“Clicking some of the silly options”: Exploring Player Motivation in Static and Dynamic Educational Interactive Narratives

Daeun Hwang, Samuel Shields, Alex Calderwood, Shi Johnson-Bey, Michael Mateas, Noah Wardrip-Fruin, Edward F. Melcer · 2025

Read “Clicking some of the silly options”: Exploring Player Motivation in Static and Dynamic Educational Interactive Narratives by Daeun Hwang, Samuel Shields, Alex Calderwood, Shi Johnson-Bey, Michael Mateas, Noah Wardrip-Fruin, Edward F. Melcer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08891.txt.

Introduction

Daeun Hwang and co-authors test how story games can teach and hold a player's drive, in a 2025 paper. Past work shows that set-path story games lift the will to learn, and new smart tools can now bend a story as it plays.

The team built two forms of one game about right and wrong in research. In one, the plot branches along paths the makers wrote by hand. In the next, the game picks the order of scenes as play goes on. Players met both forms. Quick, apt twists in the tale and a wide set of choices kept players hooked. The rub was to keep the lesson firm while the tale bent. The authors draw design tips for games that teach with a live story.

Catalog record

CREATORDaeun Hwang, Samuel Shields, Alex Calderwood, Shi Johnson-Bey, Michael Mateas, Noah Wardrip-Fruin, Edward F. Melcer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08891

