The matter with(in) CPL

Leonardo Giani, Rodrigo von Marttens, Oliver Fabio Piattella · 2025

Read The matter with(in) CPL by Leonardo Giani, Rodrigo von Marttens, Oliver Fabio Piattella (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08467.txt.

Introduction

Leonardo Giani, Rodrigo von Marttens, and Oliver Piattella propose a twist on the standard cosmology model, in a 2025 paper. In their version, ordinary matter stops behaving like pressure-free dust at late times. Below a chosen transition redshift, its equation of state drifts away from zero.

The team fits this two-parameter extension against fresh data: baryon acoustic oscillations, supernova distances, and early-universe distance measures. They compare it with the popular CPL formula for evolving dark energy. By a standard model-selection score, the two are nearly indistinguishable. Both beat the standard model by a clear margin. The authors note the setup arises naturally in cosmological backreaction, where averaging lumpy space changes the effective equations. They derive a prediction for how structure growth evolves, which low-redshift surveys can test.

Catalog record

CREATORLeonardo Giani, Rodrigo von Marttens, Oliver Fabio Piattella
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08467

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The matter with(in) CPL Leonardo Giani, Rodrigo von Marttens, Oliver Fabio Piattella Abstract We introduce a two-parameter phenomenological extension of the Λ \Lambda CDM model in which the equation of state parameter of the “dust” fluid becomes different from zero for redshifts below a transition value z t z_{t} . Using data from DESI DR2 BAO, DESY5 Sn Ia and CMB distance priors ( R , l A , ω b R,l_{A},\omega_{b} ) data, we compare our model with the standard CPL parameterization w 0 − w a w_{0}-w_{a} for dynamical dark energy. Using the Deviance Information Criteria (DIC), we find that the two models are essentially indistinguishable ( Δ \Delta DIC < < 2) and preferred over Λ \Lambda CDM with a significance ≥ 3 ​ σ \geq 3\sigma . We discuss how this parameterization finds a natural interpretation in the context of cosmological backreaction and derive a prediction for the evolution of the growth factor, discussing its impact on low redshift f ​ σ 8 f\sigma_{8} measurements. 1 Motivation During the past couple of years, the combination of Sn Ia and BAO measurements from DES ( Abbott et al., 2024 ) and DESI ( Adame et al., 2024a ; Adame et al., 2024b ; Abdul Karim et al., 2025 ) with CMB observations ( Aghanim et al., 2020 ) (or weak lensing measurements ( Abbott et al., 2022 ) ) revealed a \sim 3\sigma ’s strong preference for Dynamical Dark Energy (DDE) over the cosmological constant \Lambda . This preference is usually quantified using the Chevallier-Polarsky-Linder (CPL) parametrization ( Chevallier and Polarski, 2001 ; Linder, 2003 ) , essentially a first order Taylor expansion at low redshift of the dark energy equation of state parameter w , but it has been shown to be robust even considering different dark energy models or parametrizations ( Giarè et al., 2024 ; Jiang et al., 2024 ; Roy, 2025 ; Sakr, 2025 ; Wolf et al., 2025a ) . Whilst this exciting result might indeed provide insights on the fundamental nature of Dark Energy, the fact that its equation of state parameter crosses the ridge w=-1 is concerning from a theoretical point of view, as it suggests a dark energy fluid exhibiting phantom behavior. For these reasons, a number of works ( Cortês and Liddle, 2024 ; Shlivko and Steinhardt, 2024 ; Ye and Lin, 2025 ; Roy Choudhury and Okumura, 2024 ; Colgáin and Sheikh-Jabbari, 2024 ; Gialamas et al., 2025 ; Colgáin et al., 2024 ; Wolf et al., 2025b ; Colgáin et al., 2025 ; Wolf et al., 2025c ; Roy Choudhury, 2025 ) have tried to understand what feature of the data drives the preference for w_{0}w_{a} over the cosmological constant and whether or not phantom crossing is a necessary condition or just an artifact of the chosen parametrization. The individual datasets, when interpreted using a flat \Lambda CDM model, somewhat disagree on their inferred value of the present day matter density. In fact, BAO prefers \Omega_{m}^{\rm{DESI}}\approx 0.29\pm 10^{-3} , whereas CMB indicates \Omega_{m}^{\rm{Planck}}\approx 0.31\pm 10^{-3} and supernovae \Omega_{m}^{\rm{DESY5}}\approx 0.35\pm 10^{-2} . One would naturally conclude that \Lambda CDM seemingly does not have sufficient freedom (or parameters) to provide a