Uncertainty Profiles for LLMs: Uncertainty Source Decomposition and Adaptive Model-Metric Selection

Pei-Fu Guo, Yun-Da Tsai, Shou-De Lin · 2025

Read Uncertainty Profiles for LLMs: Uncertainty Source Decomposition and Adaptive Model-Metric Selection by Pei-Fu Guo, Yun-Da Tsai, Shou-De Lin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-07309.txt.

Introduction

Pei-Fu Guo, Yun-Da Tsai, and Shou-De Lin build a framework in 2025 for sorting out why large language models feel unsure. These models often sound fluent while stating falsehoods, and uncertainty scores are a main tool for catching such errors. Yet today's scores are hard to interpret, since no one says which kind of doubt each score captures.

The team splits uncertainty into four sources and builds a pipeline that measures each one. They then map how common scores relate to each source across tasks and models. Building on the map, they propose picking the model and score whose doubt profile fits the task. Tests show this matching beats fixed choices and aids safer deployment.

Catalog record

CREATORPei-Fu Guo, Yun-Da Tsai, Shou-De Lin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-07309

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Uncertainty Profiles for LLMs: Uncertainty Source Decomposition and Adaptive Model-Metric Selection Pei-Fu Guo, Yun-Da Tsai, Shou-De Lin Abstract Large language models (LLMs) often generate fluent but factually incorrect outputs, known as hallucinations, which undermine their reliability in real-world applications. While uncertainty estimation has emerged as a promising strategy for detecting such errors, current metrics offer limited interpretability and lack clarity about the types of uncertainty they capture. In this paper, we present a systematic framework for decomposing LLM uncertainty into four distinct sources, inspired by previous research. We develop a source-specific estimation pipeline to quantify these uncertainty types and evaluate how existing metrics relate to each source across tasks and models. Our results show that metrics, task, and model exhibit systematic variation in uncertainty characteristic. Building on this, we propose a method for task specific metric/model selection guided by the alignment or divergence between their uncertainty characteristics and that of a given task. Our experiments across datasets and models demonstrate that our uncertainty-aware selection strategy consistently outperforms baseline strategies, helping us select appropriate models or uncertainty metrics, and contributing to more reliable and efficient deployment in uncertainty estimation. Code is available at link . 1 Introduction Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in natural language generation, often surpassing average human performance on tasks involving mathematics, reasoning, and programming. Despite these advances, LLMs frequently produce confident, yet factually incorrect responses, commonly referred to as hallucinations . Such errors pose a serious challenge to the reliability and trustworthiness of LLM outputs. A promising direction for addressing hallucinations lies in LLM uncertainty estimation . Previous research has shown that hallucinations can often be identified by examining how uncertain LLM is when responding to a prompt. This has led to the development of a variety of uncertainty estimation techniques. Broadly, these methods can be grouped into four categories: likelihood-based approaches Malinin and Gales (2020) , Kuhn et al. (2023) , consistency/ensemble-based methods Xiong et al. (2023) , Jiang et al. (2023) , verbalization-based techniques Kadavath et al. (2022) , Lin et al. (2022a) , and approaches specifically targeting aleatoric and epistemic uncertainty Ahdritz et al. (2024) , Yadkori et al. (2024) , Gao et al. (2024) . Although these methods have shown strong predictive performance across different datasets and model families, they suffer from two key limitations. First, most uncertainty metrics do not provide actionable information on why a particular response is uncertain. As a result, users receive little guidance on how to reduce uncertainty or improve input accuracy. Second, it remains unclear which specific sources of uncertainty each metric captures, such as linguistic ambiguity, knowledge gaps, or the inherent randomness of the decoding process. This lack of clarity makes it difficult for practitioners to select the most appropriate metrics for new tasks. Instead, users often rely on prior benchmark results or choose metrics based on intuitive interpretations of their design, rather than a systematic understanding of what the metrics actually capture. These gaps highlight the need for a systematic method to analyze the sources of uncertainty in LLM-generated responses, enabling better interpretation, selection, and application of uncertainty estimation in practice. In this paper, we aim to answer the following key questions: 1. What type of uncertainty source does existing uncertainty metric primarily capture? 