A note on quantum Hamiltonian reduction and anomalies

Boris M. Elfimov, Alexey A. Sharapov · 2025

Read A note on quantum Hamiltonian reduction and anomalies by Boris M. Elfimov, Alexey A. Sharapov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-05779.txt.

Introduction

Elfimov and Sharapov present a finite-dimensional Hamiltonian system whose quantization shows anomalies, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. Gauge field theories often face such anomalies during quantization. They are blamed on degrees of freedom without end. A regularization scheme is then thought to be needed to complete the model.

Their counterexample is a finite system with first-class constraints. Nothing about it is infinite-dimensional. Yet quantization still yields anomalies. The authors trace the anomaly's origin to the nontrivial topology of the reduced phase space. The example tests the standard story about where anomalies come from. It suggests topology, not infinity, can be the true culprit.

Catalog record

CREATORBoris M. Elfimov, Alexey A. Sharapov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-05779

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A note on quantum Hamiltonian reduction and anomalies Boris M. Elfimov, Alexey A. Sharapov Abstract . Quantization of field-theoretic models with gauge symmetries is often obstructed by quantum anomalies. It is commonly believed that the origin of these anomalies lies in the infinite number of degrees of freedom, which requires completing the model within an appropriate regularization scheme. This paper provides an explicit example of a finite-dimensional Hamiltonian system with first-class constraints whose quantization exhibits anomalies. These anomalies arise from the nontrivial topology of the reduced phase space. a To the cherished memory of Hans-Christian Herbig, gone too soon 1. Introduction The term quantum anomaly broadly refers to the violation of classical properties upon quantization. In quantum field theory, it typically implies the breaking of global or local symmetries present in the classical model. Quantum anomalies – or, more precisely, the conditions required for their cancellation – play a crucial role in understanding fundamental interactions. For instance, the requirement of conformal anomaly cancellation in string theory imposes stringent constraints on the spacetime dimension and other physical parameters. Similarly, the absence of a chiral anomaly in the Standard Model entails exact equality between the number of quark and lepton generations. Despite their diversity, all anomalies share a common origin related to the infinite dimensionality of field space. The infinite number of degrees of freedom necessitates regularization of a field-theoretical model, which may violate its classical symmetries. If the broken symmetry is not restored when the regulator is removed, an anomaly arises. In this work, by contrast, we focus on quantum anomalies within finite-dimensional gauge systems. There are numerous approaches to studying quantum anomalies in gauge theories. The most general and consistent framework is provided by the Hamiltonian formalism and the canonical quantization method. From this perspective, all gauge theories are Hamiltonian systems with first-class constraints. The quantization of such systems was initiated by Dirac and further developed into its modern form by Batalin, Fradkin, and Vilovisky (see, for example, [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] ). Within the BFV formalism, gauge anomalies manifest themselves as violations of the so-called master equations. Many claims regarding quantum anomalies in the physics literature unfortunately lack mathematical rigor. In the context of field theory, the question of whether anomalies depend on the choice of regularization scheme remains open. Furthermore, studies of finite-dimensional Hamiltonian systems with constraints typically focus on local properties. The well-known thesis of Dirac’s quantization [ 1 ] – “ m functionally independent first-class constraints reduce the dimension of the physical phase space by 2m ” – is generally invalid when the global geometry of the phase space is taken into account. Simple counterexamples to this claim are discussed in the next section. Although the absence of quantum anomalies in finite-dimensional gauge systems was proved in [ 2 ] , this result also holds only locally. This note aims to highlight global aspects of gauge theory quantization. General cohomological obstructions to the solutions of the quantum master equations have been studied in [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . In this work, we construct an explicit example of a constrained Hamiltonian system that exhibits unavoidable quantum anomalies in the algebra of physical observables. The construction relies on general results from the theory of integrable Hamiltonian systems. 