Gamma-ray and high-energy X-ray detection with large area scintillating crystals: a hands-on review

Maurizio Bonesini 1,∗ · 2025

Read Gamma-ray and high-energy X-ray detection with large area scintillating crystals: a hands-on review by Maurizio Bonesini 1,∗ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-06929.txt.

Introduction

Maurizio Bonesini reviews how to spot gamma rays and strong X-rays with large crystals that give off light when the rays hit them. The review is hands-on, built from work with real devices rather than a full survey of every option.

Bonesini compares the crystal method with other ways to detect these rays. New doped crystals can give sharp energy readings and very fast signals, and work is under way on crystals that do not soak up water from the air. Much of the review centers on one crystal type now seen as the top choice, with notes on how build choices change results.

Catalog record

CREATORMaurizio Bonesini 1,∗
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-06929

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gamma-ray and high-energy X-ray detection with large area scintillating crystals: a hands-on review Maurizio Bonesini 1,∗ Abstract Detection of photons with scintillating inorganic crystals in the high-energy range (>0.1 MeV) will be discussed, making a comparison with other available methods. Energy resolutions up to 2 % at 662 keV and fast decay time of the order of 20 ns are within reach, with the introduction of Ce-doped crystals at the place of alkali-halides ones. Development are under way for the production of non-hygroscopic scintillating crystals, such as PrLuAg and Ce: GAAG. At the end of this review, examples of experimenta devices based on scintillating inorganic crystals will be discussed. Practical hands-on experience is emphasized at the expense of a more comprehensive description of all available and possible options. Detectors’ construction details and consequences of the different choices will be discussed. The emphasis will be put on the LaBr 3 : Ce based detectors that are the present ”golden standard” in gamma ray spectroscopy. The focus of this review will be on photon detection in the high-energy region: mainly 0.1 - 2 MeV, including both gamma rays and high-energy X-rays, even if many considerations may be applied to the detection of low-energy X-rays. \helveticabold 1 Keywords: Gamma-rays, muonic X-rays, SiPM, PMT, crystals, LaBr 3 :Ce \correspondance \extraAuth 2 Introduction Photons in the high-energy region (>0.1 MeV) include both gamma rays from nuclear decays and high-energy X-rays, such as the ones from muonic atomic decays. In the following, we will not care about their origin: nuclear or atomic and will use the generic term gamma rays to cover both types of radiation. X-rays were discovered about 130 years ago by W.C. Roentgen, by observing a glow on a phosphor screen ( roentgen ) . As direct registration of X-rays on a photographic plate is quite inefficient, a search for materials to convert X-rays to visible/ultraviolet (UV) light, to be detected later by a photographic plate, started immediately. Powders such as CWO 4 ( edison ) or Zns-based ones were then introduced. A similar indirect detection methos is used with inorganic scintillating crystals. Direct detection of X-rays may be done instead with semiconductor detectors. Here the incoming radiation is directly converted into the output signal, without an intermediate step. Gamma-ray detectors in common use may be divided into three main categories: • Gas-filled detectors • Semiconductor crystal detectors • Inorganic scintillating crystal detectors The choice depends on the energy range of interest, the needed energy resolution and the required detection efficiency. In addition, other requirements such as count rate performances, signal pulse shape and cost may be of relevance. In the high-energy region (>0.1 MeV) for photon detection, scintillating inorganic crystals are the most common choice for large area detectors and they will be fully reviewed in the following. 3 Detectors based on Scintillating Inorganic crystals Common materials include Sodium Iodide (NaI(Tl)), Bismuth Germanate (BGO), Lutetium-Yttrium oxy orthosilicate (LYSO), Lanthanum Bromide (LaBr 3 :Ce) and many others. Their great importance is associated with their good energy and time resolution, their high counting rate capability (up to 10^{7} counts/s), their high detection efficiency and finally their variety in size and making. The main characteristics required for a scintillating crystal are: • high material density: in the range of 3-7 g/cm 3 , with high atomic number of the major constituent, to allow high detection efficiency for Gamma-rays (high “stopping power”) • small decay time of the crystal’s fluorescent component providing fast signals, thus allowing high counting rates • high light yield improving the photon statistics and thus the energy resolution • small response non-linearity, giving a small degradation in energy • chemical stability and radiation hardness • matching of the crystal peak emission wavelength with the photodetector peak response The first scintillating crystals used for gamma ray detection were Alkali Halide ones (such as NaI, NaCl and NaBr) with Thallium as activator ( pohl1 ) . If the Thallium concentration is small (up to 0.1 molar percent) luminescence is in the near UV region, otherwise if it is larger (from 0.1 to 5 molar percent) the emission extends to the visible region. A crystal, as NaI(Tl), is a non-conducting crystal. This means there is a large energy gap between its filled valence band and its empty conduction band. Energetic electrons generated by a gamma interaction with the NaI material will lose their kinetic energy by producing electron-hole pairs. The recombination of these pairs may result in light emission through radiative transitions or energy release as lattice vibrations. The inclusion of Thallium at a 10 -3 molar fraction significantly enhances the crystal’s light emission, acting as an activator. The radiative emission of Thallium follows an exponential decay law with a large decay constant, meaning that luminescence occurs within a few microseconds. This enables the distinction of different scintillation events in time, which is crucial for differentiating the timing of gamma photon energy depositions. In a simple phosphor the number N of visible/UV photons produced in the scintillation conversion by an incoming gamma ray of energy E, may be expressed by: N=\frac{E}{\beta E_{gap}}\times QE_{T}\times QE_{L} where E_{gap} is the energy of the forbidden gap, QE_{T}(QE_{L}) are the quantum efficiencies of the transport(luminescence) stages in visible/UV light production, \beta a phenomenological parameter in the range 2-3. The relative conversion efficiency is thus: \eta=\frac{E_{vis}\times N}{E} with E_{vis} energy of the generated visible/UV photons. For the best available material \eta reaches a value of \sim 0.2 . For a scintillator as an inorganic crystal, one has to take into account also the collection time of photons after the gamma ray absorption, giving at the end a lower value for the efficiency \eta . After some preliminary studies on phosphors as Naphtalene ( kallman ) , Anthracene ( bell ) and Calcium Tungstate ( moon ) , the use of NaI(Tl) crystals for gamma detection was introduced in seminal papers by R. Hostader ( hofstader1 ) , ( hofstader ) in the late 40’s. They were the crystals of election for many years having a good photon yield and a reasonable energy resolution even if with a long signal decay time ( \sim 250 ns). The additional problem of being hygroscopic was handled by a proper Aluminum housing. NaI(Tl) typically converts around 11 % of the incident gamma energy into photons, with an average energy of 3.0 eV per photon. For a 1 MeV photon, approximately 3.8\times 10^{4} photons are produced on average. The statistical fluctuations in the number of photons generated by each gamma contribute to the observed width (energy resolution) of the observed photopeaks. 3.1 Available crystals A selection of scintillating crystals in current use for gamma ray detection is shown in Table 1 , with their main properties. Crystals are made from compounds, with a melting point in the typical range 700 -2000 {}^{\circ}C . They can be grown using melt-based methods such as the ones from Bridgman or Czochralski, These methods are suitable for growing large volume crystals ( brice ) . The first relevant distinction is between hygroscopic crystals, where an encapsulation is needed, and not-hygroscopic ones. While PrLuAG crystals ( prluag ) and Ce: GAAG crystals ( cecaag ) crystals are not-hygroscopic and thus

Read the complete text