Estimating the Lensing Probability for Binary Black Hole Mergers in AGN disk by Using Mismatch Threshold

Wen-Long Xu, Yu-Zhe Li,, Yi-Gu Chen,, Hui Li,, Wei-Hua Lei, · 2025

Read Estimating the Lensing Probability for Binary Black Hole Mergers in AGN disk by Using Mismatch Threshold by Wen-Long Xu, Yu-Zhe Li,, Yi-Gu Chen,, Hui Li,, Wei-Hua Lei, (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-07114.txt.

Introduction

Wen-Long Xu and co-authors present a 2025 paper on how often black hole mergers inside the disks of active galaxies get gravitationally lensed by the giant black hole at the centre. Such dense disks are promising merger factories, and lensing would split or magnify the gravitational wave signal. Earlier estimates used a simple geometric criterion for when lensing counts.

That test, the authors argue, is the wrong one. What matters is whether detectors can tell a lensed waveform from an unlensed one, judged by a mismatch threshold tied to the signal's loudness. Recalculating the odds on that basis for current observatory sensitivity gives a more honest forecast of catching a lensed event.

Catalog record

CREATORWen-Long Xu, Yu-Zhe Li,, Yi-Gu Chen,, Hui Li,, Wei-Hua Lei,
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-07114

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Estimating the Lensing Probability for Binary Black Hole Mergers in AGN disk by Using Mismatch Threshold Wen-Long Xu, Yu-Zhe Li,, Yi-Gu Chen,, Hui Li,, Wei-Hua Lei, Abstract Stellar-mass binary black holes (BBH) may form, evolve, and merge within the dense environments of active galactic nuclei (AGN) disks, thereby contributing to the BBH population detected by gravitational wave (GW) observatories. Mergers occurring in AGN disks may be gravitationally lensed by the central supermassive black hole. Such lensing presents a potential probe of BBH formation channels through its probability. In this work, we calculate the AGN lensing probability of LIGO sources embedded in AGN disk by relating mismatch threshold to the signal-to-noise ratio. The AGN lensing probability of GW190521-like event will be ∼ 3 % \sim 3\% for O3 PSD, ∼ 6 % \sim 6\% for Aplus PSD, and ∼ 33 % \sim 33\% for ET PSD. If AGNs are indeed the primary formation channel for BBHs, we could quantify the probability of detecting the lensed GW events in such a scenario. The non-detections, on the other hand, will place stricter constraints on the fraction of AGN disk BBHs and even the birthplaces of BBH mergers. ]Dated: August 24, 2026 I Introduction In 2015, LIGO detected the first binary black hole (BBH) merger event, known as GW150914 [ 7 ] . Two years later, another significant event was observed – the merger of a binary neutron star, GW170817 [ 8 ] . This event was accompanied by the electromagnetic counterpart of GRB 170817A [ 9 , 50 ] and kilonova AT 2017gfo/DLT17ck [ 116 ] . Gravitational waves from two neutron star–black hole (BH) coalescences were also observed in January 2020 [ 12 ] . The network of ground-based gravitational-wave (GW) detectors, after four observing runs, has observed more than 300 events, most of which are merging BBHs [ 10 , 11 , 5 , 14 , 110 , 70 ] . More GW events are expected to be detected in future observation runs and with new detectors such as LIGO-india [ 96 ] , Deci-hertz Interferometer GW Observatory (DECIGO, [ 62 ] ), Einstein Telescope (ET, [ 95 ] ), and Cosmic Explorer (CE, [ 41 ] ). This rapidly growing population motivates detailed studies of BBH formation channels. The proposed scenarios include chemically homogeneous evolution of isolated binary stars [ 35 ] , common-envelope ejection [ 90 , 59 ] , envelope expansion [ 108 ] , chemically homogeneous evolution in a tidally distorted binary [ 35 ] , evolution of triple or quadruple systems [ 18 , 74 ] , gravitational capture [ 89 ] , dynamical evolution in open clusters [ 19 ] and dense star clusters [ 93 ] , dynamical interaction in gas-rich nuclear regions [ 79 ] , and the evolution of Population III binary stars [ 102 ] , among others. However, the observation of BBH merger event GW231123 indicates that BBH masses are consistent with intermediate mass, and both black hole spins are consistent with very high spin