Plastic deformation as a phase transition: a combinatorial model of plastic flow in copper single crystals

Afonso D. M. Barroso, Elijah Borodin, Andrey P. Jivkov · 2025

Read Plastic deformation as a phase transition: a combinatorial model of plastic flow in copper single crystals by Afonso D. M. Barroso, Elijah Borodin, Andrey P. Jivkov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08689.txt.

Introduction

Afonso Barroso and co-authors treat bending metal as a phase change in a 2025 paper. Standard plasticity models smooth the metal into a uniform medium and so miss how its inner slip patterns evolve. Their discrete model rewrites a two-parameter mean-field theory in geometric calculus and lays a network of slip events over a copper crystal pulled in tension.

Simulated on a triangular mesh with a standard sampling algorithm, the network settles into distinct phases, arrangements mixing aligned and crossed slip systems. Some phases echo known crystal behavior, like second slip systems waking, strain bunching, and fracture. Stress changes drove abrupt, first-order switches, while the coupling dial drove smooth, second-order ones. The parallels link metal physics to statistical mechanics.

Catalog record

CREATORAfonso D. M. Barroso, Elijah Borodin, Andrey P. Jivkov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE97 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08689

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Plastic deformation as a phase transition: a combinatorial model of plastic flow in copper single crystals Afonso D. M. Barroso, Elijah Borodin, Andrey P. Jivkov Abstract Continuum models of plasticity fail to capture the richness of microstructural evolution because the continuum is a homogeneous construction. The present study shows that an alternative way is available at the mesoscale in the form of truly discrete constructions and in the discrete exterior calculus. A pre-existing continuum mean-field model with two parameters is rewritten in the language of the latter to model the properties of a network of plastic slip events in a perfect copper single crystal under uniaxial tension. The behaviour of the system is simulated in a triangular 2D mesh in 3D space employing a Metropolis-Hastings algorithm. Phases of distinct character emerge and both first-order and second-order phase transitions are observed. The phases represent arrangements of the plastic slip network with different combinations of collinear, coplanar, non-collinear and non-coplanar active slip systems. Furthermore, some of these phases can be interpreted as representing crystallographic phenomena like activation of secondary slip systems, strain localisation and fracture or amorphisation. The first-order transitions mostly occur as functions of the applied stress, while the second-order transitions occur exclusively as functions of the mean-field coupling parameter. The former are reminiscent of transitions in other statistical-mechanical models, while the latter find parallels in experimental observations. Keywords: Plastic slip, Statistical mechanics, Combinatorics, Phase transitions 1 Introduction Since Brenner’s experiments in the 1950s ( Brenner, 1956 ; Brenner, 1957 ; Brenner, 1958 ) , metal specimens of very small dimensions have put into question commonly held assumptions about the nature of plasticity and the conditions at its onset, such as the maximum yield strength attainable by metals ( Hou et al., 2022 ) , the critical resolved shear stress and the effect of normal stresses on slip planes ( Tschopp et al., 2007 ) . Unlike bulk-sized crystals and polycrystals, these microscopic single crystals, usually in the shape of microwhiskers (single crystals that are much longer than they are wide), have almost an absence of microstructure and can even be dislocation-free to the limit of image resolution ( Kamada and Tanner, 1974 ) . As increasing magnitudes of stress are applied to a perfect crystal, very high levels of potential strain energy are accumulated until a dislocation is nucleated, thereby providing a localised and propagating release mechanism that leads to the nucleation of more dislocations ( Cao and Ma, 2008 ) . Hence, there is a parallel between the nucleation of that first dislocation and the initiation of a plastic front. In fact, experimental studies have observed that many microwhiskers suffer a sudden and sharp drop in yield stress due to the initiation of a Lüders band that propagates up and down the material ( Charsley, 1960 ; Kamada and Tanner, 1974 ) . Furthermore, the yield strength of micrometre-sized single crystals varies with size, orientation