On testing the class of symmetry using entropy characterization and empirical likelihood approach
Ganesh Vishnu Avhad, Ananya Lahiri, Sudheesh K. Kattumannil · 2025
Read On testing the class of symmetry using entropy characterization and empirical likelihood approach by Ganesh Vishnu Avhad, Ananya Lahiri, Sudheesh K. Kattumannil (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08565.txt.
Introduction
Ganesh Vishnu Avhad, Ananya Lahiri, and Sudheesh Kattumannil work on a classic statistics question: how can one test whether a data distribution is symmetric? Their 2025 paper starts from a new result that characterizes symmetric distributions through entropy, a measure of randomness. That result becomes the base for a test that makes few assumptions about the data.
From this base, the authors build two tests based on jackknife empirical likelihood, one of them an adjusted version. They work out the large-sample behavior of both tests on paper. Then they run wide Monte Carlo simulations to see how the tests perform on samples of realistic size. The new tests beat existing rivals in those trials, the authors report. Two real datasets close the paper, showing how the tests work in practice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ganesh Vishnu Avhad, Ananya Lahiri, Sudheesh K. Kattumannil |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08565
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On testing the class of symmetry using entropy characterization and empirical likelihood approach Ganesh Vishnu Avhad, Ananya Lahiri, Sudheesh K. Kattumannil Abstract In this paper, we obtain a new characterization result for symmetric distributions based on the entropy measure. Using the characterization, we propose a nonparametric test to test the symmetry of a distribution. We also develop the jackknife empirical likelihood and the adjusted jackknife empirical likelihood ratio tests. The asymptotic properties of the proposed test statistics are studied. We conduct extensive Monte Carlo simulation studies to assess the finite sample performance of the proposed tests. The simulation results indicate that the jackknife empirical likelihood and adjusted jackknife empirical likelihood ratio tests show better performance than the existing tests. Finally, two real data sets are analysed to illustrate the applicability of the proposed tests. 1 Introduction In probability and statistics, the assessment of distributional symmetry is a fundamental problem. Many classical statistical procedures, such as the sign test and Wilcoxon signed-rank test, depend on the assumption of symmetry to ensure optimal performance. Methods such as trimmed means and M -estimators are constructed, particularly under the assumption of symmetry in the data. Symmetry improves the effectiveness of resampling methods such as the bootstrap by accelerating the convergence of confidence intervals via the pivotal quantity. Symmetrically distributed pivotal quantities often lead to more accurate inferential outcomes, making the assumption of symmetry advantageous in a range of applications. In finance, models such as the Sharpe–Lintner capital asset pricing model and the Black–Scholes option pricing model heavily rely on symmetric about zero assumptions ( Davison and Mamba, 2017 ). The literature extensively examines various aspects of the symmetry of probability distributions, with numerous authors investigating the properties of symmetric distributions (see, e.g. Ushakov, 2011 , Ahmadi, 2021 , Husseiny et al., 2024 and the references therein). Symmetric distributions are utilized by traders in the financial sector to forecast the value of assets over time, with the mean reversion hypothesis positing that asset prices will eventually revert to their long-term mean or average values based on the assumption of a symmetric distribution of prices over time, see Ahmed et al., 2018 . The broad applicability of symmetric assumptions in statistical modelling has been well-documented; however, Partlett and Patil, 2017 reported potential issues with the indiscriminate fitting of symmetric distributions to data, emphasizing the potential risks associated with such practices. Therefore, the first step in any robust statistical inference involving symmetric distributions is to evaluate whether the data align sufficiently with the symmetry assumption. As a result of its wide range of practical uses, several goodness-of-fit tests for symmetric distributions using different approaches are available in the literature. The most famous classical sign and Wilcoxon signed-rank test (see, e.g. Feuerverger and Mureika, 1977 and Maesono, 1987 ), and its modified version can be found in Vexler et al., 2023 . Symmetry holds significant relevance in non-parametric