On near superperfect numbers, the Goormaghtigh conjecture, and Mertens’ theorem
Satvik Beri, Joshua Zelinsky · 2025
Read On near superperfect numbers, the Goormaghtigh conjecture, and Mertens’ theorem by Satvik Beri, Joshua Zelinsky (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08160.txt.
Introduction
Satvik Beri and Joshua Zelinsky extend results on near superperfect numbers and link them to two classic topics, in a paper from 2025. A near superperfect number almost equals a double divisor-sum formula, off by one of its own divisors. Such fringe number classes can hide deep connections.
They broaden earlier results on these numbers and connect them to a conjecture about exponential Diophantine equations and to prime products of Mertens type. They also define a second type where the offset divisor divides the divisor sum instead. Analogous theorems are proved for the new class, which widens the theory in both directions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Satvik Beri, Joshua Zelinsky |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08160
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On near superperfect numbers, the Goormaghtigh conjecture, and Mertens’ theorem Satvik Beri, Joshua Zelinsky Abstract Let σ ( n ) \sigma(n) be the sum of the divisors of n n . Kalita and Saikia defined a number n n to be near superperfect if 2 n + d = σ ( σ ( n ) ) 2n+d=\sigma(\sigma(n)) for some positive divisor d d of n n . We extend some of their results about near superperfect numbers and connect these results to the Goormaghtigh conjecture and to certain products of primes similar to those which appear in Mertens’ theorem. We also define type II near superperfect numbers, which are those n n satisfying 2 n + d = σ ( σ ( n ) ) 2n+d=\sigma(\sigma(n)) for some positive divisor d d of σ ( n ) \sigma(n) , and prove analogous results about these numbers. 1 Introduction Let \sigma(n) be the sum of the positive divisors of n . A number is said to be perfect if n satisfies the equation \sigma(n)=2n . A number is said to be abundant if \sigma(n)>2n and is said to be deficient if \sigma(n)<2n . Two of the oldest unsolved problems in mathematics are whether there are infinitely many even perfect numbers and whether there are any odd perfect numbers. A wide variety of work on the second problem has occurred in the last few years. For example, Acquaah and Konyagin [ 1 ] showed that if n is an odd perfect number, then its largest prime factor is at most (3n)^{\frac{1}{3}} . Two subsequent papers, one by the second author and the other by the second author with Bibby and Vyncke [ 39 , 4 ] , proved similar upper bounds for the second and third largest prime factor. In terms of lower bounds, Goto and Ohno [ 25 ] proved that the largest prime factor of such a number must be at least 10^{8} . Similar lower bounds for the second and third largest prime factor are due to Iannucci [ 16 , 17 ] . There are also similar bounds for the size of such an n in general, with Ochem and Rao [ 23 ] showing that one must have n<10^{1500} . Ochem in as-yet unpublished work extended this lower bound to 10^{2000} but pushing this bound further will be difficult without substantial new insights. Upper bounds for n in terms of its number of prime factors have also been proven. The first such bound, which grows rapidly, was given by Pomerance [ 27 ] . This was subsequently greatly reduced by Heath-Brown [ 26 ] who showed that if n is an odd perfect number with k distinct prime factors then we must have n<4^{4^{k}}. Subsequent papers by Cook [ 13 ] , Nielsen [ 21 ] , and finally by Chen and Tang [ 6 ] have reduced this to n<2^{4^{k}-2^{k}}. A recently investigated bound is of the following type. Assume that n is an odd perfect number where n=p_{1}^{a_{1}}p_{2}^{a_{2}}\cdots p_{k}^{a_{k}} where the p_{i} are distinct primes. Then let \Omega(n)=a_{1}+a_{2}\cdots+a_{k} . That is, \Omega(n) is the total number of