorithmic Deactivations Varun Nagaraj Rao, Samantha Dalal, Andrew Schwartz, Amna Liaqat, Dana Calacci, Andrés Monroy-Hernández Abstract . What happens when a rideshare driver is suddenly locked out of the platform connecting them to riders, wages, and daily work? Deactivation—the abrupt removal of gig workers’ platform access—typically occurs through arbitrary AI and algorithmic decisions with little explanation or recourse. This represents one of the most severe forms of algorithmic control and often devastates workers’ financial stability. Recent U.S. state policies now mandate appeals processes and recovering compensation during the period of wrongful deactivation based on past earnings. Yet, labor organizers still lack effective tools to support these complex, error-prone workflows. We designed FareShare , a computational tool automating lost wage estimation for deactivated drivers, through a 6 month partnership with the State of Washington’s largest rideshare labor union. Over the following 3 months, our field deployment of FareShare registered 178 account signups. We observed that the tool could reduce lost wage calculation time by over 95%, eliminate manual data entry errors, and enable legal teams to generate arbitration-ready reports more efficiently. Beyond these gains, the deployment also surfaced important socio-technical challenges around trust, consent, and tool adoption in high-stakes labor contexts. 1. Introduction Deactivation—the sudden termination of a gig worker’s platform access—has emerged as a critical yet understudied mechanism of algorithmic control ( Lee et al. 2015 ; Rosenblat and Stark 2016 ) in the gig economy and one of the most severe and destabilizing of AI and algorithmic harms for workers ( Siddiqui 2021 ; Keppler 2025 ; Schwartz et al. 2023 ) . Prior work has found that rideshare platforms may restrict drivers’ accounts based on acceptance rates, ratings, or alleged policy violations ( Cameron 2022 ) . These studies demonstrate that unlike traditional employment termination, deactivation in gig work functions as algorithmic firing of independent contractors, who ostensibly have freedom to make their own decisions but in reality lack legal protections against unfair dismissal. The problem worsens as these deactivations remain largely arbitrary, with a study from the State of Washington revealing that platforms overturn 80% of deactivation decisions upon appeal ( Schwartz et al. 2023 ) . Deactivation thus operates in a regulatory gray zone, leaving workers with minimal recourse. Recent state-level policies in the U.S., including State of Washington’s HB 2076 and Colorado’s SB24-075, aim to address this gap. These laws mandate that platforms provide deactivation notices, formal appeals processes, and compensation for wrongful account suspensions. However, implementing these protections requires labor organizers to navigate complex workflows—manual data collection of driver earnings from in-app screenshots, error-prone translation to spreadsheets, and evidentiary disputes during arbitration. Organizers thus lack the tools to support their coordinated data work ( Khovanskaya et al. 2019 ) needed to contest wrongful deactivations resulting from arbitrary AI and algorithmic decisions. This creates an urgent need for designing and deploying systems guided by policy requirements ( Jackson et al. 2014 ; Yang et al. 2024 ) to support organizers. We designed and deployed FareShare , a computational tool for labor organizers, through a 6-month collaboration with the State of Washington’s largest rideshare labor union (hereafter referred to as DU ). FareShare operationalizes the state’s policy mandate that platforms compensate deactivated drivers based on their 12-week pre-deactivation earnings (hereafter referred to as lost wage). The tool integrates with DU ’s existing workflows, syncing historical rideshare trip and earnings data and generating arbitration-ready reports to estimate lost wages for wrongfully deactivated drivers. To inform the design of FareShare , we first conducted a formative study of DU ’s deactivation appeals process, identifying operational challenges that shaped the tool’s features. We then carried out a 3-month field deployment, resulting in 178 account sign-ups, to evaluate its real-world use and impact. In this paper, we ask: RQ1: What processes, challenges, and outcomes define the deactivation appeals workflow for DU staff? RQ2: How does the computational tool we built, FareShare , improve the deactivation appeals workflow for DU staff? Our analysis reveals three key findings. First, FareShare could reduce lost wage calculation time by over 95% (from 25 to 2.5 minutes for gathering drivers’ historical earnings, and from 2-3 hours to 2 minutes for report generation per case) and eliminated manual data entry errors, enabling the legal team to generate lost wage reports up much faster. Second, the tool provided legal teams with data access that extended beyond lost wage calculations to include independent audits and cross-referencing of platform-provided information, strengthening their position during arbitration. Third, despite these benefits, technical challenges persisted—including data synchronization issues, platform security warnings that frightened drivers, and consent process frictions—highlighting the tensions of technical solutions in high-stakes labor contexts. Our work has broader implications for CSCW/HCI scholarship. Our findings demonstrate how tools can transform regulatory mandates into actionable evidence, developing new practices for contesting algorithmic harms through coordinated data work. We also reveal how institutional incentives and invisible maintenance labor determine tool adoption success echoing past work ( Orlikowski and Baroudi 1991 ; Star and Strauss 1999 ) . Finally, our work illustrates the ethical and practical trade-offs that emerge when tools mediate data access in information and power-asymmetric environments. In summary, our contributions are as follows: - Empirical insights into the deactivation appeals workflow within a labor organization (RQ1, Section 4 ) - A policy-guided computational tool that operationalizes lost wage estimation requirements, demonstrating how such tools can support organizers in contesting AI and algorithmic platform harms (Sections 5 , 6 ) - An evaluation demonstrating both the benefits and challenges of the tool’s adoption within an organization (RQ2, Section 7 ) 2. Related Work Our paper contributes a tool supporting labor organizers in filing lost wages claims during deactivation appeals, situated within four research areas: algorithmic control mechanisms in gig work, data-driven resistance strategies, CSCW systems for organizational coordination, and HCI-policy collaboration that translates policy guidelines into design requirements. We describe them below. Figure 1. Screenshots of Driver Deactivation Notifications on Uber and Lyft sourced from Subreddits r/uberdrivers and r/lyftdrivers 2.1. Deactivation as a Mechanism for Control in the Platform Economy Gig economy workers are typically classified as independent contractors rather than employees under U.S labor law, which significantly impacts workplace control mechanisms ( Griffith 2018 ) . Independent contractors should legally determine what work they do and how they perform it ( Service 2025 ) . Platforms like Uber and DoorDash rely on “soft control” techniques to direct work while avoiding employer responsibilities ( Rosenblat and Stark 2016 ) . For example, rideshare platforms “gamify” work with rewards designed to keep drivers online and working in specific areas—effectively controlling the work drivers do ( Vasudevan and Chan 2022 ; Woodcock and Johnson 2018 ) . Unlike traditional employers who can fire employees for poor performance, gig platforms must use alternative disciplinary methods because independent contractors are supposedly self-employed. Rideshare platforms employ various disciplinary strategies, including deactivation—blocking a driver’s ability to work online. Deactivation is one of the most severe and destabilizing worker harms. Refer to Figure 1 for examples of deactivation notices from rideshare platforms. Researchers ( Watkins 2023 ; Schwartz et al. 2023 ;