Accessing the dipole-multipole transition in rapidly rotating spherical shell dynamos

Andrew T. Clarke 1∗, Christopher J. Davies 1, Stephen J. Mason 1, Souvik Naskar 1 1 School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds LS29JT, UK. E-mail: [email protected] · 2025

Read Accessing the dipole-multipole transition in rapidly rotating spherical shell dynamos by Andrew T. Clarke 1∗, Christopher J. Davies 1, Stephen J. Mason 1, Souvik Naskar 1 1 School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds LS29JT, UK. E-mail: [email protected] (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-06251.txt.

Introduction

Andrew Clarke and co-authors chart a shortcut to the edge where a planet's magnetic field flips style in this 2025 paper. Dynamo simulations model the churning metal core that makes the field. The flip from a dipole field to a tangled multipolar one sits near where polarity reversals happen, but reaching it in realistic settings is costly.

Their path theory simplifies the hunt by holding one key number fixed and balancing the main forces. Three paths were built and tested. Following them led simulations into the transition zone at very low spin friction, among the most extreme values yet reached. The catch: the magnetic strength required drifts past what Earth data allow. New buoyancy patterns may fix that.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrew T. Clarke 1∗, Christopher J. Davies 1, Stephen J. Mason 1, Souvik Naskar 1 1 School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds LS29JT, UK. E-mail: [email protected]
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-06251

