Ground-based Observations of Temporal Variation of Cosmic Ray Spectrum during Forbush Decreases

W. Mitthumsiri, D. Ruffolo, K. Munakata, M. Kozai, Y. Hayashi, C. Kato, P. Muangha, A. Sáiz, P. Evenson, P.-S. Mangeard, J. Clem, S. Seunarine, W. Nuntiyakul, N. Miyashita, R. Kataoka, A. Kadokura, S. Miyake, K. Iwai, H. Menjo, E. Echer, A. Dal Lago, M. Rockenbach, N. J. Schuch, J. V. Bageston, C. R · 2025

Read Ground-based Observations of Temporal Variation of Cosmic Ray Spectrum during Forbush Decreases by W. Mitthumsiri, D. Ruffolo, K. Munakata, M. Kozai, Y. Hayashi, C. Kato, P. Muangha, A. Sáiz, P. Evenson, P.-S. Mangeard, J. Clem, S. Seunarine, W. Nuntiyakul, N. Miyashita, R. Kataoka, A. Kadokura, S. Miyake, K. Iwai, H. Menjo, E. Echer, A. Dal Lago, M. Rockenbach, N. J. Schuch, J. V. Bageston, C. R (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08248.txt.

Introduction

Mitthumsiri and a large international team show that ground detectors can track the energy spectrum of cosmic rays during solar storms. Their 2025 paper concerns Forbush decreases, the dips in galactic cosmic ray flow when a solar storm sweeps past Earth. Such events matter for space weather warning, yet the spectrum's shape in space is usually measured only by satellites.

Two techniques get the spectrum from the ground. One fits the drops in count rates across a global web of neutron monitors and muon detectors, allowing the flow to vary with direction. The other reads a leader fraction statistic from a single neutron monitor. On five major storms both methods agreed, hour by hour, and matched daily satellite data where it existed. The leader fraction now runs publicly in real time. The work verifies precise spectrum watching from the ground across a wide energy span.

Catalog record

CREATORW. Mitthumsiri, D. Ruffolo, K. Munakata, M. Kozai, Y. Hayashi, C. Kato, P. Muangha, A. Sáiz, P. Evenson, P.-S. Mangeard, J. Clem, S. Seunarine, W. Nuntiyakul, N. Miyashita, R. Kataoka, A. Kadokura, S. Miyake, K. Iwai, H. Menjo, E. Echer, A. Dal Lago, M. Rockenbach, N. J. Schuch, J. V. Bageston, C. R
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08248

