One Bad NOFO? AI Governance in Federal Grantmaking Journal: JACM Volume: 37 4 111 8 Conference: The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency; June 23–26, 2025; Athens, Greece The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (FAccT ’25), June 23–26, 2025,
Dan Bateyko, Karen Levy · 2025
Read One Bad NOFO? AI Governance in Federal Grantmaking Journal: JACM Volume: 37 4 111 8 Conference: The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency; June 23–26, 2025; Athens, Greece The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (FAccT ’25), June 23–26, 2025, by Dan Bateyko, Karen Levy (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-08133.txt.
Introduction
Dan Bateyko and Karen Levy study a quiet channel of AI policy in a 2025 paper: federal grant notices. Agencies shape AI not only by rules and their own use, but also by the grants they offer. Those grants send billions to states, cities, and researchers who build and use AI.
The authors built a dataset of more than forty thousand grant notices posted from 2009 to 2024. Among notices that mention AI, agencies mostly cheer adoption in their program stories. Very few set AI-specific judging criteria or limits on how winners may use AI. The gap means much grant-driven AI grows with little stated oversight. The paper urges scholars and agencies to treat grant terms as a real lever of AI governance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dan Bateyko, Karen Levy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-08133
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
One Bad NOFO? AI Governance in Federal Grantmaking Journal: JACM Volume: 37 4 111 8 Conference: The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency; June 23–26, 2025; Athens, Greece The 2025 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (FAccT ’25), June 23–26, 2025, Athens, Greece DOI: 10.1145/3715275.3732109 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1482-5/2025/06 CCS: Social and professional topics Governmental regulations Dan Bateyko, Karen Levy Abstract . Much scholarship considers how U.S. federal agencies govern artificial intelligence (AI) through rulemaking and their own internal use policies. But agencies have an overlooked AI governance role: setting discretionary grant policy when directing billions of dollars in federal financial assistance. These dollars enable state and local entities to study, create, and use AI. This funding not only goes to dedicated AI programs, but also to grantees using AI in the course of meeting their routine grant objectives. As discretionary grantmakers, agencies guide and restrict what grant winners do—a hidden lever for AI governance. Agencies pull this lever by setting program objectives, judging criteria, and restrictions for AI use. Using a novel dataset of over 40,000 non-defense federal grant notices of funding opportunity (NOFOs) posted to Grants.gov between 2009 and 2024, we analyze how agencies regulate the use of AI by grantees. We select records mentioning AI and review their stated goals and requirements. We find agencies promoting AI in notice narratives, shaping adoption in ways other records of grant policy might fail to capture. Of the grant opportunities that mention AI, we find only a handful of AI-specific judging criteria or restrictions. This silence holds even when agencies fund AI uses in contexts affecting people’s rights and which, under an analogous federal procurement regime, would result in extra oversight. These findings recast grant notices as a site of AI policymaking—albeit one that is developing out of step with other regulatory efforts and incomplete in its consideration of transparency, accountability, and privacy protections. The paper concludes by drawing lessons from AI procurement scholarship, while identifying distinct challenges in grantmaking that invite further study. 1. Introduction In 2023, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) granted funds to public housing officials to curb crime through purchases such as security cameras for their properties. After HUD disbursed the funds, reporting shed light on grant winners who had repurposed the cameras to surveil their own residents—for example, using facial recognition to track tenants and video records to identify lease violations, justifying evictions. But when Congress members demanded that the funding agency intervene, the agency shrugged: housing officials had broken no rules. The grant program used to purchase the cameras banned neither extramural use of purchases nor artificial intelligence (AI) tools such as the camera’s facial recognition features ( MacMillan 2023 ) . With the grant’s spirit broken but its letter intact, who had the power to intervene? In AI policy, how U.S. federal agencies govern grants has gone overlooked. And understandably so. With grants, the government’s role would seem simple: give away money and step back. To be sure, agencies hold grant winners accountable for proper spending, creating significant reporting requirements. But while agencies conduct site visits and review grant reports ( cfr 2024 ) , they tend to focus more on fraud prevention than deep performance review ( Systems 2023 ) . Although agencies can recover funds if award winners veer from stated goals, they rarely exercise this authority ( Pasachoff 2014 ; Pasachoff 2020 ) . This perception of light-touch oversight may help explain why scholars across law ( Nagle 1994 ; Pasachoff 2014 ; Price 2019 ) , political science ( Berry et al. 2010 ) and economics ( Azoulay and Li 2020 ) note that their disciplines gloss over the mechanics of how agencies draw up grant policies. But grantmaking agencies have one key power: they can plan ahead. After facing backlash over the misuse of its crime grants, HUD banned automated surveillance in future grants, patching what its prior policy permitted ( MacMillan 2023 ) . Discretionary grants—where agencies have authority to select recipients—enable federal support for a broad range of activities, from basic research to capacity building, carried out by non-federal entities like states, local governments, nonprofits, and universities ( Grants [n. d.] ) . For these grants, agencies can conduct their own merit review of applicants ( CFR 2024a ) , typically through competitions where they set standards, convene judges, and crown winners ( Keegan 2012 ) . Agencies can make award winners follow certain terms, such as receiving technical help, submitting to monitoring, and passing key reviews ( CFR 2024a ) . These pre-award policies matter because agencies rarely can add new rules after funding begins ( Yeh 2017 ) . Through grant planning, agencies prioritize who and what gets funded, and put winners on notice to use their award appropriately—all ways in which federal agencies can influence how grantees use AI. This paper asks how agencies shape the use of AI technologies by grantees through agency-drawn priorities and conditions in discretionary grants. To do so, we examine a publicly available yet often overlooked data source: Notices of Funding Opportunity (“NOFOs”). These notices are more than simple announcements. NOFOs describe the purpose of a grant, specifying eligible and ineligible activities, review criteria, reporting requirements, and funding restrictions ( CFR 2024a ) . This article creates a novel dataset of these notices, analyzing them at scale for the first time to ask two key questions: (1) Which discretionary grants promote AI, and how? (2) What award-specific review criteria and restrictions do agencies set to regulate grantees’ use of AI? These questions gain urgency as rising federal AI funding thrusts more responsibility onto government agencies. Both the Biden and Trump administrations have pushed to expand AI grantmaking. In 2023, President Biden directed several agencies to prioritize funding for AI initiatives ( Biden 2023 ) . During his first term, President Trump called for increased AI research funding ( Vought 2020a ) and AI education through scholarships and training programs ( Exe 2019 ) . President Trump has continued this trajectory in his second term, issuing an Executive Order directing the Department of Education to support K-12 AI education through targeted grants ( Trump 2025a ) . Even in its 2026 presidential budget proposal, which aims to reduce federal spending, the Trump administration committed to sustained federal AI funding ( The White House 2025 ) . Congressional interest, too, has intensified. In 2021, the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence proposed doubling each year the non-defense AI research and development budget: from $8 billion in 2024 to $16 billion in 2025 and ultimately $32 billion by 2026 ( on Artificial Intelligence 2021 ) . A Senate AI working group endorsed this $32 billion target in its own roadmap ( bip 2024 ) . That road map earmarks specific agencies, but AI-targeted funds might soon spread across the broad landscape of grantmaking agencies, who use grants to fulfill critical public missions—from healthcare to national security to diplomacy. And that discretionary spending is significant; in 2024, government-wide obligations totaled over $239.5 billion ( Pro 2024 ) . A wave of grant applicants proposing to use AI to meet social challenges might test agency capacity and expertise. Agencies