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

“Clicking some of the silly options”: Exploring Player Motivation in Static and Dynamic Educational Interactive Narratives Daeun Hwang, Samuel Shields, Alex Calderwood, Shi Johnson-Bey, Michael Mateas, Noah Wardrip-Fruin, Edward F. Melcer Abstract . Motivation is an important factor underlying successful learning. Previous research has demonstrated the positive effects that static interactive narrative games can have on motivation. Concurrently, advances in AI have made dynamic and adaptive approaches to interactive narrative increasingly accessible. However, limited work has explored the impact that dynamic narratives can have on learner motivation. In this paper, we compare two versions of Academical, a choice-based educational interactive narrative game about research ethics. One version employs a traditional hand-authored branching plot (i.e., static narrative) while the other dynamically sequences plots during play (i.e., dynamic narrative). Results highlight the importance of responsive content and a variety of choices for player engagement, while also illustrating the challenge of balancing pedagogical goals with the dynamic aspects of narrative. We also discuss design implications that arise from these findings. Ultimately, this work provides initial steps to illuminate the emerging potential of AI-driven dynamic narrative in educational games. Conference: Augmented Educators and AI: Shaping the Future of Human-AI Collaboration in Learning on CHI 2025 Workshop; April 26,2025; Yokohama, JAPAN © This paper was adapted for the CHI 2025 Workshop on Augmented Educators and AI: Shaping the Future of Human and AI Cooperation in Learning , held in Yokohama, Japan on April 26, 2025. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). 1. Introduction It is challenging to find ways to cultivate an understanding of research ethics and motivation to care about them ( Schmaling and Blume, 2009 ; Kalichman, 2013a ; Kalichman, 2014 ; Bouville, 2008 ) . This challenge has been addressed in a variety of ways, ranging from traditional expository prose to live-action role-playing of ethical dilemmas ( Whitbeck, 2001 ; Brummel et al., 2010a ; Kalichman, 2013b ; Seiler et al., 2011 ) . While most training in the area remains textbook-like, the use of narrative and interactive methods has found success in engaging learners ( Melcer et al., 2020a ; Salter, 2016 ; Friedhoff, 2013 ) . Our research builds upon the finding that interactive visual novels (VNs) can be more effective than traditional training materials for engaging learners and cultivating knowledge of responsible conduct of research (RCR) ( Grasse et al., 2021b ) . However, while existing work has focused on the efficacy of traditional hand-authored branching plot for educational narratives (i.e., static narratives) ( Grasse et al., 2022 ) , little has been done to explore the engagement and motivational possibilities of dynamically sequenced plot during play. Engagement and motivation in particular are important to consider in the design of educational technologies as greater engagement and motivation have been shown to lead to greater knowledge transfer and increased achievement ( Hsu et al., 2019 ; Guay et al., 2008 ; Bond et al., 2020 ) . Dynamic narratives are particularly intriguing in this context as their dynamism (i.e., ability to provide a wide swath of content dynamically based upon player choices) offers potential to further engage and motivate players in a variety of ways ( Johnson-Bey et al., 2024 ) . In this paper, we explore the potential of dynamic interactive narrative in motivating players, examining their engagement with respect to 1) elements of the game design, 2) perceptions of the narrative structure presented, and 3) the motivational factors of Self-Determination Theory ( Ryan et al., 2006 ) —i.e., autonomy, competence, and relatedness (ARC) ( Oliver et al., 2016 ) . Specifically, we present results from a comparative study contrasting two versions of an interactive VN for learning RCR. The existing game is a statically authored narrative used in existing RCR education research ( Melcer et al., 2020a ) , which we refer to as "Academical 1.0". The other is designed to offer a novel dynamic narrative approach to the same content presented in Academical 1.0, which we refer to as "Academical 2.0". Our results highlight both the strengths and challenges of incorporating AI into educational interactive narratives, providing design implications to inform the future creation of dynamic educational narratives (DEN). 2. Related Work 2.1. Dynamic Narrative Systems Figure 1. Spectrum of storytelling in games. The circles represent plot points, and the solid arrows are hand-authored connections from one plot point to the next. The dotted arrows represent the plot points connected at runtime by system rules informed by designer goals and the history of player choice. A diagram split into three columns. Each column contains circles connected by arrows, representing potential playthroughs of a game's plot. The columns are labeled: "linear", "branching", "procedural", and a "mix of the three" Storytelling in games exists on a spectrum in terms of dynamism, ranging from linear to branching to procedural (see Figure 1 ). Linear storytelling moves the player from plot point to plot point without deviating from the core plot. Branching stories use player choices to branch and move the player between predefined branching plot paths. This design approach resembles Choose Your Own Adventure (CYOA) novels and is the most common form of interactive narrative in games ( Melcer et al., 2020b ) . Lastly, procedural storytelling breaks story content into loosely connected chunks, commonly called “storylets,” that players can explore in any order ( Kreminski and Wardrip-Fruin, 2018 ) . Computationally, it is the most systems-heavy of the three, but it provides players more freedom in shaping the story plot they experience ( Short, 2019 ) . 2.2. Narratives and Learning VNs are commonly defined as a genre of digital game with a narrative focus in which players shape the story or progression of the game through their interactions ( Camingue et al., 2021 ) . VNs are a popular genre for educational games ( Camingue et al., 2020 ) covering topics ranging from second language acquisition ( Faizal, 2016 ; Gabriel et al., 2018 ; Amalo et al., 2017 ; Putri et al., 2021 ; Agusalim, 2012 ) , literacy ( Lai and Chen, 2021 ; Sullivan and Critten, 2014 ) , math ( Nugroho et al., 2018 ; Muntean et al., 2018 ) , awareness ( Andrew et al., 2019 ; Korhonen and Halonen, 2017 ) , training ( Huynh et al., 2017 ) , and health ( Yin et al., 2012 ) . Past studies have shown that utilizing educational VNs is more effective in terms of attitudes, motivation, engagement, skill-development, and learning when compared to non-interactive, traditional text-based approaches ( Melcer et al., 2020a ; Faizal, 2016 ; Gabriel et al., 2018 ; Salazar et al., 2013 ) . However, while many educational interactive narrative games have been created and assessed, they have predominately utilized hand-authored static narrative approaches ( Camingue et al., 2020 ) . In contrast, dynamic narratives offer the ability to cater learning and story beats to an individual user during their playtime. This allows users to discover pedagogical content at their own pace, as well as the system to serve learning content informed by player navigation ( Rowe et al., 2010 ) . A notable implementation of this approach comes from the

Read the complete text