Atmospheric Newtonian Noise May Constrain Third-Generation Gravitational-Wave Detectors
Wenhui Wang, Teviet Creighton · 2025
Read Atmospheric Newtonian Noise May Constrain Third-Generation Gravitational-Wave Detectors by Wenhui Wang, Teviet Creighton (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-05690.txt.
Introduction
Wenhui Wang and Teviet Creighton warn that air itself may set a noise floor for next-wave gravity detectors. Their 2025 paper treats Newtonian noise, the tug of passing pockets of dense and thin air on the test masses. Future detectors reach for lower tones, where this once-small noise can swell.
Two air sources are weighed: sound-like pressure waves and drifting warm-cold patches. Broad scaling rules give the noise spectrum without site maps. Current top detectors stay safe from this limit, the math confirms. Third-wave machines that chase low tones will likely meet it as a lead noise, with burial depth setting the low cutoff. Site picks must now weigh the sky as well as the ground.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wenhui Wang, Teviet Creighton |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-05690
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Atmospheric Newtonian Noise May Constrain Third-Generation Gravitational-Wave Detectors Wenhui Wang, Teviet Creighton Abstract Advanced gravitational-wave detector designs are pushing towards lower frequencies, where certain types of noise, previously considered negligible, may come to dominate the detectors’ noise budgets. In particular, we revisit atmospheric Newtonian noise, caused by the fluctuating gravitational field as regions of high and low gas density move past the detector. We consider density perturbations both due to pressure waves (infrasound) and due to advected temperature fluctuations. In the absence of detailed site-specific models of topography, airflow, and building design, we present general scaling formulae that estimate the spectrum of atmospheric Newtonian noise, and show how it is affected by broad detector design choices. We confirm previous analyses that show that atmospheric Newtonian noise is not likely a strong contributor to advanced LIGO; however, it will be a dominant factor for third-generation detectors targeting low frequencies, with the low-frequency cutoff principally constrained by the depth of the detector underground. 1 Introduction In 2015, the first direct detection of gravitational waves was made by the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO) [ 1 ] . Since then, LIGO and similar “second generation” detectors Virgo [ 2 ] and KAGRA [ 3 ] have provided a steady stream of gravitational wave observations. Now, with the field of gravitational-wave astronomy firmly established, plans are afoot in the coming decade to build “third generation” detectors, such as the Einstein Telescope (ET) [ 4 , 5 ] and Cosmic Explorer [ 6 , 7 ] . At the same time, new detector concepts such as the proposed Torsion Bar Antenna (TOBA) [ 8 ] and Superconducting Omnidirectional Gravitational Radiation Observatory (SOGRO) [ 9 , 10 ] seek to achieve similar or better sensitivities using novel technologies, while ambitions space-based detector proposals such as LISA [ 11 ] , DECIGO [ 12 ] , and TianQin [ 13 ] benefit from immense interferometer baselines and isolation from terrestrial noise sources. The scientific gains of these proposed detectors come from improved sensitivity and/or greater spectral range, particularly at low frequencies. In doing so, they will encounter new sources of noise previously deemed unimportant for second-generation detectors. A particularly insidious source of noise is Newtonian Noise (NN), the changing near-zone gravitational field caused by masses moving near the detector (distinct from the far-zone propagating gravitational waves from astrophysical objects that these observatories seek to detect). Newtonian noise can arise from any sort of mass motion, including in the ground [ 14 ] , the air [ 15 ] , and from human activity [ 16 ] . These sources pose a particular challenge at low ( \;\makebox[0.0pt][l]{\raisebox{-0.43057pt}{${}^{<}$}}\mbox{\raisebox{0.43057pt}{${}_{\sim}$}}\;10\mathrm{Hz} ) frequencies. Since detectors cannot be isolated or shielded from gravitational fields, the only way to overcome Newtonian noise is to suppress all movement of masses in the vicinity of the detector, or to model these masses and subtract their contribution. In [ 15 ] one of us (Creighton) derived formulae and made estimates of atmospheric Newtonian gravitational noise (there called “gravity gradient noise”) due to propagating pressure waves (infrasound) and to thermal variations in the atmosphere being carried past the detector. It was motivated primarily by the target sensitivity of the advanced LIGO