consistent cosmological evolution. With the above motivation in mind, in this work we introduce a novel two-parameter extension of the \Lambda CDM model, where rather than modifying the evolution of the dark energy fluid, we focus on the matter equation of state parameter. We formulate the following ansatz for the total (baryonic plus dark ) matter density: \rho_{m}=\tilde{\rho}^{\rm{dust}}_{0}\left(1+z\right)^{3}f(z_{t},\epsilon,z)\;,\qquad f(z_{t},\epsilon,z)\equiv\left[\Theta\left(z-z_{t}\right)+\frac{\left(1+z\right)^{\epsilon}}{\left(1+z_{t}\right)^{\epsilon}}\Theta\left(z_{t}-z\right)\right]\;, (1) describing a perfect fluid whose equation of state parameter transitions from w=0 for z>z_{t} to w=\frac{\epsilon}{3} at later times z<z_{t} . In the above, \Theta(x) is the Heaviside theta function: \Theta(x)=1 if x>0 and \Theta(x)=0 otherwise, and where \tilde{\rho}^{\rm{dust}}_{0} represents the density that a standard dust fluid (without transition) would have at redshift zero starting from the same initial conditions. One can easily compute the difference between the two at present day: \rho_{m}(z=0)=\frac{\tilde{\rho}^{\rm{dust}}_{0}}{\left(1+z_{t}\right)^{\epsilon}}\;. (2) This parametrization finds a natural interpretation in the context of cosmological backreaction ( Buchert and Ehlers, 1997 ; Clarkson et al., 2011 ; Bolejko and Korzyński, 2017 ) . The distribution of the matter “fluid elements” across cosmic epochs is very different. Early in the evolution of the Universe, perturbations of the matter fluid are small, as reflected by the temperature fluctuations of the CMB. However, they are bounded to grow in an expanding Universe, eventually resulting in the complex web of inhomogeneities that we observe in the Universe today. The possible impact of these inhomogeneities on cosmological measurements and the overall expansion history of the Universe is subject of debate, with a spectrum of possibilities ranging from negligible impact ( Kaiser, 2017 ; Ishibashi and Wald, 2006 ; Green and Wald, 2011 ) to being responsible for the observed accelerated expansion of the Universe ( Rasanen, 2004 ; Wiltshire, 2009 ; Buchert, 2008 ) . It has also been recognized that in this era of high-precision cosmology, at least in our cosmic neighborhood, these inhomogeneities can lead to systematic biases in our cosmological inference even in the framework of the \Lambda CDM model ( Heinesen, 2021 ; Bolejko et al., 2016 ; Giani et al., 2024a ; Giani et al., 2024b ; Heinesen and Macpherson, 2022 ; Anton and Clifton, 2023 ) . For our purposes, it is enough to recognize that the strong gravitational interactions between dark matter fluid elements in the late Universe at various scales justify possible deviations on the overall equation of state parameter of the matter fluid averaged on large volumes, as described by Eq. ( 1 ). We model the transition to such a different behavior with an instantaneous process (as reflected by the Heaviside step distribution), because properly characterizing a smoothed process would unavoidably introduce a new parameter \delta\tau accounting for the transition timescale, and as thoroughly discussed in Refs. ( Linder and Huterer, 2005 ; Di Valentino et al., 2017 ) , current observations are insufficient to effectively constrain dark energy parametrizations with more than two free parameters. In summary, Eq. ( 1 ) can be considered as an effective description of a matter fluid whose averaged (integrated) equation of state parameter between 0<z<z_{t} is \epsilon . Volume averages of cosmological quantities in inhomogeneous spacetimes, as described for example in Buchert and Carfora (2003) ; Buchert and Räsänen (2012) , result in modified Friedmann equations containing contributions from the kinematic backreaction and the spatial curvature terms, which in the past have been suggested as a possible alternative to dark energy. In this work, however, we rather assume that for an observer with no information about the true geometry of the spacetime, these terms are degenerate with what they identify as ”matter”, leading to a different cosmological evolution for the latter. This applies both to the case of local inhomogeneities ( Marra et al., 2022 ; Chirinos Isidro et al., 2017 ; Giani et al., 2024a ) , such as an observer within an LTB region, and to the case of average over multiple inhomogeneities, such as the models discussed in Giani et al. (2024b) ; Marra et al. (2007) ; Barbosa et al. (2016)

Read the complete text