Interplay between Electroweak Symmetry Breaking and Dark Matter Relic Density
Sreemanti Chakraborti, André Milagre, Rui Santos, João P. Silva · 2025
Read Interplay between Electroweak Symmetry Breaking and Dark Matter Relic Density by Sreemanti Chakraborti, André Milagre, Rui Santos, João P. Silva (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-07946.txt.
Introduction
Dark matter froze out of the hot early universe at an amount we can measure today, but the recipe depends on a subtle detail: the electroweak symmetry broke partway through the cooking. Sreemanti Chakraborti, André Milagre, Rui Santos, and João Silva quantify that detail in 2025 for Higgs portal dark matter.
When the symmetry breaks, particle masses and interaction rates shift, which changes how fast dark matter annihilates and so how much survives. Working through a concrete model, the authors show that ignoring the break can wrongly rule viable parameter regions in or out. They also give a model-independent way to size the error. The paper is a warning label for relic density calculations everywhere.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sreemanti Chakraborti, André Milagre, Rui Santos, João P. Silva |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-07946
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Interplay between Electroweak Symmetry Breaking and Dark Matter Relic Density Preprint: IPPP/25/26 Sreemanti Chakraborti, André Milagre, Rui Santos, João P. Silva Abstract Models of Dark Matter must contend with the fact that the presence of electroweak symmetry breaking along the thermal evolution of the Universe modifies the masses, interactions and, thus, the thermally averaged cross sections. We study in detail the impact of taking (not taking) the presence of the electroweak symmetry breaking into account in the calculations of the Dark Matter relic density, providing a model-independent measure of such differences. By focusing on a particular model, we show that ignoring this effect can lead to the inclusion (exclusion) of wrong (viable) regions of parameter space. I Introduction The spectrum of temperature fluctuations in the Cosmic Microwave Background has offered physicists an extraordinary opportunity to measure the relative abundances of the various energy components of the Universe. The structures that make up these fluctuations are consistent with the existence of a non-baryonic matter component that exceeds the amount of ordinary baryonic matter by a factor around five, offering, together with a number of experimental results from many other experimental sources Cirelli:2024ssz , compelling evidence for the existence of Dark Matter (DM). The best determination of the present DM relic density is Planck:2018vyg \Omega h^{2}|_{\rm Obs}=0.1200\pm 0.0012, (1) where \Omega is the current energy density in the form of DM relative to the critical energy density of the Universe, and h is today’s reduced Hubble constant in the units of 100\, km/s/MPc. Amongst the plethora of DM production mechanisms found in the literature DEramo:2010keq ; Hochberg:2014dra ; Kuflik:2015isi ; DAgnolo:2015ujb ; Pappadopulo:2016pkp ; Garny:2017rxs ; DAgnolo:2020mpt ; Smirnov:2020zwf ; Fitzpatrick:2020vba ; Kramer:2020sbb ; Hryczuk:2021qtz ; Bringmann:2021tjr , the thermal freeze-out scenario stands out for mirroring the thermal behavior of particles in the Standard Model (SM) Bauer:2017qwy . 1 1 1 Namely, photons and neutrinos. This mechanism assumes that in the early stages of our Universe, i.e. at very high temperatures, the interaction rate between DM and particles in the primordial thermal bath was strong enough to keep them in chemical and thermal equilibrium. However, as the Universe expanded and cooled, there arose a moment (the freeze-out instant) when the annihilation rate of DM into lighter particles became subdominant to the Hubble expansion rate, resulting in the decoupling of DM from the thermal plasma and the subsequent freeze-out of its comoving number density. In the freeze-out scenario, the present relic density is computed by solving the Boltzmann Equation, which describes the change in the number density of the DM species over time. As an input, one needs to provide a cosmological history for our universe (contained in the Hubble parameter) and a set of thermally averaged DM depletion processes (coming from the particle physics model chosen, provided it has a DM candidate). The solution to the Boltzmann Equation can then be written implicitly as an integral over all time . With this information, one may predict the corresponding DM relic