Controlling the morphologies and dynamics in three-dimensional tissues
Rajsekhar Das 1, Xin Li 1, Sumit Sinha 2, D. Thirumalai 1,2 · 2025
Read Controlling the morphologies and dynamics in three-dimensional tissues by Rajsekhar Das 1, Xin Li 1, Sumit Sinha 2, D. Thirumalai 1,2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-06168.txt.
Introduction
Rajsekhar Das, Xin Li, Sumit Sinha, and Dhananjay Thirumalai wrote a 2025 paper on what controls the shape and motion of three dimensional tissues. Cells push on each other and also propel themselves with internal forces. How those two factors combine to set tissue behavior was the question.
The team built a minimal 3D model where cells repel each other elastically at short range. Each cell also gets random self propulsion kicks, the only source of motion. By varying cell size spread and stiffness, they found distinct phases, all driven by propulsion strength. Soft tissues flow like liquids, while stiff, varied tissues turn glassy. Evenly sized stiff cells can even crystallize. Near the glass boundary, viscosity rises sharply with density.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rajsekhar Das 1, Xin Li 1, Sumit Sinha 2, D. Thirumalai 1,2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-06168
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Controlling the morphologies and dynamics in three-dimensional tissues Rajsekhar Das 1, Xin Li 1, Sumit Sinha 2, D. Thirumalai 1,2 Abstract A number of factors, such as, cell-cell interactions and self-propulsion of cells driven by cytoskeletal forces determine tissue morphologies and dynamics. To explore the interplay between these factors in controlling the dynamics at the tissue scale, we created a minimal three dimensional model in which short-range repulsive elastic forces account for cell-cell interactions. Self-propulsion is modeled as active uncorrelated random stochastic forces, with strength μ \mu , that act on individual cells and is the only source of cell motility. Strikingly, variations in polydispersity in cell sizes ( Σ \Sigma ) and cell elasticity ( E E ), results in the formation of a variety of distinct “phases”, driven entirely by μ \mu . At low E E , the tissue behaves like a liquid, at all values of Σ \Sigma , whereas at high E E and Σ \Sigma , it has the characteristics of a glass. The tissue crystallizes at low Σ \Sigma provided E E exceeds a critical value. Over a narrow range of E E and Σ \Sigma , that lies between the boundaries of the liquid and glass phase, the effective viscosity increases like in a glass as the cell density increases and saturates as the cells are compressed beyond a certain value, creating the viscosity saturation (VS) phase. The VS phase does not form in systems at finite temperature in which the dynamics satisfies the Fluctuation Dissipation Theorem. In the glass phase, the tissue exhibits aging (relaxation times depend on the waiting time) behavior at high E E values. Our findings provide a framework for designing tissues with tunable material properties by controlling the physical characteristics of cells. I Introduction Mechanical and morphological properties of cells are of fundamental importance to embryogenesis and cancer progression DonaldIngber2003 ; Guilak2009 ; Tambe2011 ; Kumar2009 ; petridou2019tissue ; PETRIDOU20211914 . The material properties of tissues change so dramatically, especially during development, that they are reminiscent of phase transitions Huebner2018 . Indeed, the sharp changes in tissue connectivity found during morphogenesis have been analyzed using the language and concepts familiar in the theory of phase transitions MORITA2017354 ; Mongera2018 ; Barriga2018 ; Petridou2019 ; li2024emergence ; PETRIDOU20211914 . Strikingly, the equilibrium rigidity percolation theory Thorpe1983 ; Jacobs1995PRL ; Jacobs1996PRE , intended to describe network glasses, was recently used to quantitatively accounts for zebrafish morphogenesis PETRIDOU20211914 . Not surprisingly, the morphological changes are also accompanied by substantial variations in the collective cell dynamics. Cells exhibit a broad range of dynamics spanning glass Schötz2013 ; Angelini2011 ; Nnetu2012 ; malmi2018cell , solid fung1993biomechanics ; Vandiver2009 , and liquid like behavior Liquidliketissue ; Beysens2000 ; ranft2010fluidization ; matoz2017cell ; malmi2018cell . A number of factors control the observed range of dynamical behavior. For instance, homeostasis between cell division and apoptosis fluidizes tissues at long times, which was first shown in a pioneering study ranft2010fluidization . In contrast, imaging experiments found glass-like dynamics, characterized by the vanishing of the migration speed in confluent epithelial cells at