CNN-based Image Models Verify a Hypothesis that The Writers of Cuneiform Texts Improved Their Writing Skills When Studying at the Age of Hittite Empire
Daichi Kohmoto, Katsutoshi Fukuda, Daisuke Yoshida, Takafumi Matsui, Sachihiro Omura · 2025
Read CNN-based Image Models Verify a Hypothesis that The Writers of Cuneiform Texts Improved Their Writing Skills When Studying at the Age of Hittite Empire by Daichi Kohmoto, Katsutoshi Fukuda, Daisuke Yoshida, Takafumi Matsui, Sachihiro Omura (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-06974.txt.
Introduction
Daichi Kohmoto and co-authors use image-learning models in a 2025 study to read the hands of two ancient scribes. Their text is a wedge-script tablet of rites, penned twice in near-same words by two writers. Why such a twin tablet was kept was a puzzle.
Rather than cut out each wedge sign, the team fed whole tablet photos to the models. The marks of the first half fit a teacher hand, and the marks of the second fit a learner whose skill grew as he copied. The tablet thus reads as a school piece from an empire age. Old-world scholars gain a new lens for unsigned school work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daichi Kohmoto, Katsutoshi Fukuda, Daisuke Yoshida, Takafumi Matsui, Sachihiro Omura |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-06974
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
CNN-based Image Models Verify a Hypothesis that The Writers of Cuneiform Texts Improved Their Writing Skills When Studying at the Age of Hittite Empire Daichi Kohmoto, Katsutoshi Fukuda, Daisuke Yoshida, Takafumi Matsui, Sachihiro Omura Abstract A cuneiform tablet KBo 23.1 ++/KUB 30.38, which is known to represent a text of Kizzuwatna rituals, was written by two writers with almost identical content in two iterations. Unlike other cuneiform tablets that contained information such as myths, essays, or business records, the reason why ancient people left such tablets for posterity remains unclear. To study this problem, we develop a new methodology by analyzing images of a tablet quantitatively using CNN (Convolutional Neural Network)-based image models, without segmenting cuneiforms one-by-one. Our data-driven methodology implies that the writer writing the first half was a ‘teacher’ and the other writer was a ‘student’ who was training his skills of writing cuneiforms. This result has not been reached by classical linguistics. We also discuss related conclusions and possible further directions for applying our method and its generalizations. 2023 keywords Cuneiform Analysis, CNN-based Image Models, Similarity for Writing Skills, Majority Vote 1 Preface Since ancient times, letters have been crucial for supporting civilizations and keeping track of various records and ideas. Apparently, schools for teaching the writing skills existed in those periods. For example, in a circular tablet excavated in the Mesopotamian region Spar (1988) , with an estimated date approximately from 2000 BC to 1600 BC, students practiced in writing the name of the God Urash in Sumerian and Akkadian in cuneiform six times. Common theories and hypotheses assume that reading and writing were popular among officials and military personnels in this era, and that young potential candidates practised their reading and writing skills at schools, called Edubba in ancient Mesopotamia. A potential Edubba was found in the royal palace of Zimri-Lim in the Mali ruins of Sumerian civilization (e.g., Waetzoldt (1986) , Tanret (1981) , and Volk (2000) ). The first key to discovering the existence of such schools would be finding clay tablets showing the evidence of training the skills of writing cuneiforms. A unique clay tablet KBo 23.1 ++/KUB 30.38 Košak et al (2022) was found in the Hittite capital city, Hattusa (see Fig. 1 ) and belongs to the period of the Hittite Empire (1400 BC to 1300 BC). It is known as a document about the rituals of Kizzuwatna, a region in South-East Turkey under the Hittite control from the fifteenth century BC during the reign of the King Tuthaliya I/II, Strauß (2006) and Torri (2008) . From linguistic viewpoint, it is known that two authors wrote almost identical sentences in this tablet, and a former work suggests this tablet might be evidence of ‘a pedagogic exercise’ concerning one of those two authors Gordin (2015) . These motivate us to study this tablet as potential evidence of practising skills of writing cuneiforms, via handwriting analysis. This study incorporates machine learning, which has been rapidly developing in recent years, into the conventional linguistics methodologies. Machine learning makes precise predictions based on large-scale data with fairness, reproductivity, and explainability. In this study, our data analysis is performed using three 2D image data of the clay tablet KBo 23.1 ++/KUB 30.38 in Hethitologie-Portals Mainz Košak et al (2022) . Many previous studies focused on identifying hundreds order of authors by analyzing handwritten characters using machine learning for modern languages such as English, Spanish, French, and Arabic. These research projects are collectively called the writer-identification problem . A comprehensive review Rehman et al (2019a) describes the research on writer identification using machine learning. As the wedge-shaped characters written in a tablet are handwritten characters, the evidence of improvements in training skills of writing cuneiforms might be obtained quantitatively via these technologies in addition to identifying the authors. This study has two parts: handwriting analysis and writer identification analysis. 2 Methodology and Experiments We start from extracting rectangular image pieces of two-line sentences from three images of our target tablet KBo 23.1 ++/KUB 30.38 as seen in Fig. 1 . Next, we define n classes for these pieces assuming n candidate writers, and construct the main datasets enabling 5 -fold validation via cropping squares and data augmentation techniques. Almost as in some cases of writer-identification problems, we model our problem as multi-class classification with multiple CNN-based image models VGG19 Simonyan and Zisserman (2014) , ResNet50 He et al (2016) , and InceptionV3 Szegedy et al (2016) , trained on ImageNet Deng et al (2009) , which is a well-known large-scale dataset of images. Differences between writer-identification problems and our approach are (1) the way of constructing the datasets for building our models, because the number of images of our target tablet is limited (e.g., three images), and writers are not true writers but ‘candidate’ writers in the first place, (2) that we focus not only on achieving state-of-the-art precision when we fine-tune image models, but also on non-matching parts between true labels and predictions of its models for our analysis, which we will define as similarity , and (3) that we use multiple CNN-based image models and derive conclusions by majority vote from the results of (1) and (2). As we can discuss similarity between n candidate writers from (2) and (3), leads to new insights related to this tablet. Similarity and majority vote, explained in subsections 2.2 and 2.3 , are two main building blocks of our methodology in this study. To our knowledge, there are few studies on developing methodologies focusing on specific problems of humanities with only a few images using machine learning. As an aspect of handwriting analysis, there exist a deductive approach Dencker et al (2020) developing methodologies to identify each cuneiform character one-by-one using image datasets of tablets and their transliterations. Since their purposes do not include extracting features of cuneiforms on tablets, one cannot directly apply their methodologies to our problems. Previous research on writer-identification problems Rehman et al (2019b) is focusing on identifying authors in the order of hundreds via developed and optimized one model, so that approaches of our study are quite different from them. This study uses pretrained PyTorch Image Models timm Wightman (2019) as CNN-based image models. We fine-tune these pretrained models over augmented main datasets enabling 5 -fold validations, and check (i) the results of confusion matrices that we obtain by applying fine-tuned models to the test parts of the main datasets, (ii) the results of external validations by applying fine-tuned models to other datasets built from two additional parts of the target tablet to be identified, and (iii) the results of class activation mapping to understand what features of image samples in the main datasets these models encode for identifying the class of the image sample. 2.1 Building Main Datasets Our target tablet KBo 23.1 ++/KUB 30.38 have two-sided columns of sentences, as shown in Fig. 1 : this study borrows and uses these three original pictures from Košak et al (2022) . According to the current understanding of linguistics, two authors wrote the same sentences in the tablet: due to the existence of certain signs at the end of the tablet, the first column and almost half of the second column (right