The Tantalizing Case of the Quasar J0950 + + 5128 – I. Presentation of the Data and Detailed Exploration of the Binary Supermassive Black Hole Scenario Facilities: Sloan(SDSS;BOSS), HET(LRS;LRS2), Palomar(DBSP), Keck(LRIS), IRSA, CRTS, NEOWISE, ZTF

Niana N. Mohammed, Jessie C. Runnoe, Michael Eracleous, Tamara Bogdanović, Daniel Stern, Joseph Simon, Maria Charisi, T. Joseph W. Lazio, Kaitlyn Szekerczes, Steinn Sigurðsson, Collin Dabbieri · 2025

Read The Tantalizing Case of the Quasar J0950 + + 5128 – I. Presentation of the Data and Detailed Exploration of the Binary Supermassive Black Hole Scenario Facilities: Sloan(SDSS;BOSS), HET(LRS;LRS2), Palomar(DBSP), Keck(LRIS), IRSA, CRTS, NEOWISE, ZTF by Niana N. Mohammed, Jessie C. Runnoe, Michael Eracleous, Tamara Bogdanović, Daniel Stern, Joseph Simon, Maria Charisi, T. Joseph W. Lazio, Kaitlyn Szekerczes, Steinn Sigurðsson, Collin Dabbieri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-06221.txt.

Introduction

Niana Mohammed and co-authors present in this 2025 paper twenty-two years of watching one quasar, J0950+5128, for signs of two black holes. A key emission line in its light creeps steadily in velocity and widens over time, traits that could betray a binary pair of supermassive black holes. The team measures the drift with care, checks the light curves, and weighs five rival stories, from dust clouds to a recoiling black hole.

No repeating cycle shows up in the timing tests. Two stories survive as plausible: a binary pair, or a single disturbed gas disk. The binary fit gives a thirty-three-year orbit with high eccentricity. The authors call the quasar a candidate worth continued watching.

Catalog record

CREATORNiana N. Mohammed, Jessie C. Runnoe, Michael Eracleous, Tamara Bogdanović, Daniel Stern, Joseph Simon, Maria Charisi, T. Joseph W. Lazio, Kaitlyn Szekerczes, Steinn Sigurðsson, Collin Dabbieri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-06221