density and test it against the observed value in Eq. ( 1 ). In practice, analytical and numerical solutions are hard to find, so one usually resorts to approximations to perform the aforementioned integral. One such approximation relies on the assumption that DM particles remain in thermal equilibrium with the primordial bath until the freeze-out instant, implying that the Boltzmann equation becomes dominated by DM depletion processes occurring at temperatures below freeze-out, and hence below the DM mass scale. In effect, this reduces the problem to integrating the Boltzmann Equation only from freeze-out to the present time Cline:2013gha ; Arcadi:2024ukq . Since the relevant integration range lies at lower temperatures, the process becomes effectively low-energy, and finite temperature corrections are typically neglected in this scenario. This contrasts with other DM production mechanisms where these higher-order corrections play an important role in accurately predicting the present DM abundance Baker:2017zwx ; Chakrabarty:2022bcn . The standard approach, therefore, is to calculate all thermally averaged DM depletion processes in the low-energy regime and input them into the Boltzmann Equation. However, this reasoning misses the unavoidable fact that the Higgs boson acquires a non-zero vacuum expectation value (vev), triggering electroweak symmetry breaking (EWSB) at temperatures around T_{\rm EWSB}\approx 160\, GeV Laine:2015kra . It is therefore expected that the particle masses and interaction rates change across the EWSB transition. In this sense, we propose an improved approach for calculating the DM relic density in which both before and after EWSB interactions are considered. As we will demonstrate, neglecting the effects of EWSB in the calculation of the DM relic density is especially concerning for DM candidates that freeze-out before EWSB and can lead to large discrepancies between the standard and improved approaches. We prove that the deviations from the standard approach are driven by a change in the freeze-out instant and/or by a change in the thermally averaged DM depletion processes. In addition, we provide an analytical way to quantify this deviation. Time-varying masses have been studied before in the context of Variable-Mass Particles, where a scalar DM candidate is coupled to a quintessence field Anderson:1997un ; Rosenfeld:2005pw ; Franca:2003zg ; in spontaneous freeze-out, where fermionic DM acquires its mass through an early phase transition, and freezes out due to its mass becoming larger than the plasma temperature Heurtier:2019beu ; in super-cool dark matter, where the universe undergoes a brief period of thermal inflation during which all particles become massless, leading to a dilution of the DM abundance Hambye:2018qjv ; and in the Flip-Flop vev mechanism, where an auxiliary scalar field acquires a temporary vacuum expectation value, inducing a period where DM is allowed to decay Baker:2018vos . Furthermore, inclusion of thermally averaged DM depletion processes before and after EWSB has been considered in a model with a light scalar DM candidate produced via freeze-in Heeba:2018wtf , and in a two-component DM model where one particle freezes in and the other freezes out Bhattacharya:2021rwh . Yet, to the best of our knowledge, the effect has not been studied in the case of a single freeze-out DM component, and a systematic comparison between the standard and improved approaches and its physical implications is lacking in the literature. The paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we start by discussing the standard way of computing thermal relic densities performed using the broken phase model throughout the thermal evolution of the Universe. Then, we repeat the calculation using the unbroken phase model before EWSB, and the broken phase model after EWSB, which we dub the improved approach. Figures of merit aimed at comparing the two approaches are introduced in Subsection II.3 . In Section III , we introduce a simple model illustrating the differences between the two approaches, which are quantitatively explored in Section IV . The conclusions appear in Section V . Several detailed aspects of the calculation have been relegated to the appendices. II Relic density: standard vs. improved approaches II.1 Relic density: the standard approach Consider a SM extension with a single DM candidate of mass m_{\rm DM} which, at high enough temperatures, is kept in thermal and chemical equilibrium with the primordial bath through 2\to 2 scattering processes. To calculate the present abundance of DM