statistics and structured models, where a common assumption is that errors are distributed symmetrically. In the regression setup, Allison and Pretorius, 2017 conducted an extensive Monte Carlo simulation study to test whether the error distribution in the linear regression model is symmetric. Additionally, several papers offer comparative analyses of symmetry tests; see Maesono, 1987 , Farrell and Rogers-Stewart, 2006 , Milošević and Obradović, 2019 and Ivanović et al., 2020a . Characterization theorems play a crucial role, particularly in the development of goodness-of-fit tests; one may refer to Marchetti and Mudholkar, 2002 and Nikitin, 2017 . Tests based on characterization provide a robust framework for assessing symmetry and have been applied to various families of distributions. Recently, Milošević and Obradović, 2016 , Ahmadi and Fashandi, 2019 and Božin et al., 2020 proposed characterization-based tests for the univariate symmetry of the distribution. The entropy measures serve as a compelling alternative to traditional symmetry measures ( Fashandi and Ahmadi, 2012 ). Entropy, a notion built upon information theory, quantifies the uncertainty associated with a probability distribution. It captures the inherent randomness and disorder within the data, providing an in-depth perspective on distributional characteristics. Several forms of entropy, such as Shannon entropy, Rényi entropy, and Tsallis entropy, have been developed to address different aspects of uncertainty. Recently, several papers have been published on the characterization of distribution functions using the entropies of order statistics and record values. Ahmadi and Fashandi, 2019 introduced several characterization results for symmetric continuous distributions, which are established based on the properties of order statistics and various information measures. Ahmadi, 2020 obtained a characterization of the symmetric continuous distributions based on the properties of k -records and spacings. Ahmadi, 2021 , Jose and Abdul Sathar, 2022 and Gupta and Chaudhary, 2024 developed new tests for the distributional symmetry based on the different information measures. Thomas and Grunkemeier, 1975 introduced the first paper to find the empirical likelihood-based confidence intervals for survival data analysis. The empirical likelihood method is a powerful non-parametric approach that does not depend on specific parametric assumptions, and inference based on it does not require variance estimation. Jing et al., 2009 introduced the jackknife empirical likelihood (JEL) approach, integrating two non-parametric techniques: the jackknife and empirical likelihood. Since then, various tests based on JEL have been developed and explored in the literature. Some of the recent works in this area can be found in Liu et al., 2023 , Huang et al., 2024 , Chen et al., 2024 and Suresh and Kattumannil, 2025 . For a comprehensive overview of the JEL method, including recent advancements, the reader is referred to the review articles by Lazar, 2021 and Liu and Zhao, 2023 . In addition, the JEL method can face challenges due to the empty set problem, as noted by Chen et al., 2008 and Jing et al., 2017 . To enhance the accuracy of JEL, several techniques have been introduced, including bootstrap calibration ( Owen, 1988 ) and Bartlett correction ( Chen and Cui, 2007 ). To address both the empty set issue and low coverage probability, the adjusted jackknife empirical likelihood (AJEL) method was proposed by Chen et al., 2008 and Wang et al., 2015 . In what follows, we introduce a novel entropy-based characterization for the symmetric distributions and propose a class of goodness-of-fit tests for the symmetric distributions. The rest of the article is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we provide characterization results of the symmetric distributions based on the entropy measure, and with a few examples, we demonstrate the results. In Section 3 , based on the random samples X_{1},X_{2},...,X_{n} from an unknown distribution F , nonparametric goodness-of-fit test procedure is developed to test H_{0}:F\in F_{S} against H_{1}:F\notin F_{S} , where F_{S} = { F : F is a class of symmetric distributions}. We also propose JEL and AJEL ratio tests for distribution symmetry based on the characterization introduced in Section 2 . In Section 4 , the finite sample performance of the proposed tests is evaluated and compared with other symmetry tests through a Monte Carlo simulation study. Section 5 presents and analyses two real examples. Finally, Section 6 concludes with some closing remarks. 2 Characterization result based on entropy measure Since the test is based on the entropy measure, we begin by modifying the generalized entropy measure obtained by