More Than Opinions: The Role of Values in Shaping Fairness and Status in the Ultimatum Game within Structured Societies
Hana Krakovská, Rudolf Hanel · 2025
Read More Than Opinions: The Role of Values in Shaping Fairness and Status in the Ultimatum Game within Structured Societies by Hana Krakovská, Rudolf Hanel (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-07060.txt.
Introduction
Hana Krakovska and Rudolf Hanel model how social values and status shape fairness in the ultimatum game. In that game, one player offers a split of a prize and the other can kill the deal for both. Lab results swing wildly across cultures, which hints that hidden hierarchies steer the offers.
Their society builds its own pecking order from visible traits like age and wealth. Rank rules pass down family lines and settle over time. Roles of proposer and responder then fall by that subjective order, not by lot. A living population model with shifting size and networks plays the game under varied hierarchies. Sharing norms from stingy to generous emerge on their own. The work argues that values, not mere opinions, set what a group will call a fair split.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hana Krakovská, Rudolf Hanel |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-07060
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
More Than Opinions: The Role of Values in Shaping Fairness and Status in the Ultimatum Game within Structured Societies Hana Krakovská, Rudolf Hanel Abstract Asymmetric evolutionary games, such as the Ultimatum Game, provide keys to understanding the emergence of fairness in social species. Building on this framework, we explore the evolution of social value systems and the operational role that social status plays in hierarchically organised societies. Within the asymmetric Ultimatum Game paradigm, where ”proposers” suggest terms for resource distribution, and ”responders” accept or reject these terms, we examine the assignment of roles between players under a subjective social order. This order is grounded in an emergent status hierarchy based on observable player attributes (such as age and wealth). The underlying rules for constructing such a hierarchy stabilise over time by inheritance and family ties. Despite their subjective nature these (often sub-conscious) value systems have operative meaning in controlling access of individuals to resources and decision making. We demonstrate these effects using a simple but sufficiently complex model with dynamical population size and network structure, where division of resources (prey) is carried out according to the principles of the Ultimatum Game. We focus on the emerging proposer and responder thresholds under distinct social hierarchies and interaction networks and discuss them in relation to the extensive body of Ultimatum Game experiments conducted across a wide range of cultural contexts. We observe the emergence of diverse sharing norms, ranging from unfair to highly generous, alongside the development of various social norms. I Introduction The study of fairness or social cooperation has been explored for decades through the lens of games like the Prisoner’s Dilemma and the Stag-Hunt game. Here, we choose a particularly simple game for this context, the Ultimatum Game (UG) [ 1 ] . It is worth noting that zero-determinant strategies of the iterated Prisoner’s Dilemma reduce to the UG once players notice that such strategies are played [ 2 ] . At that point, players must decide whether to accept the proposal or refuse to play. In this work, we are interested in how status, and cultural means to ”measure” status in terms of observables, such as energy levels or age of a player, bias the roles a player can take in cooperative games for resources. We are also interested how, e.g. a minimal reproductive age and a dynamical population size affect the dynamics. The UG, first studied experimentally by Güth et al. [ 1 ] , involves two players with asymmetric roles—a ”proposer” and a ”responder”—and a reward to be divided. The proposer suggests how to split the reward, and the responder chooses whether to accept or reject the offer. If accepted, the reward is divided as proposed; if rejected, both players receive nothing. According to the theoretical predictions, a rational and self-interested proposer will offer the smallest amount they expect the responder to accept. Likewise, a rational and self-interested responder will accept any positive offer and be indifferent between accepting or rejecting an offer of zero. Consequently, the subgame-perfect Nash equilibrium [ 3 ] prescribes that the proposer should offer the lowest possible unit of the reward (or zero), which the responder will then accept [ 4 ] . However, ample experimental evidence reveals that responders in Western, educated, industrialised, rich and democratic (W.E.I.R.D.) societies typically reject proposals at 10-30\% of the reward and proposers often offer 40-50\% (see e.g. Oosterbeek et al. [ 5 ] ). While initially these thresholds were thought to be sharply defined and universally applicable, experimental evidence has unveiled various cultural and psychological biases that lead to either more greedy but sometimes also overly generous split proposals. For instance, Henrich et al. [ 6 ] conducted experiments in 15 small-scale societies around the globe and found a wide spectrum of arising strategies. From the ”greedy” societies of the Quichua all the way to the Lamalera tribe, where offers frequently exceed 50\%, with proposers often giving more to others than keeping for themselves. Despite significant cultural differences in fairness norms observed in experimental settings, the extent to which real-world actions deviate from the predictions of strict economic self-interest remains a topic of debate and has been examined from various theoretical perspectives (see e.g. the review by Debove et al. [ 7 ] , or more recent analysis by Akdeniz et al. [ 8 ] ). Earlier models with role-alternating frameworks [ 9 ] suggest that what is learned through the repeated interactions might also translate to one-shot UG settings. Other models that have been investigated include evolutionary game-theoretical approaches with reputation-based explanations (see e.g. [ 10 ] , [ 11 ] ), noise-based explanations [ 12 ] , models with ”empathy”, where the agents are not allowed to ask for bigger splits than they would accept in the responder’s role [ 13 ] and spite-based models [ 14 ] . It has also been shown that the topology of the players’ interaction network significantly influences the split levels that are commonly proposed or rejected (see e.g. Sinatra et al. [ 15 ] and Page et al. [ 16 ] ). Interestingly, a small world transition takes place from relatively ”fair” behaviour in a ring-shaped regular network topology to much more greedy splits in the small world, i.e. for Poissonian networks [ 17 ] . Furthermore, both [ 17 , 16 ] present analytical invasion analysis that explores why non-zero rejection strategies can successfully stabilise within a structured population. The majority of UG models assume that the roles of the players are dual, meaning they play both roles with equal probability. Consequently, when all individuals adopt the same strategy, the average payoff from successful interactions equals half the total reward. This inherent symmetry means the average total reward remains unaffected as long as the rejection threshold is below the proposal threshold. However, this ceases to be true for societies that are not strictly egalitarian (i.e. societies that do not really exist) but have notions of status that regulate the chances of an individual to play one or the other role in UG-like situations. Han et al. [ 18 ] experimentally highlight the difference between dual and single-role distribution by conducting experiments with different role assignment and different population structure (well-mixed vs. fixed) and show that playing both roles (dual-role) promotes rational sharing (low offers), whereas single-role distribution leads to fair offers (approximately 45\% ). Considering the inherent hierarchy between the players may therefore be an important component for studying fairness. Some authors have investigated unequal role distribution (see e.g. [ 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 ] ). For instance, Li et al. [ 19 ] look at degree-based role allocation and show fairer behaviour when low-degree players act more often as proposers. Wu et al. [ 20 ] also look at unequal role distribution through role degree assignment on scale-free network, with their update mechanism the thresholds reach the highest values of 0.2 if the proposers are played by low-degree nodes. Debove et al. [ 21 ] investigate the model with the possibility of switching partners at various cost levels and show that, for low costs, fairness can be achieved despite intrinsic unequal role distributions. Killingback et al. [ 22