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Accessing the dipole-multipole transition in rapidly rotating spherical shell dynamos Andrew T. Clarke 1∗, Christopher J. Davies 1, Stephen J. Mason 1, Souvik Naskar 1 1 School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds LS29JT, UK. E-mail: [email protected] Abstract keywords Dynamo: theories and simulations; Geomagnetic Reversals. {summary} Earth’s magnetic field has exhibited erratic polarity reversals over much of its history; however, the processes that cause polarity transitions are still poorly understood. Dipole reversals have been found in many numerical dynamo simulations and often occur close to the transition between dipole-dominated and multipolar dynamo regimes. However, the physical conditions used in reversing simulations are necessarily far from those in Earth’s liquid iron core because of the long runtimes needed to capture polarity transitions and because a systematic exploration of parameter space is needed to find the dipole-multipole transition. Here, we develop a unidimensional path theory in an attempt to simplify the search for the dipole-multipole transition at increasingly realistic physical conditions. We consider three paths that are all built from the requirements of a constant magnetic Reynolds number \mathit{Rm} ; one path further attempts to impose balance between Magnetic, Coriolis, and Archimedean forces (a MAC balance) while the other two seek to constrain solutions to an inertia-MAC, or IMAC, balance. The presence of inertia, although not geophysically realistic, allows us to build paths that more closely follow the conditions where simulated reversals have been found to date. Numerical simulations show reasonable agreement with the expected physical conditions along the paths within the accessible parameter space, but also deviate from predicted behaviour for certain diagnostic quantities, particularly the magnetic field strength and the magnetic/kinetic energy ratio. Furthermore, the paths do not follow the dipole-multipole transition; starting from reversing conditions, simulations move into the dipolar non-reversing regime as they are advanced along the path. By increasing the Rayleigh number, a measure of the buoyancy driving convection, above the values predicted by the path theory, we are able to access the dipole-multipole transition down to an Ekman number \mathit{E}\sim 10^{-6} , comparable to the most extreme conditions reported to date. Our results, therefore, demonstrate that the path approach is an efficient method for seeking the dipole-multipole transition in rapidly rotating dynamos. However, the conditions under which we access the dipole-multipole transition become increasingly hard to access numerically and also increasingly unrealistic because \mathit{Rm} rises beyond plausible bounds inferred from geophysical observations. Future work combining path theory with variations in the core buoyancy distribution, as suggested by recent studies, appears a promising approach to accessing the dipole-multiple transition at extreme physical conditions. 1 Introduction Paleomagnetic data shows that Earth’s magnetic field has reversed polarity many times over it’s history ( strik_palaeomagnetism_2003 ; ogg2020geomagnetic ) . The present reversal rate is around 4 per Myr, while past reversal rates have dropped to zero for tens of millions of years during superchrons and reached 10 reversals per Myr in “hyper-reversing” periods like the Jurassic ( biggin_possible_2012 , e.g.) . The origin of these rare but extreme fluctuations is the dynamo process in Earth’s liquid iron core, which converts the kinetic energy of convective fluid motion into magnetic energy. An outstanding problem is to identify the conditions under which dipole-dominated dynamos reverse polarity. Owing to the inherent nonlinearity of the dynamo problem, this question is generally addressed using numerical simulations, and this is the approach taken in the present study. Reversals of spherical shell dynamos were first reported by glatzmaiers_three-dimensional_1995 . Since then, many simulated reversals have been reported at a variety of different physical conditions ( kutzner_stable_2002 ; wicht_inner-core_2002 ; driscoll2009polarity ; olson_complex_2011 ; heimpel_testing_2013 ; olson_magnetic_2014 ; driscoll2018paleomagnetic ; sprain_assessment_2019 ; menu_magnetic_2020 ; gwirtz2022can ; nakagawa_combined_2022 ; tassin_geomagnetic_2021 ; jones2025low , e.g.) . An important result is that increasing the Rayleigh number \mathit{Ra} , a measure of the buoyancy force driving convection, with all other parameters fixed leads to a transition from a stable dipole-dominated core-mantle boundary (CMB) field at low \mathit{Ra} to a reversing dipole and then to the loss of dipole dominance and emergence of the so-called multipolar state as \mathit{Ra} increases ( kutzner_stable_2002 ; christensen_scaling_2006 ; olson_dipole_2006 ) . This has led several authors to postulate that the geodynamo lies close to the dipole-multipole transition ( olson_dipole_2006 ; driscoll_effects_2009 , e.g.) . One interpretation is that reversals represent brief incursions of the dynamo into the multipolar regime ( olson_complex_2011 ) . The physical processes that determine the multipole-dipole transition have been widely debated, and several possibilities have been proposed. mcdermott2019physical argued that the multipole state arises from the suppression of inertial waves since these waves have been hypothesised to sustain the convection columns that maintain the dipole field ( ranjan2018internally ) . Recently, majumder_self-similarity_2024 suggested that the transition arises when a specific class of magnetic wave is suppressed in the dynamo, while frasson2024geomagnetic argue that lateral heterogeneity in CMB heat flux promotes reversals by suppressing westward zonal flows. Several alternatives focus on the enhanced role of inertia in the force balance ( sreenivasan_role_2006 ) . Hydrodynamic criteria to describe the transition include balances between Inertia (I) and Coriolis (C) forces at the characteristic velocity lengthscale d_{\mathrm{u}} ( christensen_scaling_2006 , an IC balance measured by the local Rossby number criterion \mathit{Ro}_{\ell}\sim 0.12 ,) , inertia and Viscous forces ( soderlund_influence_2012 , IV balance,) , a non-gradient triple VIC balance ( oruba2014transition ) , and loss of equatorial symmetry due to enhanced inertia ( garcia2017equatorial ) . However, recent studies have challenged the local Rossby number and equatorial symmetry criteria and instead highlighted the role of the magnetic field ( menu_magnetic_2020 ) . In particular, tassin_geomagnetic_2021 used a large suite of simulations to show that the transition from dipole-dominated to multipolar solutions arises at a magnetic to kinetic energy ratio \mathcal{M}\sim 1 ( tassin_geomagnetic_2021 ) . The challenge of describing the dipole-multipole transition arises because of the vast range of spatial and temporal scales inherent to the dynamo problem, which makes direct numerical simulations at Earth’s core parameters impossible. The important control parameters are the Ekman number \mathit{E} , which compares the importance of rotation with viscosity, the Rayleigh number \mathit{Ra} , measuring the vigour of convection, and the magnetic Prandtl number \mathit{Pm} , the ratio of viscous and magnetic diffusion coefficients. In the most extreme (non-reversing) direct numerical simulations (DNS) \mathit{E} is limited to \mathit{E}\gtrsim 10^{-7} ( schaeffer_turbulent_2017 , e.g.) , much larger than the value of \mathit{E}\sim 10^{-15} in the Earth, while \mathit{Ra} and \mathit{Pm} must be set respectively much lower and higher compared to Earth values in order to obtain dipole-dominated dynamo action. In terms of diagnostic quantities, simulations can reach geophysically relevant values of the magnetic Reynolds number (the ratio of magnetic advection to diffusion), \mathit{Rm}\sim 1000 , but not the small values of the Rossby number, \mathit{Ro}\sim 10^{-6} , characterising the balance of inertial and Coriolis effects. Reversing simulations are further compromised compared to simulations that attempt to reproduce short-timescale dynamics ( aubert_state_2023 , e.g.) because of the long integration times (usually greater than 1 magnetic diffusion time, or O(10^{5}) yrs) needed to observe reversals. Indeed, all reversing simulations have been conducted at \mathit{E}\geq 10^{-5} ( sheyko_magnetic_2016 ; tassin_geomagnetic_2021 ) , except for the DNS study of sheyko_magnetic_2016 who

Read the complete text