Evolving dunes under flow reversals: from an initial heap toward an inverted dune
W. R. Assis, E. M. Franklin, N. M. Vriend · 2025
Read Evolving dunes under flow reversals: from an initial heap toward an inverted dune by W. R. Assis, E. M. Franklin, N. M. Vriend (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-06707.txt.
Introduction
Willian Assis and co-authors watch a sand dune turn itself inside out when the wind changes its mind. Crescent barchan dunes march across deserts and other planets. The team grew dunes from conical heaps in a water flume and in Euler-Lagrange simulations, then reversed the flow and filmed the undoing.
Grains on the sheltered face climbed straight back over the crest while the dune's core and toe sat frozen, and a new slip face carved into the old windward slope. Two-dimensional dunes kept time with the midline of three-dimensional barchans, and a full reversal took twice the time the dune needed to form. Many grains never moved at all. The findings bless cheaper two-dimensional computations for predicting real barchan behavior.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | W. R. Assis, E. M. Franklin, N. M. Vriend |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-06707
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evolving dunes under flow reversals: from an initial heap toward an inverted dune W. R. Assis, E. M. Franklin, N. M. Vriend Abstract Sand dunes are ubiquitous in nature, and are found in abundance on Earth and other planetary environments. One of the most common types are crescent-shaped dunes known as barchans, whose mid-line could be assumed to behave as 2D dunes. In this work, we (i) compare the morphology of the mid-line of 3D barchans with 2D dunes; and (ii) track the evolution of 3D barchans and 2D dunes while reversing flow conditions. We performed experiments on 2D dunes in a 2D flume and Euler-Lagrange simulations of 3D bedforms. In all reversal experiments and simulations, the initial condition start with a conical heap deforming into a steady-state dune, which is then perturbed by reversing the flow, resulting in an inverted dune. We show that during the reversal the grains on the lee side immediately climb back onto the dune while its internal part and toe remain static, forming a new lee face of varying angle on the previous stoss slope. We show that (i) the characteristic time for the development of 2D dunes scales with that for 3D barchans, (ii) that the time for dune reversal is twice the time necessary to develop an initial triangular or conical heap to steady-state, and (iii) that a considerable part of grains remain static during the entire process. Our findings reveal the dynamics for dune reversal, and highlight that numerical computations of barchans based on 2D slices, which are more feasible in geophysical scales, predict realistic outcomes for the relevant time-scales. † † journal: JGR: Earth Surface † † corresponding: Willian Assis, [email protected] keypoints Experiments show that 2D dunes grow and develop over a characteristic time that matches that of fully 3D barchan dunes The morphodynamics of reversing dunes over time are revealed by fully reversing the flow direction and tracking the rebuilding and reshaping Numerical simulations on a reversing 3D barchan show that its central slice behaves as the reversing 2D dunes Plain Language Summary Crescent-shaped dunes, known as barchans, are found in abundance on Earth and other planetary environments. Although their different shapes and manifestations intrigue us and produce fascinating images (such as in the latest images from Mars), the underlying physics still challenges us. Here we investigate two critical questions: (i) can we capture the relevant physical processes of 3D dunes in a 2D slice? and (ii) how does the dune morph over space and time upon flow reversal (e.g. the wind blowing from the opposite direction)? We research these questions by carrying out experiments with 2D dunes in a water flume and numerical simulations of 3D barchans, and flip-around our flow forcing to investigate flow reversal. We find that the typical development times for 2D and 3D dunes are equivalent and reveal details of the rebuilding processes of the dune upon flow reversals. Interestingly, the inversion time after flow reversal is twice that of the formation time of the initial heap, and a considerable part of grains remains static during the entire process. Our findings reveal the mechanisms for dune reversal and show that 2D simulations, which are simpler and faster, reproduce the underlying physics. 