prime factors of n , counting repetitions. Ochem and Rao [ 22 ] have proved that N must satisfy \Omega(N)\geq\frac{18k-31}{7} (1) and \Omega(N)\geq 2k+51. (2) This bound was subsequently improved by the second author in a pair of papers [ 40 , 41 ] which were then surpassed by a paper by Clayton and Hansen [ 8 ] who proved that \Omega(n)\geq\frac{99}{37}k-\frac{187}{37}, and that if 3\nmid n , then one has the stronger result that \Omega(n)\geq\frac{51}{19}k-\frac{46}{19}. A recent direction has been to look at what Dris and Luca [ 12 ] called the index of a prime power of n . In particular, assume that p^{a}||n (that is, that p^{a}|n and p^{a+1}\nmid n ). Define the index of p^{a} with respect to n to be \sigma(n/p^{a})/p^{a} . They showed that for any such n and p^{a} , the index is greater than 5. This was greatly improved by Chen and Chen in a pair of papers [ 9 , 10 ] who showed among other results that the index is never of any of the forms q_{1}^{i} where q_{1} is prime and 1i\leq 4 . They also similarly ruled out the index being q_{1}q_{2} or q_{1}^{2}q_{2} for two distinct primes, along with 24 similar forms. This was then improved further by Gallardo [ 24 ] who showed how to rule out many additional forms. Despite these restrictions and many other results, we appear to be not anywhere close to proving the non-existence of odd perfect numbers. Not surprisingly then, many have tried to branch out to look at closely related problems, and a large number of variations on the idea of perfect numbers have been proposed. Pollack and Shevelev [ 28 ] defined a number n to be near perfect if it satisfies 2n+d=\sigma(n)) for some d>0 where d|n . The d in question is referred to as the omitted divisor or redundant divisor since one has that 2n=\sigma(n) if one omits d from the sum of the divisors of n . A variety of results concerning near perfect numbers have recently been proven. In their original paper, Pollack and Shevelev constructed three families of near perfect numbers: 1. 2^{t-1}(2^{t}-2^{k}-1) where 2^{t}-2^{k}-1 is prime. Here 2^{k} is the omitted divisor. 2. 2^{2p-1}(2^{p}-1) where 2^{p}-1 is prime. Here 2^{p}(2^{p}-1) is the omitted divisor. 3. 2^{p-1}(2^{p}-1)^{2} where 2^{p}-1 is prime. Here 2^{p}-1 is the omitted divisor. Subsequent work by Ren and Chen [ 29 ] showed that all near perfects with two distinct prime factors must be either 40 or a member of one of Pollack and Shevelev’s three families. Hasanalizade [ 15 ] proved that there are no odd near perfect Fibonacci or Lucas numbers, and that there are no near perfect Fibonacci numbers with fewer than three distinct prime factors. Tang, Ma, and Feng [ 33 ] showed that 173369889=(3^{4})(7^{2})(11^{2})(19^{2}) is the only odd near perfect number with four or fewer distinct prime divisors; currently this is the only odd near perfect number known. Similarly, Pollack and Shevelev defined a number to be s - near perfect if \sigma(n)=2n+d_{1}+d_{2}\cdots d_{s} where d_{1},d_{2},\cdots d_{s} are distinct positive divisors of n . Note that when s=1 these are just the usual near perfect numbers. Aryan, Madhavani, Parikh, Slattery, and the second author of this paper, in a recent paper [ 2 ] classified all 2 -near perfect numbers of the form 2^{k}p or 2^{k}p^{2} where p is an odd prime. In particular, they proved the following two theorems. Theorem 1 . Assume n is a 2 -near perfect number with omitted divisors d_{1} and d_{2} . Assume further that n=2^{k}p where p is prime and k is a positive integer. Then one must have, without loss of generality, one of four situations. 1. p=2^{k}-1 . Here we have d_{1}=1 and d_{2}=p . 2. p=2^{k+1}-2^{a}-2^{b}-1 for some a,b\in\mathbb{N} . Here d_{1}=2^{a} and d_{2}=2^{b} . 3. p=\frac{2^{k+1}-2^{a}-1}{1+2^{b}} for some a,b\in\mathbb{N} . Here d_{1}=2^{a} and d_{2}=2^{b}p . 4. p=\frac{2^{k+1}-1}{1+2^{a}+2^{b}} for some a,b\in\mathbb{N} . Here d_{1}=2^{a}p and d_{2}=2^{b}p . Theorem 2 . Assume that n is