and strain rate ( Peng et al., 2012 ; Dupont and Germann, 2012 ) . It is plausible that the punctuated behaviour of small-scale crystals reflects one or more phase transitions occurring in the microstructure. Second-order phase transitions have been associated with the percolation of ordered regions surrounding a dislocation network ( Dubrovskiǐ and Krivoglaz, 1979 ) . A connection has also been made between single slip in a forest of dislocations (forest hardening) and the second-order phase transition of an Ising model ( Ortiz, 1999 ) . Furthermore, a second-order phase transition has been experimentally observed in the change from stage III (characterised by a linearly decreasing work-hardening coefficient) to stage IV in the plastic deformation of copper (characterised by a constant work-hardening coefficient) ( Schafler et al., 2005 ) and it has been noted that plastic slip avalanches follow scaling and universality laws that are typical of phase transitions ( Friedman et al., 2012 ; Solé, 2011 ) . The Ising model ( Ising, 1925 ) (and other such statistical-mechanical models) is famous for its description of phase transitions in ferromagnetism, as well as other physical applications (e.g. see Wang, 2024 ). A parallel between electromagnetism and plasticity mechanics has been remarked upon previously by Holländer, 1960 . Nevertheless, the continuum models fail to describe the strange behaviour observed at the scale limit of the very small, because the continuum itself is an inappropriate approximation. Kröner, 1995 ; Kröner, 2001 recognised that, since defects can only exist in contrast with a surrounding ordered structure, they cannot be explicitly described by a continuum – because a continuum is, by definition, a homogeneous structure. Continuum models carry with them the implicit assumption of the permanence of points or volume elements and of a topology stationary in time. An expression of the kind x=x(X,t) assumes that the particles described by coordinates x in the current configuration and by X in a reference configuration are immutable, but the movement of dislocations displaces atoms inhomogeneously, which causes X\rightarrow x to not be a bijective function. This produces a discontinuous displacement field, which cannot be treated appropriately in a continuum theory. Similarly, dislocations modify volume elements, so that the current configuration cannot be mapped back to the reference configuration by a bijective function. Therefore, a crystal undergoing plastic deformation has neither point permanence nor a stationary topology. One renowned alternative is that of discrete dislocation dynamics (DDD). However, this approach has a high computational cost, in part because it attempts to mix discrete methods with continuous methods, namely in the sense that dislocations exist as geometric lines in a continuum but their stress fields are functions of continuous coordinates (cf. Gurrutxaga-Lerma et al., 2013 ). Furthermore, it has been shown that the discretisation of the slip planes, rather than the dislocation lines, is a more appropriate procedure when compromising averaging errors with computational cost ( Roy et al., 2008 ; Sandfeld et al., 2013 ) . Then, the question arises as to whether it is possible to have a fully discrete model of plasticity, with discrete dislocation lines and discrete planes as well as discrete stress and strain. To achieve this vision, one would have to abandon the traditional vector calculus altogether. Most prominently, the use of exterior calculus has gained traction over the past couple of decades, due to its close relationship with differential geometry and its natural partition of the continuum into the direct sum of spaces of objects with different geometric dimensions ( k -forms) — e.g. see Rashad et al., 2023 for non-linear elasticity and see Hochrainer and Zaiser, 2005 and Sozio and Yavari, 2023 for dislocation plasticity. Still, the continuum assumption is present in these approaches, because the underlying mathematical space is a continuum. The crucial point is in making the stress and strain fields discrete as well – that is, functions of discrete spaces rather than continua. It is important to note that dislocation motion is fundamentally a two-dimensional phenomenon. Two volume elements slide over each other along a two-dimensional interface which determines the discontinuity, and the boundary of that interface is the dislocation line. This has been previously recognised in the literature ( Xia and El-Azab, 2015 ) . Wijnen et al., 2021 successfully implemented a model of plastic slip where

Read the complete text