2. Classical Reduction Let us consider a Hamiltonian system with n degrees of freedom and m first-class constraints T_{a}\approx 0 . In general, the phase space of the system is a 2n -dimensional smooth manifold M equipped with a non-degenerate Poisson bracket. According to Dirac [ 1 ] , the first-class type of the Hamiltonian constraints means that their pairwise Poisson brackets vanish on the common constraint surface \Sigma : (2.1) \{T_{a},T_{b}\}\approx 0\,. We will assume that the constraints satisfy the regularity condition (2.2) \left.dT_{1}\wedge\ldots\wedge dT_{m}\right|_{\Sigma}\neq 0\,. This condition guarantees that the constraint surface is a smooth coisotropic submanifold \Sigma\subset M of dimension 2n-m , and that the left-hand side of equation ( 2.1 ) is given by a linear combination of constraints U^{c}_{ab}T_{c} with some smooth functions U^{c}_{ab} . The involution condition ( 2.1 ) means that the Hamiltonian vector fields X_{a}=\{T_{a},-\} are tangent to the constraint surface \Sigma , defining a smooth integrable distribution of rank m . The integral leaves of this distribution are called gauge orbits , and the resulting foliation \mathcal{F} on \Sigma is called the gauge foliation . In the case where the gauge foliation is a smooth fibration, the space of gauge orbits \Sigma/\mathcal{F} is a smooth manifold (the base of the fibration), called the reduced phase space of the Hamiltonian system and denoted by M/\!/{T_{a}} . This terminology extends also to the general case where the set \Sigma/\mathcal{F} is not a smooth Hausdorff manifold. In this case, “smooth functions” on the reduced phase space N=M/\!/{T_{a}} are identified with smooth functions on \Sigma that are constant along the gauge orbits: (2.3) C^{\infty}(N)=\big\{f\in C^{\infty}(\Sigma)\;|\;X_{a}f=0\big\}\,. When the regularity condition ( 2.2 ) holds, the commutative algebra of functions C^{\infty}(\Sigma) is isomorphic to the quotient algebra C^{\infty}(M)/J by the ideal J generated by the functions T_{a} . The involution condition ( 2.1 ) is equivalent to the closure of the ideal under Poisson brackets: \{J,J\}\subset J . This allows one to define the Poisson algebra of smooth functions on the reduced phase space as the quotient algebra C^{\infty}(M)^{J}/J , where (2.4) C^{\infty}(M)^{J}=\big\{f\in C^{\infty}(M)\;|\;\{f,J\}\subset J\;\big\} is the stabilizer of J in C^{\infty}(M) . With this definition, the original Poisson bracket on M induces a Poisson structure on the algebra C^{\infty}(N) even when the reduced phase space N is not a smooth Hausdorff manifold. Elements of the algebra C^{\infty}(N) are called physical observables of the Hamiltonian system with constraints. As an example illustrating both smooth and non-smooth Hamiltonian reduction by first-class constraints, consider the harmonic oscillator with two degrees of freedom. The Hamiltonian of the system has the form (2.5) H_{0}=H_{1}+H_{2}=\frac{\omega_{1}}{2}(p_{1}^{2}+x_{1}^{2})+\frac{\omega_{2}}{2}(p_{2}^{2}+x_{2}^{2})\,, where \omega_{1} and \omega_{2} are the frequencies of the oscillator, and (p_{1},x_{1}) and (p_{2},x_{2}) are canonically conjugate pairs of variables. We interpret the equation of the isoenergetic surface H_{0}=E>0 as a first-class constraint H_{0}-E\approx 0 in the 4-dimensional phase space \mathbb{R}^{4} . Topologically, the constraint surface \Sigma is a 3-dimensional sphere (ellipsoid). The Hamiltonian flow X_{H_{0}}=\{H_{0},-\} does not vanish anywhere on \Sigma , foliating the constraint surface into one-dimensional gauge orbits. The structure of the resulting foliation is fully determined by whether the frequencies are commensurate or not: when \omega_{1}/\omega_{2}\in\mathbb{Q} all trajectories are closed and diffeomorphic to S^{1} , otherwise all trajectories are diffeomorphic to \mathbb{R} . Additional information about the foliation structure can be obtained by noting that the energies of both oscillators, i.e., the functions H_{1} and H_{2} , are first integrals of motion of the system ( 2.5 ). Clearly, the equations (2.6) H_{1}=E_{1}\,,\qquad H_{2}=E_{2} for various constants E_{1} and E_{2} , related by E_{1}+E_{2}=E , foliate the isoenergetic surface of the oscillator into two-dimensional Liouville tori. These tori are all either resonant or non-resonant depending on whether the rotation number \omega_{1}/\omega_{2} is rational or irrational. For the isotropic oscillator, for example, we immediately obtain the Hopf fibration p:S^{3}\rightarrow S^{2} with fiber S^{1} , so that the reduced phase space \mathbb{R}^{4}/\!/\{H_{0}-E\} indeed turns out to be a smooth manifold

Read the complete text