Assessing the Latency of Network Layer Security in 5G Networks

Sotiris Michaelides, Jonathan Mucke, Martin Henze · 2025

Read Assessing the Latency of Network Layer Security in 5G Networks by Sotiris Michaelides, Jonathan Mucke, Martin Henze (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-07328.txt.

Introduction

Sotiris Michaelides, Jonathan Mucke, and Martin Henze measure the delay cost of network layer security in fifth generation mobile nets. Low delay is a star trait of the new nets for factories and key services, yet security adds work that may slow them. They test a classic secure tunnel on user and control paths.

Set right, that tunnel adds near no delay, which keeps it fit for real time use. A newer lean tunnel was checked as a rival to cut cost further. The classic tool, tuned well, wins the prime spot for securing time tight scenes, they find. Operators gain a clear guide.

Catalog record

CREATORSotiris Michaelides, Jonathan Mucke, Martin Henze
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-07328

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Assessing the Latency of Network Layer Security in 5G Networks Sotiris Michaelides, Jonathan Mucke, Martin Henze Abstract . In contrast to its predecessors, 5G supports a wide range of commercial, industrial, and critical infrastructure scenarios. One key feature of 5G, ultra-reliable low latency communication, is particularly appealing to such scenarios for its real-time capabilities. However, 5G’s enhanced security, mostly realized through optional security controls, imposes additional overhead on the network performance, potentially hindering its real-time capabilities. To better assess this impact and guide operators in choosing between different options, we measure the latency overhead of IPsec when applied over the N3 and the service-based interfaces to protect user and control plane data, respectively. Furthermore, we evaluate whether WireGuard constitutes an alternative to reduce this overhead. Our findings show that IPsec, if configured correctly, has minimal latency impact and thus is a prime candidate to secure real-time critical scenarios. Conference: 18th ACM Conference on Security and Privacy in Wireless and Mobile Networks; June 30-July 3, 2025; Arlington, VA, USA 18th ACM Conference on Security and Privacy in Wireless and Mobile Networks (WiSec 2025), June 30-July 3, 2025, Arlington, VA, USA DOI: 10.1145/3734477.3734722 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1530-3/2025/06 CCS: Security and privacy Security protocols CCS: Security and privacy Mobile and wireless security CCS: Networks Mobile networks † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Up until the Fourth Generation (4G) of mobile networks, the primary focus was on enhancing mobile broadband for commercial use, prioritizing bandwidth ( Kumar et al., 2012 ) . However, the advent of Fifth Generation (5G) networks marked a significant shift towards addressing both commercial and industrial deployments. This transition targeted industrial applications and critical infrastructure, meeting the growing demand for robust, low-latency communication ( Michaelides et al., 2025a ; 3GPP, 2024a ) . To this end, 5G supports Ultra-Reliable Low Latency Communication, crucial for real-time applications, making it an ideal backbone for critical infrastructure such as industrial control systems and healthcare. In these sectors, even minor latency shifts can disrupt production lines or create safety hazards in real-time data transmission scenarios, such as remote surgeries. At the same time, 5G’s enhanced security over its predecessors resonates extremely well with the strict security requirements of such sectors faced by growing security threats ( Stellios et al., 2018 ) . Concretely, 5G implements advanced security protocols and controls addressing previous vulnerabilities, such as the lack of User Plane integrity protection in 4G ( Rupprecht et al., 2019 ) . These controls and protocols are essential for ensuring security guarantees, such as protection against tampering and eavesdropping attacks. However, the utilization of many of these is optional and left to the discretion of network operators. A notable example is the use of network layer security to ensure these essential security guarantees. The 3GPP 5G specification suggests implementing IPsec on most 5G interfaces, including those within the 5G Core, which manages critical functions such as authentication, billing, and security. Without proper protection, these interfaces remain vulnerable to data tampering, privacy breaches, or service outages. While the specification mandates their protection, utilizing security protocols can be avoided if alternative measures, such as physical security, are used ( 3GPP, 2024f ) . Furthermore, even if network operators principally decide to apply such optional security controls, they have to choose between different configuration options, e.g., ciphers, authentication options, and operation modes. This decision is further complicated as, besides tremendous security benefits, these optional controls increase latency, contradicting efforts to achieve reliable communication with minimal latency. Still, with the rise of distributed and cloud-based 5G Core deployments ( GSMA, 2024 ) , where physical protection becomes impractical, network operators must consider enabling these controls to improve security. Consequently, they require a profound understanding of how these controls impact 5G’s ability to support time-critical applications and which configurations are most latency-friendly. This paper provides this much-needed understanding by empirically evaluating the latency overhead of network layer security in 5G. Specifically, we analyze the latency impact of IPsec in various configurations on both the User Plane (UP) and the Control Plane of the 5G Core in a simulated setup. Furthermore, we assess the overhead of WireGuard, a modern security protocol often proposed as a promising alternative ( Zeidler et al., 2024 ; Haga et al., 2020 ) . In detail, our contributions are: (1) By orchestrating and extending existing open-source components, we facilitate the first open 5G testbed that implements IPsec and WireGuard ( Michaelides et al., 2025b ) . (2) By measuring the overhead of IPsec for UP data transmission and CP communication within the 5GC, we identify latency-friendly IPsec configurations that add an overhead of just 55\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro s} for UP and between 300\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro s} - 600\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro s} for CP. (3) By assessing WireGuard, we find that while it shows no advantage in w.r.t latency, it is still a fast and more resource-friendly alternative compared to IPsec. 2. Background on 5G Systems and Their Security A 5G system comprises the User Equipment, Radio Access Network, and 5G Core (cf. Figure 1 ). The User Equipment is the end-user device equipped with authentication credentials while the Radio Access Network manages radio resources to provide wireless connectivity to the User Equipment via the Uu interface. The 5G Core, linked to the Radio Access Network, interconnects Network Functions controlling network operations and managing connections ( 3GPP, 2024c , §4.2) . A 5G system is logically divided into two planes: the Control Plane (CP) handling control functions such as authentication and session management, and the User Plane (UP) transmitting user data ( 3GPP, 2024b , §4.3) . This separation is most evident in the 5G Core, where control tasks are handled by Control Plane Network Functions such as the Authentication and Mobility Function, Session Mangement Function, and Policy Control Function, while the User Plane Function in the User Plane routes user data to external networks. Control Plane Network Functions communicate with each other over Service Based Interfaces, while Control Plane and User Plane data are transmitted from the Radio Access Network to the Authentication and Mobility Function and User Plane Function via the N2 and N3 interfaces, respectively. Figure 1. In a 5G network, separated into control and user plane, various security controls apply to different planes and interfaces: Control Plane Security , User Plane Security , IPsec , and TLS . In this work, we study the latency impact of IPsec and WireGuard to secure the User Plane of 5G and the Control Plane of the 5G Core. 2.1. Security Controls in 5G To secure data over 5G, 3GPP defines several security controls, which inevitably affect network performance, especially latency. CP and UP Security The specification mandates security controls for both planes, comprising three encryption and three integrity protection schemes based on AES, SNOW, and ZUC ( Heijligenberg et al., 2023 ) . However, operators are only required to enable integrity protection for Control Plane data, while the other security controls remain optional. While both planes use the same schemes, their termination points differ: Control Plane security is established between the User Equipment and Authentication and Mobility Function, whereas User Plane security terminates at the Radio Access Network. Thus, control data from the UE is always integrity-protected over Uu and N2. On the other

Read the complete text