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ground-based Observations of Temporal Variation of Cosmic Ray Spectrum during Forbush Decreases W. Mitthumsiri, D. Ruffolo, K. Munakata, M. Kozai, Y. Hayashi, C. Kato, P. Muangha, A. Sáiz, P. Evenson, P.-S. Mangeard, J. Clem, S. Seunarine, W. Nuntiyakul, N. Miyashita, R. Kataoka, A. Kadokura, S. Miyake, K. Iwai, H. Menjo, E. Echer, A. Dal Lago, M. Rockenbach, N. J. Schuch, J. V. Bageston, C. R. Braga, H. K. Al Jassar, M. M. Sharma, N. Burahmah, F. Zaman, M. L. Duldig, I. Sabbah, T. Kuwabara Abstract Observations of temporary Forbush decreases (FDs) in the Galactic cosmic ray (GCR) flux due to passage of solar storms are useful for space weather studies and alerts. Here we introduce techniques that use global networks of ground-based neutron monitors and muon detectors to measure variations of GCR rigidity spectra in space during FDs by: A) fitting count rate decreases for power-law rigidity spectra in space with anisotropy up to second order, and B) using the “leader fraction” derived from a single neutron monitor. We demonstrate that both provide consistent results for hourly spectral index variations for five major FDs and they agree with daily space-based data when available from AMS-02. We have also made the neutron monitor leader fraction publicly available in real time. This work verifies that ground-based observations can be used to precisely monitor GCR spectral variation over a wide range of rigidities during space weather events, with results in real time or from short-term post-analysis. Accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal Letters I Introduction Solar flares and interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICMEs) have various impacts on human activity known as space weather effects [ 19 ] . Among the numerous techniques used to provide warnings of ongoing space weather events, one avenue focuses on effects of interplanetary shocks and their ICME drivers on Galactic cosmic rays (GCRs), including temporary Forbush decreases (FDs) [ 16 , 13 ] (for an example of an automated FD warning system, see https://www.sws.bom.gov.au/Geophysical/1/4 ). A related method watches for an anisotropic precursory decrease before the arrival of an interplanetary shock, i.e., a loss-cone decrease in GCR ions from certain directions before a Forbush decrease, which can in principle provide advance warning up to 12 hours before certain space weather effects [ 29 , 7 , 32 , 31 , 21 , 30 ] . Real-time space weather warning systems based on cosmic ray ions commonly use ground-based detectors of atmospheric secondary particles, monitoring the count rate due to the detector response over a wide range of primary cosmic ray energies. The most commonly used detectors are neutron monitors (NMs) [ 34 , 17 ] , which can provide stable monitoring of count rates over time scales up to decades [ 35 ] . However, precise determination of short-term variation in the GCR energy (or rigidity) spectrum has been more challenging; for example, a comparison between count rates of NMs with different geomagnetic cutoffs (thresholds) may not correctly indicate short-term changes in the spectral index, presumably due to local atmospheric effects on the count rates [ 33 ] . Therefore, techniques have been developed using specially designed electronics to record the distribution of time delays from one neutron arrival to the next in an NM [ 9 ] , and from this distribution to extract the leader fraction [ 33 ] (inverse neutron multiplicity) as a measure of the cosmic ray spectral index \mathit{\Gamma} (i.e., negative logarithmic slope of the cosmic intensity vs. rigidity P=pc/q , where p is the particle’s momentum and q is its charge). Measuring the spectral index at a single NM avoids systematic errors from local atmospheric effects on the count rate, which are effectively divided out when calculating the leader fraction. GCR intensity variation observed at ground level generally consists of two components: 1) temporal variation in GCR density (or the isotropic component of intensity) and 2) variation because of GCR directional anisotropy, as the detector’s look direction changes with Earth’s rotation. To analyze these components separately and accurately requires global detector networks that simultaneously monitor the whole sky around Earth. NMs, which detect atmospheric secondary neutrons, have a maximum response to primary GCRs with median rigidities between 10 GV and 35 GV. An NM is an omnidirectional detector, with a response dominated by nearly vertically incident GCRs, so anisotropy information is obtained either from a single detector, as Earth rotates [ 14 ] , or over faster timescales by comparing data from NMs with different look directions [ 4 , 10 ] . Muon detectors (MDs) detect muons produced through the hadronic interaction between GCRs and atmospheric nuclei. Because a higher primary energy is needed to produce muons with sufficient Lorentz factor and relativistic time dilation to reach ground level before decaying, muon detectors (MDs) have a response to primary GCRs with higher median rigidities, between \sim 50 and \sim 100 GV. A single MD can have numerous directional channels because the incident directions of muons closely represent the incident directions of primary GCRs at the top of the atmosphere. The Global Muon Detector Network (GMDN) was established in 2006 with four multidirectional surface muon detectors at Nagoya (Japan), Hobart (Australia), Kuwait City (Kuwait), and São Martinho (Brazil) [ 31 ] . The global fit analysis of data from networks of NMs and MDs worldwide allows us to accurately separate anisotropy from spectral effects [ 26 ] , and deduce the GCR rigidity spectrum over a wide rigidity range. Such information can only be derived from the cosmic ray measurements and observationally constrains the three-dimensional macroscopic picture of the interaction between coronal mass ejections and the ambient solar wind, which is essential for prediction of large magnetic storms [ 18 ] . Daily fluxes of protons (which dominate GCR ions) from the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer (AMS-02) experiment on board the International Space Station (ISS) are available for 2011-2019, during the previous sunspot cycle [ 1 ] . Wang et al. [37] recently analyzed these data to determine GCR spectral variation during a large number of FDs. The AMS-02 detector can identify the species and rigidity of charged cosmic rays with a large geometric factor [ 2 ] . It orbits Earth along with ISS, with a period of 93 min and orbital inclination of 52 ∘ . While the viewing direction and geomagnetic cutoff (threshold) rigidity of the detector rapidly change during its orbit and it does not evenly sample the entire sky, the daily averages provide a reasonable estimate of the omnidirectional cosmic ray spectrum. Here we present the temporal variation of the GCR rigidity spectral index \mathit{\Gamma} measured from the South Pole leader fraction and from global fit analysis of NM and MD count rates during five FDs, including comparison with the AMS-02 data that are available for three of the FDs. II Data and Analysis Methods II.1 AMS-02 data We use the daily proton rigidity spectrum measured by AMS-02 from 20 May 2011 to 29 October 2019 [ 1 ] . The proton flux \Phi_{k} given in each of 30 rigidity bins is assigned to the geometric mean P_{k} of minimum and maximum rigidities of the k -th rigidity bin, with P_{k} values ranging from 1.10 GV to 83.50

Read the complete text