Satellite Streak Brightness Variation with Orbit Height

Adam Snyder, J. Anthony Tyson · 2025

Read Satellite Streak Brightness Variation with Orbit Height by Adam Snyder, J. Anthony Tyson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-06424.txt.

Introduction

Adam Snyder and Anthony Tyson sim how bright satellite streaks look in sky survey cameras as orbit height changes, in a paper from 2025. Streak glare can spoil star photos, and its strength rests on range, satellite size, lens width, and streak speed.

For a large lens focused at far distance, a low satellite blurs out of focus, which spreads its light. In the Rubin Observatory camera case, the effects near cancel out. A big satellite moved from a mid orbit down to a low orbit ends up about as bright in streak form.

Catalog record

CREATORAdam Snyder, J. Anthony Tyson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-06424

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Satellite Streak Brightness Variation with Orbit Height Adam Snyder, J. Anthony Tyson Abstract We study the apparent optical brightness of satellite streaks in ground-based observatory cameras as the orbit height is varied. This is done via simulations. Several factors are in play: the range to the satellite, satellite size and geometry, the diameter of the telescope aperture, and the angular velocity of the satellite image as it streaks across the camera’s focal plane. For a large telescope aperture, a satellite in a lower orbit becomes out-of-focus in a camera focused at infinity. In the case of Rubin Observatory’s LSSTCam, we find that these factors nearly cancel as a large satellite is moved from an orbit at 550 km down to 350 km. I Introduction The exponential increase in numbers of Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites ( A. Falle et al. 2023 ) presents a challenge to ground-based optical astronomy due to reflected sunlight during much of the night. Historically, attempts to mitigate the optical brightness of these LEO satellites have involved darkening the satellites via various schemes, and exploration of conops changes in collaboration with ground based observatories. Recently, many satellite operators have opted to build larger satellites capable of direct-to-cell communication. At a given reflectivity a larger satellite will scatter more sunlight towards the observatory. Some observatories image faint galaxies whose surface brightness (flux/pixel) are hundreds of millions times fainter than these LEO satellites. Multiple studies ( C. Walker et al. 2020 ; M. L. Rawls et al. 2021 ) have thus recommended that satellites be designed such they appear fainter than detectable by the unaided eye in a dark location, 7th V magnitude. Recent satellites however are being reported as bright as 1st magnitude, a factor of 300 brighter than the recommended brightness. This presents a challenge to worldwide astronomy. The most impacted observatories are those that have large light collecting apertures, highly sensitive cameras, and wide field of view. For example, the NSF-DOE Vera C. Rubin observatory will scan the southern sky with 1000 sensitive exposures every night for ten years ( Ž. Ivezić et al. 2019 ) , the Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST). Mitigation of satellite interference with LSST is thus a priority. In this paper we simulate variations in LEO satellite surface brightness observed in the 3200 megapixel camera (LSSTCam) as a function of satellite orbit height. II Satellite Streaks A satellite streak surface brightness profile will depend on the following: bidirectional reflectance distribution function (BRDF), satellite geometric properties, orbital height, and observed angle from zenith. We wish to model the changes to the satellite streak peak brightness due to changes in the orbital height while keeping all other properties the same. We begin with a discussion of the various factors that will affect the measured peak brightness and how these depend on the orbital height. II.1 Distance to the Satellite The distance from the satellite to the observing telescope, known as the range, is an important quantity because it sets the angular sizes of the satellite as viewed by the telescope and the telescope pupil as viewed from the satellite. For a given zenith angle \theta_{Z} we define the nadir angle \theta_{N} as the angle between the nadir of the satellite and a line from the satellite to the