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Tantalizing Case of the Quasar J0950 + + 5128 – I. Presentation of the Data and Detailed Exploration of the Binary Supermassive Black Hole Scenario Facilities: Sloan(SDSS;BOSS), HET(LRS;LRS2), Palomar(DBSP), Keck(LRIS), IRSA, CRTS, NEOWISE, ZTF Niana N. Mohammed, Jessie C. Runnoe, Michael Eracleous, Tamara Bogdanović, Daniel Stern, Joseph Simon, Maria Charisi, T. Joseph W. Lazio, Kaitlyn Szekerczes, Steinn Sigurðsson, Collin Dabbieri Abstract Spectroscopic observations of the quasar J0950 + + 5128 spanning 22 years reveal monotonic radial velocity variations in its broad H β \beta emission line. Moreover, the line profile becomes broader over time, necessitating careful measurements. We present robust H β \beta velocity shift measurements obtained via cross correlation, applied to both the full spectra and to isolated broad H β \beta components derived from spectral decomposition. We also examine the light curves for variability consistent with the spectroscopic trends. Using Lomb-Scargle periodogram analysis we find no significant periodic signal. We consider several interpretations for the observed changes, including a binary supermassive black hole, dust-cloud obscuration, outflows, a recoiling black hole, and a single perturbed, disk-like broad-line region. We deem the binary and perturbed broad-line region scenarios to be physically plausible. The binary interpretation is the only one for which we can immediately compare a physical model to the available data. Thus, we incorporate radial velocity “jitter” to emulate typical quasar variability and fit the radial velocity curve with a Keplerian model to examine whether it can reproduce the observations. In this context, the available observations trace only a segment of the putative orbit. The fit yields a period of 33 years (observed frame) and an eccentricity of 0.65, with lower limits on the semi-major axis and black hole mass of 10 − 2 10^{-2}\; pc and 10 7 ​ M ⊙ 10^{7}\;{\rm M}_{\odot} , respectively. Thus, J0950 + + 5128 is a binary candidate deserving further study. The single, perturbed broad-line region interpretation remains viable but requires additional observations and modeling for further evaluation. Continued monitoring is, therefore, essential. numpy [ 60 ] , astropy [ 7 , 5 , 6 ] , scipy [ 126 ] , matplotlib [ 66 ] , extinction [ 9 ] , radvel [ 49 ] , spectres [ 21 ] , pandas [ 119 ] I Introduction I.1 Background and Motivation Galaxy mergers are a frequently observed phenomenon, and given that most massive galaxies have central supermassive black holes (BHs; Kormendy and Richstone 73 ), supermassive black hole binaries (SBHBs) are thought to be an inevitable consequence of the merger process. [ 12 ] described how a SBHB evolves in a post-galaxy merger. The evolution begins with the stellar bulges and respective BHs of the two galaxies sinking toward the center of the merger remnant. This process is initially driven by dynamical friction ( Chandrasekhar 22 ), which acts as the dominant mechanism for angular momentum loss for \sim 10 9 yr for typical masses and can bring the BH pair closer. At a separation of \lesssim 10 pc, the BHs form a gravitationally bound binary (e.g., Bogdanović et al. 19 ). Eventually, the binary “hardens” as its orbital velocity becomes comparable to the velocity dispersion of the stars. At this point, stellar scattering takes over as the dominant mechanism that further reduces the binary separation. Stellar scattering is effective so long as the number of stars with the right orbits to interact with the binary can be replenished ( Milosavljević and Merritt 91 , Yu et al. 133 ). If this reservoir of stars is depleted, the binary separation may slow its evolution or stall at a separation of \sim 1 pc (known as the “last parsec problem”). However, several models––ranging from angular momentum loss through interactions with a circumbinary accretion disk or gaseous cloud (e.g., Armitage and Natarajan 4 , Escala et al. 46 , Dotti et al. 34 , Cuadra et al. 28 ) to dynamical models that consider non-spherical and anisotropic stellar distributions (e.g., Merritt and Poon 87 , Berczik et al. 17 , Khan et al. 69 , Khan et al. 68 , Holley-Bockelmann and Khan 64 )––now suggest that there are a number of sufficiently efficient mechanisms for continued orbital decay. Once the binary separation reaches \lesssim\, 10 -2 pc, angular momentum loss via gravitational waves (GWs) becomes an efficient mechanism, leading the two BHs to coalesce within a Hubble time. Unambiguous observational evidence for SBHBs has been confined to the early stages of their evolution. Galaxy mergers and widely separated (kilo-parsec and sub-kilo-parsec scale) BH pairs are observed (e.g., Comerford et al. 26 , Comerford et al. 27 , Liu et al. 81 , Ellison et al. 40 , Hou et al. 65 , Foord et al. 48 , Goulding et al. 55 , Shen et al. 114 , Koss et al. 74 ), but bound SBHBs have yet to be imaged and resolved directly. An exception is the radio-loud candidate CSO 0402+379, directly imaged through radio interferometry with a projected separation of \sim 7 pc ( Rodriguez et al. 106 , Bansal et al. 8 ). The recent evidence of a stochastic GW background by pulsar timing array (PTA) experiments is compatible with the low-frequency signal expected from a population of SBHBs at the last stages of their evolution ( Agazie et al. 1 , Agazie et al. 2 , EPTA Collaboration et al. 41 , Reardon et al. 102 , Xu et al. 132 , Miles et al. 89 ), strongly suggesting that SBHBs must evolve to merger, emitting GWs in the process. This is promising for directly resolving nanohertz GWs (corresponding to orbital periods of tens of years) from individual SBHBs at sub-parsec separations. The upcoming Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA; Amaro-Seoane et al. 3 , Colpi et al. 25 ) is also expected to detect SBHB mergers, at higher frequencies corresponding to somewhat lower BH masses and later stages of SBHB evolution than those detected by the PTAs. SBHBs have also been invoked to explain a number of galaxy properties, including mass deficits in the cores of elliptical galaxies (e.g., Milosavljević et al. 90 , Merritt 88 ), helical or precessing jets (e.g., Roos et al. 108 , Romero et al. 107 ), and X-shaped radio sources (e.g., Merritt and Ekers 86 , Gopal-Krishna et al. 54 ). Finding unambiguous SBHBs at small separations ( \sim 0.1 - 1 pc) would greatly enhance our understanding of their evolution and their effects on their host galaxies. Thus, indirect methods have been developed to search for their observational signatures. The two most commonly used methods, which we describe further below, rely on periodic photometric variability or regular spectroscopic (radial velocity) variability of the broad emission lines. In addition to these, a few other methods have been proposed that are appropriate for SBHBs at separations of \sim 10^{-2} – 1 pc: peculiar profiles and relative intensities of broad emission lines [ 92 , 93 , e.g.,] , proper motion measurements via infrared interferometry [ 30 , e.g.] , periodic modulation of the polarization of scattered light [ 33 , e.g.] , kinematic signatures in reverberation mapping signals [ 127 , e.g.,] , or blue-red asymmetric reverberation of the broad emission lines [

Read the complete text