parameters [ 1 ] . These two distinctive properties pose challenges to conventional formation channels. Recent studies suggested that GW231123 may originate from active galactic nuclei (AGN channel). For example, Ref. [ 22 ] proposed that GW231123 could be formed via accretion onto Population III remnants in an AGN disk, whereas Ref. [ 36 ] suggested that it may arise from hierarchical mergers within AGN disks. Although electromagnetic counterpart observations could, in principle, provide constraints on the localization and environment of GW231123 [ 23 , 30 ] , whether such counterparts are detectable remains uncertain [ 78 , 63 , 122 ] . Thus, a single observational signature may be insufficient to uniquely identify the formation environment of BBHs, highlighting the need for multiple diagnostic approaches. In this context, we propose that AGN lensing may serve as a complementary diagnostic tool. The basis for this proposal is that the complex environment of AGN may lead to diverse AGN lensing signatures, which in turn underpin their diagnostic potential. For example, BBHs prior to merger, while orbiting the central supermassive black hole (SMBH), may undergo repeated gravitational lensing events [ 39 , 121 ] , leading to periodic spikes in GW amplitude. As the BBH passes near caustics, its waveforms could be distorted due to diffraction [ 44 ] . The presence of a lensing object may also cause the GW to experience the gravitational spin Hall effect during propagation [ 119 , 17 , 87 , 88 ] , thereby altering its polarization [ 57 ] . Moreover, the stellar field [ 31 , 103 ] surrounding the BBH and galaxy substructure [ 73 , 104 ] may also play a role in shaping the AGN lensing signature. Although the AGN lensing signatures are diverse, they are not beyond investigation. Previous work has established a framework for lensed GW signal search and identification [ 4 , 2 , 111 ] , which provides a foundation for such investigations. Generally, each GW event is first identified by matched-filtering search pipelines [ 10 , 11 , 5 , 14 , 110 , 70 ] . The assessment of potential lensing is performed subsequently [ 54 , 33 , 4 , 60 , 2 , 111 , 52 , 28 , 58 ] , through the identification of lensing signatures [ 56 , 42 , 68 ] using model selection methods [ 61 , 75 , 55 , 118 ] . Reference [ 81 ] employed a comprehensive approach combining Bayesian inference and matched-filtering analysis to systematically investigate lensing effects. Their results indicate that the maximum match across the M_{\rm L} – y plane effectively captures the similarity between lensed and unlensed waveforms. This motivates us to employ the match-filtering method to investigate and quantify the distribution of waveform deviations induced by AGN lensing across the AGN disk. Existing research indicates that waveform deviations can be quantified using mismatch [ 71 , 112 ] . With a reasonable construction of the AGN lensing geometry, it is possible to map the distribution of waveform deviations induced by AGN lensing across the disk via the mismatch. Unfortunately, even if such waveform deviations are quantified, they may not necessarily be measurable. Recent studies show that the mismatch can be related to an indistinguishability signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) [ 112 ] . Specifically, if the mismatch \epsilon falls below a certain threshold (mismatch threshold hereafter), the intrinsic deviation between waveforms becomes smaller than the statistical uncertainty [ 112 ] . In such cases, the waveforms are considered indistinguishable [ 46 , 47 , 32 , 48 , 71 , 72 , 80 ] . This indistinguishability suggests two implications. First, AGN lensing effects need to be sufficiently pronounced to have a chance of being distinguished from other AGN-related effects. Second, for a merger event at a given disk location, if the AGN lensing-induced waveform deviation is indistinguishable, that event would not contribute to the overall AGN lensing probability. This offers a potential method for estimating the AGN lensing probability across the disk using the mismatch threshold and SNR. GW lensing rates have been derived from optical depth, adopting the Einstein radius serving as a

Read the complete text