Galaxies in the Epoch of Reionization Are All Bark and No Bite — Plenty of Ionizing Photons, Low Escape Fractions

Casey Papovich, Justin W. Cole, Weida Hu, Steven L. Finkelstein, Lu Shen, Pablo Arrabal Haro, Ricardo O. Amorín, Bren E. Backhaus, Micaela B. Bagley, Rachana Bhatawdekar, Antonello Calabrò, Adam C. Carnall, Nikko J. Cleri, Emanuele Daddi, Mark Dickinson, Norman A. Grogin, Benne W. Holwerda, Anne E. · 2025

Read Galaxies in the Epoch of Reionization Are All Bark and No Bite — Plenty of Ionizing Photons, Low Escape Fractions by Casey Papovich, Justin W. Cole, Weida Hu, Steven L. Finkelstein, Lu Shen, Pablo Arrabal Haro, Ricardo O. Amorín, Bren E. Backhaus, Micaela B. Bagley, Rachana Bhatawdekar, Antonello Calabrò, Adam C. Carnall, Nikko J. Cleri, Emanuele Daddi, Mark Dickinson, Norman A. Grogin, Benne W. Holwerda, Anne E. (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08870.txt.

Introduction

Casey Papovich and a large team of co-authors present a 2025 astronomy paper on the first galaxies and the reionization of the universe. Early James Webb telescope results suggested young galaxies flood out ionizing light, which should have cleared the cosmic fog suspiciously early. The team measured 412 galaxies seen as they were when the universe was young.

Fitting star and gas models to images and spectra, they found these galaxies do make ionizing photons at high rates, rising for smaller and earlier galaxies. But the share that escapes is tiny, only a few percent, so most photons are swallowed inside the galaxy itself. Counting faint galaxies as well, the timing of reionization lands where other evidence expects it.

Catalog record

CREATORCasey Papovich, Justin W. Cole, Weida Hu, Steven L. Finkelstein, Lu Shen, Pablo Arrabal Haro, Ricardo O. Amorín, Bren E. Backhaus, Micaela B. Bagley, Rachana Bhatawdekar, Antonello Calabrò, Adam C. Carnall, Nikko J. Cleri, Emanuele Daddi, Mark Dickinson, Norman A. Grogin, Benne W. Holwerda, Anne E.
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE119 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08870