high cell densities in two dimensions (2D) Angelini2011 . Notably, the velocity fields were spatially heterogeneous, varying from region to region (sub-sample to sub-sample like in glasses Thirumalai89PRA ). Despite the crucial difference between synthetic materials and cellular systems in which cell division plays an important role in determining the dynamics Angelini2011 , experimental findings in the latter are reminiscent of dynamical heterogeneity in glass forming materials Biroli13JCP ; Kirkpatrick15RMP . Indeed, simulations using vertex models showed that there is a transition from glass to fluid bi2016motility in 2D confluent tissues, driven by self-propulsion (active force). Finally, theory and simulations accounting for cell division and apoptosis, and mechanical feedback exhibit complex dynamical behavior malmi2018cell . Variations in cell division rate and the strength of mechanical feedback result in sub-diffusive, diffusive, and even hyper diffusive dynamics Sinha25SoftMatter . An important issue that has received less attention is how changes in tissue morphology, which can be controlled by varying cell softness, affect collective dynamics, in non-confluent tissues in which cell division plays an insignificant role. A previous insightful study PETRIDOU20211914 has provided a link between morphology describing geometric networks in zebrafish blastoderm and the dynamics at a fixed value of cell elasticity. The observed morphological changes were quantitatively described using scaling laws that are valid near (second order) phase transitions Thorpe1983 ; Jacobs1995PRL ; Jacobs1996PRE . In particular, it was shown that the non-confluent tissue undergoes a rigidity percolation transition Jacobs1995PRL that is characterized by an abrupt increase in the cell-cell connectivity. Strikingly, the geometric changes are also reflected in viscosity (a collective property), which exhibits an unusual behavior as a function of cell packing fraction, \phi PETRIDOU20211914 . At \phi\leq\phi_{S} the viscosity increases sharply, like in a conventional glassy materials ANGELL199113 , but saturates when \phi increases beyond a critical value, \phi_{S} , a behavior that is rarely observed in synthetic materials sumitCommentary . We refer to this as the viscosity saturation (VS) regime. Computer simulations Das2023 , using a particle-based model of a two-dimensional (2D) tissue at a fixed value of the cell softness (elasticity), found that the plateau in \eta above \phi_{S} is a consequence of saturation in the available free area per cell beyond \phi_{S} . If the value of the elasticity is chosen such that the cells interpenetrate to some extent then \eta increases rapidly when \phi\leq\phi_{S} and saturates beyond \phi_{S} provided there is polydispersity ( \Sigma ) in the cell size. The applicability of the rigidity percolation theory PETRIDOU20211914 was rationalized by purely a geometric criterion associated with cell-cell contact topology, which is surprising given the complexity of morphogenesis. However, it is unclear how the network of cellular contacts would change if the cell elasticity is altered. This is not merely problem of an academic interest because cell softness plays a critical role in many biological properties, such as cell motility and cancer progression Luo2016 ; Cross2007 . For instance, metastatic cancer cells are softer than normal cells Cross2007 ; Alibert17BiolCell , and exhibit increased migration Liu2020 ; Watanabe2014 ; Gensbittel21DevCell . Other experiments Zhang2014 ; harn2015 ; rianna2020direct ; Gensbittel21DevCell also suggested that higher cell motility is usually correlated with lower stiffness because it helps the cells to deform more readily, allowing them to squeeze through constricted spaces during migration or invasion. The cell elastic modulus ( E ) could vary from 1.4\times 10^{-4}MPa (human melanoma WM115 cells Weder2014 ) to 1.6\times 10^{-3}MPa (non-malignant bladder HCV29 cells Ramos2014 ; gnanachandran2022discriminating ) depending on the cell type. How the order of magnitude change in cell elasticity impacts the morphology and collective dynamics in non-confluent tissue in three dimension (3D) is unknown. Here, we explore the morphological changes and the associated impact on the dynamics that occur as the cell softness and polydispersity are varied using a minimal computational model in which short range elastic (Hertz) forces are combined with stochastic self-propulsion forces. Although we are motivated by biological considerations, the work provides a framework for understanding the connections between material properties and dynamics in active soft matter systems. The central results, which were obtained using 3D simulations are: (i) For a