2. Do certain tasks consistently exhibit stronger tendencies toward specific uncertainty source? 3. Are different language models more susceptible to specific uncertainty source? 4. Can we leverage uncertainty characteristic to adaptively select appropriate metrics and models for different downstream task? To address these questions, we begin by identifying four distinct sources of uncertainty in LLM responses, motivated by prior work on improving model response accuracy. We then develop a pipeline with dedicated estimators to quantify each uncertainty source. By analyzing the relation between source estimators and existing LLM uncertainty metrics, we find that different metrics are sensitive to different types of uncertainty. Our analysis also shows that tasks tend to exhibit distinct uncertainty profiles, and that models vary in their susceptibility to different uncertainty sources. Building on these findings, we propose an adaptive approach for selecting uncertainty metrics and models based on the estimated uncertainty profile of a task. Our experimental results show that our method consistently outperforms non-adaptive baselines, offering a practical alternative to manual tuning or trial-and-error strategies for efficient deployment in real-world uncertainty estimation applications. The major contributions of this paper are as follows: • We propose a conceptual framework that decomposes LLM uncertainty into four interpretable sources, represented as an uncertainty profile —a vector capturing the fine-grained structure of model uncertainty. • We develop an estimation pipeline that quantifies each uncertainty source at the response level and analyze these uncertainty profiles across multiple metrics, tasks, and models. • We present a novel method for adaptive model and metric selection based on uncertainty profiles, enabling more effective and reliable deployment in real-world uncertainty estimation scenarios. 2 Profiling LLM Uncertainty: A Literature-Grounded Taxonomy Uncertainty in LLM responses can arise from a wide range of factors, many of which are entangled and difficult to isolate in practice. To better understand and interpret what existing uncertainty metrics are capturing, we propose a decomposition of LLM uncertainty into four principal sources. This taxonomy is developed through a broad survey of prior work on model calibration, uncertainty estimation, and failure analysis in language models. While not exhaustive, these four sources reflect distinct and recurring behavior patterns in LLM outputs that we believe are both interpretable and practically useful. We introduce the four principal uncertainty sources as follows: Surface Form Uncertainty (SU) arises when the model struggles to parse the linguistic structure of the input, such as rare vocabulary, complex syntax, or unconventional phrasing. This often leads to shallow comprehension failures. For instance, Zhou et al. (2024) show that even subtle changes in surface form can significantly affect answer distributions and success rates in math reasoning tasks, highlighting the sensitivity of LLMs to low-level linguistic variation. Aleatoric Uncertainty (AU) reflects inherent ambiguity or underspecification in the prompt. Even when syntactically clear, the input may support multiple valid interpretations, leading to diverse or inconsistent responses. This source of uncertainty is particularly important in instruction-following or open-ended tasks. Hou et al. (2023) decompose total uncertainty in LLM responses into aleatoric and epistemic components using input clarification ensembling. Gao et al. (2024) jointly handle aleatoric and epistemic uncertainty by proposing a perturbation and aggregation module. Epistemic Uncertainty (EU) reflects the model’s limited factual knowledge or reasoning capacity. In such cases, the model lacks the necessary information or logical grounding to produce a correct response. Prior work by Yadkori et al. (2024) , Ling et al. (2024) and Ahdritz et al. (2024) specifically focuses on isolating and estimating epistemic uncertainty in LLMs, emphasizing its importance for evaluating model reliability. Operational Uncertainty (OU) refers to errors that emerge during the response generation process. These include stochastic decoding issues such as logical slips, arithmetic mistakes, or formatting inconsistencies. Studies like Bigelow et al. (2024) demonstrate that small perturbations at critical decoding steps can lead to dramatically different outputs, while Xu et al. (2025) and Zeng et al. (2025) show that longer reasoning chains tend to amplify such instabilities—underscoring the impact of decoding dynamics on response quality. While

Read the complete text