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Galaxies in the Epoch of Reionization Are All Bark and No Bite — Plenty of Ionizing Photons, Low Escape Fractions Casey Papovich, Justin W. Cole, Weida Hu, Steven L. Finkelstein, Lu Shen, Pablo Arrabal Haro, Ricardo O. Amorín, Bren E. Backhaus, Micaela B. Bagley, Rachana Bhatawdekar, Antonello Calabrò, Adam C. Carnall, Nikko J. Cleri, Emanuele Daddi, Mark Dickinson, Norman A. Grogin, Benne W. Holwerda, Anne E. Jaskot, Anton M. Koekemoer, Mario Llerena, Ray A. Lucas, Sara Mascia, Fabio Pacucci, Laura Pentericci, Pablo G. Pérez-González, Nor Pirzkal, Srinivasan Raghunathan, Lise-Marie Seillé, Rachel S. Somerville, L. Y. Aaron Yung Abstract Early results from JWST suggest that epoch-of-reionization (EoR) galaxies produce copious ionizing photons, which, if they escape efficiently, could cause reionization to occur too early. We study this problem using JWST imaging and prism spectroscopy for 412 galaxies at 4.5 < z < 9.0 4.5<z<9.0 . We fit these data simultaneously with stellar–population and nebular–emission models that include a parameter for the fraction of ionizing photons that escape the galaxy, f esc f_{\mathrm{esc}} . We find that the ionization production efficiency, ξ ion = Q ⁡ ( H 0 ) / L UV \hbox{$\xi_{\mathrm{ion}}$}=Q(\mathrm{H_{0}})/\hbox{$L_{\mathrm{UV}}$} , increases with redshift and decreasing UV luminosity, but shows significant scatter, σ ⁡ ( log ⁡ ξ ion | z , M UV ) ≃ 0.3 \sigma(\log\hbox{$\xi_{\mathrm{ion}}$}|z,\hbox{$M_{\mathrm{UV}}$})\simeq 0.3 dex. The inferred escape fractions averaged over the population are low, ranging from ⟨ f esc ⟩ ≃ 2.6 ± 1.4 \langle\hbox{$f_{\mathrm{esc}}$}\rangle\simeq 2.6\pm 1.4 % at 6 < z < 9 6<z<9 to 6.5 ± 2.2 6.5\pm 2.2 % at 4.5 < z < 6 4.5<z<6 with weak or no indication of evolution with redshift. This implies that in our models most of the ionizing photons need to be absorbed to account for the nebular emission. We compute the impact of our results on reionization, including the distributions for ξ ion \xi_{\mathrm{ion}} and f esc f_{\mathrm{esc}} , and the evolution and uncertainty of the UV luminosity function. Considering galaxies brighter than M UV < − 16 \hbox{$M_{\mathrm{UV}}$}<-16 mag, we would produce an IGM hydrogen-ionized fraction of x e = 0.5 x_{e}=0.5 at 5.3 < z < 5.8 5.3<z<5.8 , possibly too late compared to constraints from from QSO sightlines. Including fainter galaxies, M UV < − 14 \hbox{$M_{\mathrm{UV}}$}<-14 mag, we obtain x e = 0.5 x_{e}=0.5 at 6.0 < z < 8.1 6.0<z<8.1 , fully consistent with QSO and CMB data. This implies that EoR galaxies produce plenty of ionizing photons, but these do not efficiently escape. This may be a result of high gas column densities combined with burstier star-formation histories, which limit the time massive stars are able to clear channels through the gas for ionizing photons to escape. I Introduction JWST has transformed our ability to characterize the nature of galaxies at redshifts as high as z\sim 14 ( Bunker et al. 2023 ; Arrabal Haro et al. 2023b ; Carniani et al. 2024 ; Kokorev et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . From the analyses of JWST data, galaxies at z>7 appear to be dominated by younger stellar populations ( Papovich et al. 2023 , e.g.,) , with stronger nebular emission ( Endsley et al. 2024 ; Calabrò et al. 2024 ; Mascia et al. 2024 ; Pahl et al. 2025 ; Simmonds et al. 2024a ; Simmonds et al. 2024b ) , and evidence of more bursty star-formation histories ( Endsley et al. 2024 ; Cole et al. 2025 ; Trussler et al. 2025 ) , compared to lower redshift galaxies ( Shen et al. 2024 ; Cole et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . The properties of galaxies at z>6 are crucially important because this period corresponds to the epoch of reionization (EoR) of the intergalactic medium (IGM). Constraints from the polarization of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) show that the ionized fraction of the IGM rises from nil at the epoch of recombination, z\approx 1100 , to x_{e}=0.5 by z=8.4 ( Planck Collaboration et al. 2020 ). 1 1 1 The Planck Collaboration et al. (2020) analysis also suggests a non-zero optical depth of CMB photons scattering off free electrons at z\approx 15 , which implies ionization of the IGM had begun by this epoch. This can be combined with observations of the optical depth of ionizing radiation from QSOs to show that reionization had effectively “ended” by z\sim 5-6 when the ionized fraction was x_{e}\mathrel{\hbox{\hbox to0.0pt{\hbox{\lower 4.0pt\hbox{$\sim$}}\hss}\hbox{$>$}}}0.9 ( McGreer et al. 2015 ; Greig et al. 2017 ; Becker et al. 2019 ; Hu et al. 2019 ; Mason et al. 2019 ; Wang et al. 2020 ; Whitler et al. 2020 ; Nakane et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . Galaxies during the first billion years appear to be the most likely cause of this reionization ( Robertson et al. 2022 , see,) . Observations from JWST have already shown evidence that galaxies at z\mathrel{\hbox{\hbox to0.0pt{\hbox{\lower 4.0pt\hbox{$\sim$}}\hss}\hbox{$>$}}}7 have sufficient ionizing radiation to complete reionization by this time ( Simmonds et al. 2024a ; Simmonds et al. 2024b ) . The primary measurement of interest is the so-called ionizing production efficiency, \xi_{\mathrm{ion}} , defined as the ratio of production rate of photons with energy > 13.6 eV, Q(\mathrm{H_{0}}) , in units of s -1 , to the luminosity density at 1500 Å, L_{\mathrm{UV}} , in units of erg s -1 Hz -1 ( Leitherer and Heckman 1995 ) . The analysis of JWST data shows that \xi_{\mathrm{ion}} spans a wide range, from as low \log\hbox{$\xi_{\mathrm{ion}}$}\simeq 24.5 to as high as \log\hbox{$\xi_{\mathrm{ion}}$}\simeq 25-26 ( Atek et al. 2024 ; Prieto-Lyon et al. 2023 ; Pahl et al. 2025 ; Simmonds et al. 2024a ; Simmonds et al. 2024b ; Begley et al. 2025 ; Hayes et al. 2025 ; Llerena et al. 2025 , e.g.,) , possibly exceeding the canonical value, \log\hbox{$\xi_{\mathrm{ion}}$}=25.2 expected for young stellar populations and observed for galaxies at z\sim 2 ( Robertson et al. 2015 ; Shivaei et al. 2018 ) . That is, EoR galaxies appear to produce sufficient ionizing radiation for reionization to proceed. However, we lack a good understanding of how much of this radiation escapes into the IGM. This is measured by the escape fraction, f_{\mathrm{esc}} , which is the relative amount of photons with energy greater than the ionization energy of hydrogen (also referred to as Lyman-continuum radiation, LyC, at wavelengths < 912 Å). Theoretical constraints predict that the escape fraction is low for EoR galaxies as the column density of gas that fuels star formation is very large ( Ferrara and Loeb 2013 ; Xu et al. 2016 , e.g.,) . The key is how efficiently feedback from star formation can clear channels through the gas through which the LyC can escape ( Kimm and Cen 2014 ) . Current predictions for EoR galaxies, with masses like those we currently detect with JWST , are that they have lower escape fractions, with \hbox{$f_{\mathrm{esc}}$}\sim 1-15\% ( Ma et al. 2015 ; Xu et al. 2016 ; Ferrara et al. 2019 ; Kostyuk et al. 2023 ; Yeh et al. 2023 ) , although some simulations argue for an increase in f_{\mathrm{esc}} with increasing redshift ( Rosdahl et al. 2022 ; Trebitsch et al. 2022 , e.g.,)

Read the complete text