1 Introduction Sand dunes are bedforms resulting from erosion and deposition of sand by the action of a fluid flow Bagnold ((1941)) ; Hersen et al. ((2002)) , and they are frequently found on Earth, Mars and other celestial bodies Hersen ((2004)) ; Elbelrhiti et al. ((2005)) ; Claudin & Andreotti ((2006)) ; Parteli & Herrmann ((2007)) ; Courrech du Pont ((2015)) . Among the most common are crescent-shaped dunes, known as barchans, that appear under a one-directional flow regime and when the quantity of available sand is limited i.e., they grow over a non-erodible ground over which the sand, once the dune is formed, does not cover the entire surface. Given the abundance of barchans present in nature, a considerable number of field measurements, experiments, and numerical simulations were conducted over the last decades to better understand those bedforms C. Sauermann et al. ((2000)) ; Hersen et al. ((2002)) ; Andreotti et al. ((2002)) ; Hersen et al. ((2004)) ; Hersen ((2004)) ; Kroy et al. ((2005)) ; Kroy et al. ((2002)) ; Parteli et al. ((2007)) ; Andreotti et al. ((2009)) ; Franklin & Charru ((2011)) ; Pähtz et al. ((2013)) ; Kidanemariam & Uhlmann ((2014)) ; Guignier et al. ((2013)) ; Parteli et al. ((2011)) ; Khosronejad & Sotiropoulos ((2017)) , but only very few of them were carried out at the grain scale Alvarez & Franklin ((2018)) ; Alvarez & Franklin ((2019)) ; Alvarez & Franklin ((2020)) ; Alvarez & Franklin ((2021)) ; Assis & Franklin ((2020)) ; Assis & Franklin ((2021)) . Most analytical models and numerical simulations are based on information from field measurements on aeolian dunes, so that they solve the problem at the bedform scale only by considering that the grains move mainly in the longitudinal direction (typical of aeolian saltation). For example, the first numerical simulations considered the granular system as a continuum medium, some of them modeling 2D dunes G. Sauermann et al. ((2001)) ; Kroy et al. ((2002)) ; Kroy et al. ((2002)) , and some others modeling 3D dunes as vertical slices that behave as 2D dunes Herrmann & Sauermann ((2000)) ; Hersen ((2004)) ; Kroy et al. ((2005)) . The latter hypothesize that grains move in the longitudinal direction (the same direction of the fluid flow), while transverse diffusion transfers a small quantity of mass between adjoining slices Hersen ((2004)) . More recent models consider the 3D perturbations of the fluid flow, and, thus, the transverse sediment transport Schwämmle & Herrmann ((2005)) ; Durán et al. ((2005)) ; Parteli et al. ((2009)) ; Parteli et al. ((2014)) , but always in the aeolian case, meaning that the transport of grains occurs mainly in the longitudinal direction. In addition, in some cases a transverse diffusion of grains needs to be included for obtaining the correct crescent shape ( Schwämmle & Herrmann, (2005) , even though the transverse flow is present,) . Therefore, the continuum-sliced models are, in principle, valid for aeolian barchans, which consist of a large number of grains that are entrained mainly in longitudinal direction, with small lateral motion due to reptation Andreotti et al. ((2002)) ; Hersen ((2004)) . However, this is not necessarily the case of subaqueous barchans, where transverse sediment transport can become significant ( Andreotti et al., (2002) , even if reptation is absent, the grains being directly entrained by the fluid by rolling and sliding,) . Some recent works showed that the transverse motion of grains is important for subaqueous barchans Alvarez & Franklin ((2018)) ; Alvarez & Franklin ((2019)) , indicating that the picture of a 3D dune as connected slices must be refined in the subaqueous case. For instance, Alvarez & Franklin ((2018)) ; Alvarez & Franklin ((2019)) measured experimentally the displacement of individual grains migrating to horns as an initial pile was deformed into a barchan dune. They found that most of those grains come from upstream regions on the periphery of the dune, within angles forming 105 ∘ and 160