detectors, and concluded that these noise sources would not likely dominate the advanced LIGO noise budget at 10 Hz. Now that advanced LIGO is operating and third generation observatories are in the planning stages, it seems prudent to revisit the question of atmospheric gravitational noise from a broader perspective, considering a wider variety of detector configurations. This paper presents general scaling laws for the strain noise power spectral density S_{h}(f) , with tunable parameters to accommodate a variety of instrumental designs. In particular, the results will be applicable to gravity gradiometers (instruments with very short baselines) as well as long-baseline laser interferometric detectors, and will consider the effects of moving the instrument underground or even (in principle) near-Earth space. Our goal is not, primarily, to give specific predictions for any particular design, but to provide a more general analytic tool to evaluate and assess noise “risk” for different design concepts. The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 gives estimates of the noise due to low-frequency pressure perturbations (infrasound), and demonstrates the broad comparability of our formalism with the results of other researchers [ 17 ] . Section 3 estimates the noise due to temperature perturbations advected past the instrument, which represents a more concerning and difficult-to-mitigate source of Newtonian noise. Section 4 presents some typical results for certain canonical design choices. Section 5 discusses the general prospects for advanced detectors, concluding with the observation that these detectors’ low-frequency response will be largely constrained by their depth underground. An appendix presents numerical simulations that were undertaken to check the validity of our analytic formulae. 2 Infrasonic gravitational noise Infrasound consists of atmospheric pressure fluctuations below 20 Hz. Infrasound researchers [ 18 ] distinguish between coherent infrasound (pressure waves propagating from remote sources) and incoherent or wind-generated infrasound (pressure changes caused by turbulent airflow at the receiver). For purposes of gravitational noise, we are concerned primarily with coherent infrasound; wind-driven infrasound would behave in a manner similar to thermal fluctuations described in section 3 , but with density perturbations about 4 orders of magnitude lower. We start with a derivation of the gravitational perturbation due to a coherent plane pressure wave, in a slightly more generic form than in [ 15 ] . We will first give the general scaling law, then the more precise form of the gravitational noise for a coherent plane wave, then show approximately how various real-world effects modify the ideal form. The gravitational field of an infinite plane of density \rho and thickness w is g=2\pi\rho w . In a plane wave train, successive planes of density perturbation \pm\delta\rho largely cancel each other out, but this cancellation is not exact due to incoherence of the wave train. The result is that the effective field of the entire train comes from the asymmetry of the density perturbation \pm\delta\rho at a distance \pm\lambda/2 on either side of a given point, giving a gravitational field: \delta g\;\;\sim\;\;G\delta\rho\,\lambda (1) More precisely, consider a wave train of density perturbations \rho=\rho_{0}+\rho_{1}\cos(\omega t-kx) , with k=2\pi/\lambda=\omega/v_{s} where v_{s} is the sound speed. The disturbance in the gravitational field is given by: \begin{array}[]{rcl}\delta g_{x}&=&\displaystyle\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}2\pi G\rho_{1}\cos(\omega t-kx)\,\mathrm{sgn}(x)\,dx\\[8.61108pt] &=&\displaystyle 2\pi G\rho_{1}\left(\int_{0}^{\infty}\cos(\omega t-kx)\,dx-\int_{0}^{\infty}\cos(\omega t+kx)\,dx\right)\end{array} Although not formally integrable, we can solve this using a regularizing factor e^{-ax} with a\ll k (physically equivalent to imposing incoherence on a scale l\gg\lambda ): \delta g_{x}\;\;=\;\;2\pi G\rho_{1}\sin\omega t\,\mbox{$\frac{2}{k}$}\;\;=\;\;2\pi G\delta\rho\,\mbox{$\frac{2}{k}$}\;. (2) For an interferometer, the effect of this acceleration is to produce an effective strain h(t) on an arm of length L given by: \ddot{h}\;\;=\;\;\frac{\delta g}{L}\;\;=\;\;4\pi G\delta\rho\,\frac{v_{s}}{\omega L} The noise from the four test masses at the ends of the two arms will add in quadrature , increasing this by a factor between \sqrt{3} and 2, depending on correlations between the noise in the two masses at the corner. Pessimistically, we assume a factor of 2. For a gravity gradiometer sensor, the measured gravity gradient is g^{\prime}=kg , or: \delta g^{\prime}\;\;=\;\;4\pi G\delta\rho In either case, the contribution to the gravitational wave signal h comes by taking two time