telescope, calculated as \theta_{N}=\arcsin\left(\frac{R_{\oplus}}{R_{\oplus}+h}\sin\theta_{Z}\right), (1) where h is the orbital height of the satellite. When considering cases of satellites observed at a specific zenith angle, the nadir angle depends only on the orbital height and will simplify a number of calculations. Then the range is r=\begin{cases}h&\theta_{N}=0\\ R_{\oplus}\frac{\sin(\theta_{Z}-\theta_{N})}{\sin\theta_{N}}&\theta_{N}\neq 0\end{cases}. (2) The case of \theta_{N}=0 corresponds to \theta_{Z}=0 , i.e. the satellite is observed directly above the telescope. In this case, the range is exactly equal to the orbital height. In general, the range to a satellite observed at a specific zenith angle is more complex and the dependence on orbital height is encapsulated by changes to the nadir angle (see Figure 1 ). Figure 1: Distance, or range, to satellites observed at specific zenith angles as a function of the orbital height. II.2 Brightness The flux reflected from the satellite to the telescope is the fraction of the total incoming flux defined in F. Fankhauser et al. 2023 as \frac{I_{\mathrm{out}}}{I_{\mathrm{in}}}=(\hat{w}_{i}\cdot\hat{n})(\hat{w}_{o}\cdot\hat{n})f_{r}(\hat{w}_{i},\hat{w_{o}})\frac{A}{r^{2}} (3) where \hat{w}_{i} is the vector to the incoming light source, \hat{w}_{o} is the vector to the telescope, \hat{n} is the normal vector of the satellite surface, f_{r}(\hat{w}_{i},\hat{w_{o}}) is the BRDF, A is the satellite surface area, and r is the range of the satellite. We can then examine each of the terms individually to determine the change in brightness of the satellite. The incoming flux from the Sun I_{\mathrm{in}} is assumed to be constant since it has a negligible dependence on orbital height. The dot product \hat{w}_{i}\cdot\hat{n} encapsulates changes in the surface area perpendicular to the source and, for the same reason, is assumed to be unchanged. The dot product \hat{w}_{o}\cdot\hat{n}=\cos(\theta_{N}) represents changes in the surface area perpendicular to the observer and depends on the nadir angle defined in Equation 1 . Satellites at different orbital heights that are observed at the same zenith angle will have different nadir angles and therefore there will be additional changes to the amount of reflected flux that depends on this projection effect and the specific properties of the satellite BRDF. II.3 Surface Brightness Profiles At a lower orbital height and subsequent shorter range, the angular size of the satellite will increase and it will appear more out-of-focus because the telescope is focused at infinity. The effective FWHM of a satellite streak as a function of range can be approximated as \theta^{2}_{\mathrm{eff}}=\theta^{2}_{\mathrm{atm}}+\frac{D^{2}_{\mathrm{satellite}}+D^{2}_{\mathrm{mirror}}}{r^{2}}, (4) where \theta_{\mathrm{atm}} is the FWHM of a star due to atmospheric turbulence, D_{\mathrm{satellite}} is the diameter of the satellite (approximated as a circle), and D_{\mathrm{mirror}} is the diameter of the primary mirror of the telescope ( D. Bektešević et al. 2018 ) . From the above approximation we predict that the FWHM of the satellite streak will increase; as a result the surface brightness in electrons per pixel will decrease. II.4 Orbital Velocity Moving objects, such as satellites, are imaged as they traverse the focal plane, whereby individual pixels are exposed to the object for a much shorter time than the full exposure time. We define the effective pixel exposure time t_{\mathrm{eff}} as the time it takes for the satellite to move the angular distance corresponding to one pixel, which is inversely proportional to the angular velocity at which the satellite appears to move across the focal plane. This angular velocity is related to, but not equal to, the orbital angular velocity; this is because it is measured in the altitude-azimuth coordinate system centered at the telescope rather than in the equatorial coordinate system. As in F. Fankhauser et al. 2023 this calculation can be simplified by using a satellite-centered frame, although we make some modifications to the axes definitions. As before the z-axis points along the satellite nadir. However for our purposes, the y-axis lies in the plane defined by the center of the Earth, the satellite, and the telescope, rather than the Sun and we apply the restriction that the angle between the y-axis and the vector from the satellite to

Read the complete text