Responsibility Gap in Collective Decision Making

Pavel Naumov, Jia Tao · 2025

Read Responsibility Gap in Collective Decision Making by Pavel Naumov, Jia Tao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-06312.txt.

Introduction

Pavel Naumov and Jia Tao study in 2025 the responsibility gap in group decisions. The gap is the set of outcomes for which no single member can be held responsible. Designers of voting and decision rules would like that gap small or empty, since blame and credit guide trust.

The pair propose a rule form they call elected dictatorship. With full information, they prove the gap is empty exactly when the rule has that form. With partial information, the family of gap-free rules sits strictly between two versions of that form. The results give designers a sharp test for when shared decisions leave no one answerable.

Catalog record

CREATORPavel Naumov, Jia Tao
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-06312

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Responsibility Gap in Collective Decision Making Pavel Naumov, Jia Tao Abstract The responsibility gap is a set of outcomes of a collective decision-making mechanism in which no single agent is individually responsible. In general, when designing a decision-making process, it is desirable to minimise the gap. The paper proposes a concept of an elected dictatorship. It shows that, in a perfect information setting, the gap is empty if and only if the mechanism is an elected dictatorship. It also proves that in an imperfect information setting, the class of gap-free mechanisms is positioned strictly between two variations of the class of elected dictatorships. 1 Introduction AI agents are involved in making significant decisions in our everyday lives – from driving autonomous vehicles and investing in stock to estimating (in the role of war robots) potential civilian casualties. For such decisions to be socially acceptable, there should be at least one agent responsible for the outcome of the decision. That is, the decision-making mechanism should be designed without responsibility gaps. The term responsibility gap (or responsibility void) is used in the literature in two distinct but related ways. First, it refers to situations where an agent who would normally be held responsible lacks moral agency –for example, minors, animals, and often AI systems Matthias (2004) ; Champagne and Tonkens (2015) ; Burton et al. (2020) ; Coeckelbergh (2020) ; Gunkel (2020) ; Santoni de Sio and Mecacci (2021) ; Tigard (2021) ; Königs (2022) ; Oimann (2023) ; Hindriks and Veluwenkamp (2023) . Second, it describes cases where the design of a collective decision-making mechanism is such that no single agent (artificial or otherwise) can be held accountable for the outcome of the group decision Braham and van Hees (2011) ; Duijf (2018) ; List (2021) ; Duijf (2022) ; Dastani and Yazdanpanah (2023) ; Shi and Naumov (2025) . In this paper, we investigate the properties of responsibility gaps–specifically in the second sense–using the concept of an elected dictatorship that we introduce. We demonstrate that in the perfect information setting, the responsibility gap is empty if and only if the mechanism constitutes an elected dictatorship. In the case of imperfect information, we further show that the class of gap-free mechanisms lies strictly between two variants of elected dictatorships. After the statement of Theorem 1 , we compare our findings with two closely related results from the literature. 2 Decision-making Mechanisms An example of a collective decision-making mechanism is the Two-person Rule used to launch American Minuteman II intercontinental ballistic missiles with nuclear warheads. Only the President of the United States can authorise the launch of the missiles. Once the President issues a launch order, the crew on the missile launch site must strap to their chairs (in case of a nuclear attack on the launch facility). Then, two on-duty officers must simultaneously turn their keys to activate the launch. No single officer can turn both keys because they are 12 feet apart United States Air Force (2024) . Figure 1 : Two-person Rule mechanism. Figure 1 depicts this mechanism as a tree. In this figure, the President ( P ) can unilaterally decide not to launch the missiles and, thus, transition the decision-making process from node u_{1} to node v_{1} . Alternatively, the President can transition the mechanism to node u_{2} . In that node, officers A and B must simultaneously turn the keys in order for the decision path to end in node v_{3} where the missiles are automatically launched 1 1 1 Technically, for missiles to leave the silos, another pair of keys must be turned at another launch control facility United States Air Force (2024) . However, this does not change the responsibility analysis in this paper. . If either of them does not turn the key, the decision-making process transitions from node u_{2} to node v_{2} and the missiles are not launched. The next definition generalises the mechanism depicted in Figure 1 . Definition 1 . A tuple (V,E,\mathcal{A},\Delta,\tau,\ell) is a decision-making mechanism, where 1. (V,E) is a rooted directed tree; by L and D we denote the set of all leaf and decision (non-leaf) nodes of this tree, respectively. For each decision node v\in D , by Ch_{v} we denote the set \{u\in V\mid(v,u)\in E\} of children of node v , 2. \mathcal{A} is a set of “agents”, 3. \Delta_{v}^{a} is a nonempty set of “actions” available to an agent a\in\mathcal{A} at a decision node v\in D , 4. \tau_{v}:\prod_{a\in\mathcal{A}}\Delta_{v}^{a}\to Ch_{v} is a choice function for each decision node v\in D , 5. \ell:L\to\{\text{Yes},\text{No}\} is a labelling function that maps leaf nodes into “outcomes”. Although trees are usually assumed to be finite, the results of this paper also hold for a rooted directed tree (V,E) of infinite width (but not infinite depth). In the case of the mechanism in Figure 1 , nodes u_{1} and u_{2} are the decision nodes and nodes v_{1} , v_{2} , and v_{3} are the leaf nodes. Relation E is represented by the directed edges in the figure. In this example, the set of agents consists of the President P and officers A and B . Each of the agents has two actions: “go left” (Left) and “go right” (Right). The choice function \tau_{v} determines which node the decision process transitions to based on the actions of agents taken at node v . Intuitively, we assume that only the President decides at node u_{1} in Figure 1 and only the two officers contribute to the decision at node u_{2} . This can be captured in the more general setting of Definition 1 by assuming that all three agents act at each decision node, but some actions might not influence the decision at all. For example, function \tau_{u_{1}} formally takes a tuple (representing actions of agents P , A , and B ). However, the value of this function is completely determined by the action of agent P alone. Similarly, the value of \tau_{u_{2}} is completely determined by the actions of agents A and B . Labelling function \ell specifies the outcome of the decision-making process at each of the leaf nodes. Note that in this paper, we only consider the mechanisms that make binary ( Yes/No ) decisions. We briefly discuss a more general class of mechanisms in the conclusion. Note that each element \delta of the set \Pi_{a\in\mathcal{A}}\Delta^{a}_{v} specifies a possible combination of actions of all agents at a decision node v . We refer to such a combination \delta as an action profile at node v . By \delta_{a} we denote the action of agent a\in\mathcal{A} under the profile \delta . Intuitively, by Next^{a}_{d}(v) we denote the set of all children of node v to which the decision-making process can transition from node v if agent a chooses action d . Definition 2 . Next^{a}_{d}(v)=\{\tau_{v}(\delta)\mid\delta_{a}=d\} . In the case of our running example, Next^{A}_{\text{Left}}(u_{2})=\{v_{2}\} and Next^{A}_{\text{Right}}(u_{2})=\{v_{2},v_{3}\} . 3 Counterfactual Responsibility Imagine now a situation, when the President decides to authorise a nuclear strike, the two officers turn the keys, and half of the world is destroyed. Who is responsible for this? The notion of responsibility has been extensively studied in philosophy and law. In philosophy, one of the

Read the complete text