State-wise Economic Viability of Long-Duration Energy Storage Systems in the United States

Alexandre Moreira, Patricia Silva, Miguel Heleno, André Marcato · 2025

Read State-wise Economic Viability of Long-Duration Energy Storage Systems in the United States by Alexandre Moreira, Patricia Silva, Miguel Heleno, André Marcato (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-07624.txt.

Introduction

Alexandre Moreira, Patricia Silva, Miguel Heleno, and Andre Marcato ask where long-duration energy storage pays off in the United States, in a 2025 paper. Such storage can firm up wind and solar power for days. The technology is young, and future costs are unsure. The team worked state by state.

For each of the 48 mainland states, they found the top cost at which storage stays worthwhile. Under a federal cost target, only four states could drop firm fossil plants without raising total costs. States with high storage value tended to have little thermal power and lots of wind. The map helps planners see where long storage helps first and where costs must fall further.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexandre Moreira, Patricia Silva, Miguel Heleno, André Marcato
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-07624

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

State-wise Economic Viability of Long-Duration Energy Storage Systems in the United States Alexandre Moreira, Patricia Silva, Miguel Heleno, André Marcato Abstract Long-duration energy storage (LDES) assets can be fundamental resources for the next-generation power systems. However, LDES technologies are still immature and their future technology costs remain highly uncertain. In this context, we perform in this paper an extensive study to estimate the maximum LDES technology costs (which we define as viability costs) under which LDES systems would be economically viable in each state of the contiguous U.S. according to their characteristics. Our results indicate that only 4 states (out of 48) would be able to remove firm conventional generation supported by LDES systems without increasing their total system costs under the current US-DOE cost target of US$ 1,100 kW − 1 \text{kW}^{-1} for multi-day LDES. In addition, we find that states with the highest LDES viability costs have in general low participation of thermal generation, a high share of wind generation, and higher thermal-related fixed operation and maintenance (FO&M) costs. † † equal-contributors: These authors contributed equally to this work. † † equal-contributors: These authors contributed equally to this work. 1 Introduction Long-duration energy storage (LDES) systems can play a pivotal role in future power systems as they have the capability to charge and discharge over extended periods of time either leveraging excess or compensating for insufficient momentaneous generation capacity. This capability allows LDES technologies to counterbalance a potential lack of sufficient availability of intermittent generation capacity for a sustained amount of time Zhang et al. 2020 , which is a service that short-duration energy storage (SDES) systems cannot support. Nonetheless, in the heterogeneous landscape of the energy systems in the United States, it is sill unclear what the thresholds would be for the economic viability of LDES systems in the regional power systems of the future. In general, the economic viability of LDES technologies is assessed in the current literature by means of assuming future technology cost projections. For instance, Colombo and Kurtz 2023 focuses on a capacity expansion study for California targeting years 2030, 2035, 2040, and 2045 while taking into account, as candidate resources, 100-h LDES systems with 50% and 80% round-trip efficiency. The LDES investment costs are assumed to range from US$ 1,715 \text{kW}^{-1} in 2030 to US$ 1,500 \text{kW}^{-1} and, based on this assumption, the authors in Colombo and Kurtz 2023 conclude that only the 80% round trip efficiency (RTE) LDES would be competitive with 4-h lithium-ion batteries. In Staadecker et al. 2024 , the authors examine how factors such as the share of wind and solar generation capacity, the availability of hydropower generation, and the deployment of new transmission capacity can impact the appetite for investments in LDES. Their study combines these factors into 39 capacity expansion scenarios, using the Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC) system and assuming, for candidate storage resources, overnight power capacity costs of US$ 19.58 \text{kW}^{-1} , along with annual operation and maintenance costs of US$ 6.10 \text{kW}^{-1} , and baseline energy capacity cost of US$ 22.43 \text{kWh}^{-1} . The Study finds that (i) wind-dominant regions would be ideally served by 10-h to 20-h storage resources, (ii) a reduced hydropower availability in hydro-dominant areas would increase the ideal duration of newly installed storage assets from around 6-h to 23-h, (iii) a variation of overnight energy capacity costs would imply in ideal durations ranging from 9-h to around 800-h. In Guerra et al. 2020 , the economic viability of different types of storage is assessed for the Western US power system by a proposed 3-step approach that consists of obtaining a capacity expansion solution, running a production cost analysis without seasonal storage and then repeating this run with seasonal storage. Based on their results, considering a given cost range, hydrogen seasonal storage with 1-week duration would be economically viable with power and energy technology costs lower or equal to around US$ 1507 \text{kW}^{-1} and US$ 1.8 \text{kWh}^{-1} , respectively, by 2025. In Hunter et al. 2021 , the capacity expansion and production cost model results from Zhang et al. 2020 are leveraged to compare the cost-effectiveness of different LDES technologies, in terms of levelized cost of energy (LCOE), to flexible power generation systems, such as natural gas combined cycle plants (NG-CC). Based on the considered reference technology costs, NG-CC are more competitive than any other options while, among the storage technologies, diabatic compressed air energy storage in a salt cavern (D-CAES—Salt) achieves the lowest LCOE values ranging from lower than US$ 200 MWh -1 for durations between 12 and 72 h to lower than US$ 400 MWh -1 for durations between 72 to 168 h (in 2018 USD). However, these values can dramatically change due to uncertainty in future investment costs of these technologies. Furthermore, Sepulveda et al. 2021 indicates that (i) power systems dominated by intermittent resources can have more than 10% decrease in total costs if the LDES energy capacity costs are limited to US$ 20 \text{kWh}^{-1} , (ii) LDES energy capacity costs would have to fall lower than US$ 10 \text{kWh}^{-1} to displace nuclear plants and lower than US$ 1 \text{kWh}^{-1} to able to displace natural gas with carbon capture storage (CCS). The relevance of the aforementioned works notwithstanding, emerging LDES technologies are currently immature and their future cost projections are highly uncertain. In this context, we introduced in Silva et al. 2024 two capacity expansion-based models to compute the viability costs below which LDES technologies would be economically viable from the system’s perspective. The first one is a baseline model where firm flexible generators are considered without LDES and the second one is an opportunity value model in which conventional flexible generators are removed and a given capacity (which varies through a sensitivity analysis) of LDES is included. To compute the LDES viability costs, we first obtain the maximum opportunity value for LDES given its main parameters (duration and efficiency) and the energy matrix of the system under consideration. We define this LDES maximum opportunity value as the maximum avoided cost that can be achieved when replacing conventional firm generators with a mix of intermittent power plants along with short-duration energy storage (SDES) and LDES systems. Then, the LDES viability costs are calculated as ratio between the LDES maximum opportunity value and its corresponding capacity. In this paper, we expand the methodology proposed in Silva et al. 2024 to calculate the LDES viability costs across the 48 contiguous U.S. states, focusing on 100-h duration systems, and to conduct an extensive analysis of the economic viability of LDES. Our analysis is based on information from comprehensive datasets from the NREL’s Cambium 2022 Gagnon et al. 2023 , the Regional Energy Deployment System (ReEDS) base Cole et al. 2021 , the 2022 Annual Technology Baseline (ATB) data NREL 2022 , and the Annual Energy Outlook (AEO) 2023 website information U.S. Energy Information Administration 2023 . Our results reveal a wide range of viability costs for LDES technologies across the States, from -US$ 11.81 \text{kW}^{-1} to US$ 5,993.94 \text{kW}^{-1} . While the US-DOE has set a 2030 cost target of US$ 1,100 \text{kW}^{-1} for multi-day LDES (36–160 hours) Scott et al. 2023 , our results indicate that this target

Read the complete text