The Electroweak Sphaleron Revisited: I. Static Solutions, Energy Barrier, and Unstable Modes
Konstantin T. Matchev, Sarunas Verner · 2025
Read The Electroweak Sphaleron Revisited: I. Static Solutions, Energy Barrier, and Unstable Modes by Konstantin T. Matchev, Sarunas Verner (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-05607.txt.
Introduction
The electroweak sphaleron is a lumpy, unstable solution of the Standard Model's field equations. It marks the top of the energy barrier between vacuum states that differ in topology, so its height governs how often baryon number can change. Matchev and Verner redo the classic analysis with today's measured values. They use the true Higgs mass of 125.1 GeV rather than the old shortcut that set it equal to the W boson mass.
They derive the full field equations without fixing a gauge, then solve them with high numerical precision. The barrier comes out near 9.1 TeV. They also trace the lowest-energy path from the vacuum up to the sphaleron and compute its single unstable mode, giving fits for its shape. Using the real Higgs mass shifts that mode's frequency, which feeds into rates of baryon number violation in the early universe and in collider signatures.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Konstantin T. Matchev, Sarunas Verner |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-05607
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Electroweak Sphaleron Revisited: I. Static Solutions, Energy Barrier, and Unstable Modes Konstantin T. Matchev, Sarunas Verner Abstract The electroweak sphaleron is a static, unstable solution of the Standard Model classical field equations, representing the energy barrier between topologically distinct vacua. In this work, we present a comprehensive updated analysis of the sphaleron using current Standard Model parameters with the physical Higgs boson mass of m H = 125.1 m_{H}=125.1 GeV and m W = 80.4 m_{W}=80.4 GeV, rather than the m H = m W m_{H}=m_{W} approximation common in earlier studies. The study includes: (i) a complete derivation of the S U ( 2 ) × U ( 1 ) SU(2)\times U(1) electroweak Lagrangian and field equations without gauge fixing constraints, (ii) high-precision numerical solutions for the static sphaleron configuration yielding a sphaleron energy E sph ≃ 9.1 E_{\rm{sph}}\simeq 9.1 TeV, (iii) an analysis of the minimum energy path in field space connecting the sphaleron to the vacuum (a 1D “potential barrier” as a function of Chern–Simons number), and (iv) calculation of the sphaleron single unstable mode with negative eigenvalue ω − 2 = − 2.7 m W 2 \omega^{2}_{-}=-2.7m^{2}_{W} , providing analytical fits for its eigenfunction. We find that using the measured Higgs mass modifies the unstable mode frequency, with important implications for baryon number violation rates in both early universe cosmology and potential high-energy collider signatures. These results provide essential input for accurate lattice simulations of sphaleron transitions and precision calculations of baryon number violation processes. I Introduction Nonperturbative electroweak processes can violate baryon ( B ) and lepton ( L ) number through the chiral anomaly Adler 1969 ; Bell and Jackiw 1969 . This was first demonstrated by ’t Hooft ’t Hooft 1976a ; ’t Hooft 1976b , who showed that instanton solutions of the SU(2) gauge theory induce processes that change B and L . At zero temperature such processes are exponentially suppressed by a factor of \exp(-4\pi/\alpha_{W})\sim 10^{-161} , but Kuzmin, Rubakov, and Shaposhnikov pointed out that at high temperatures in the early Universe these baryon-number violating processes would occur at an unsuppressed rate Kuzmin et al. 1985 . These transitions are instead governed by the so-called sphaleron: a static, unstable saddle-point configuration of the classical field equations that sits at the top of the energy barrier separating vacua of different Chern-Simons (CS) number. The electroweak sphaleron thus plays a pivotal role as the critical configuration mediating anomalous B+L violation in the Standard Model (SM) at high temperatures. The seminal work of Klinkhamer and Manton Klinkhamer and Manton 1984 identified this static saddle-point solution to the classical field equations of the Weinberg-Salam model in the limit where the weak mixing angle \theta_{W} vanishes. This limiting case offers significant simplification: the U(1)_{\rm Y} hypercharge gauge field completely decouples, reducing the theory to an SU(2)_{\rm W} gauge theory coupled to a scalar Higgs doublet. Klinkhamer and Manton showed that the energy functional varies smoothly with \theta_{W} , such that finite but small values of the mixing angle contribute only perturbative corrections to the sphaleron configuration. The electroweak vacuum is topologically degenerate: configurations can be characterized by an integer Chern–Simons number N_{\rm CS} , and sphalerons correspond to configurations with half-integer values N_{\rm CS}=n+1/2 (where n is an integer) Manton and Sutcliffe 2004 . The sphaleron with N_{\rm CS}=1/2 is positioned at the peak of the energy barrier separating the vacua with N_{\rm CS}=0 and N_{\rm CS}=1 . More recently, it has been argued that sphaleron-like processes may also occur in high-energy collisions if sufficient energy is concentrated into the electroweak gauge and Higgs sectors. The possibility of sphaleron-mediated baryon and lepton number violation at high-energy colliders has been explored in Gibbs et al. 1995 ; Ringwald 2003 ; Bezrukov et al. 2003a ; Bezrukov et al. 2003b ; Tye and Wong 2015 . In particular, Tye and Wong proposed a Bloch-wave picture in which the periodicity of the CS number leads to band structures in the transition probability, suggesting that above a certain energy threshold ( E\gtrsim E_{\rm sph} ), baryon number violation could proceed unsuppressed Tye and Wong 2015 . Subsequent work extended this framework to incorporate realistic parton distributions and collider observables, providing detailed cross-section estimates for sphaleron-induced transitions at the LHC and future colliders Ellis et al. 2016 ; Ellis and Sakurai 2016 . These developments have renewed interest in understanding the precise structure, energy, and instability properties of the sphaleron, particularly in light of the precisely measured Higgs boson mass. Despite their theoretical significance, the quantitative characterization of the sphalerons has seen surprisingly few updates since the late 1980s. Most early works preceded the discovery of the Higgs boson and often assumed an approximate mass degeneracy m_{H}=m_{W} for simplicity. Given that the Higgs mass is now known to be m_{H}\simeq 125.1 GeV (significantly larger than m_{W}\simeq 80.4 GeV) Navas et al. 2024 , it is important to revisit the sphaleron with physically accurate SM parameters. Furthermore, the CMS collaboration has recently performed dedicated searches for anomalous multi-fermion events consistent with sphaleron-induced \Delta N_{\rm CS}=\pm 1 transitions Sirunyan et al. 2018 , making precision calculations of sphaleron properties directly relevant to current experimental efforts. If the Higgs were significantly heavier than its measured value, the sphaleron energy would increase and the static solution would deform, potentially altering the baryon number violation rate. However, the measured 125 GeV Higgs ensures we are in the regime where the original sphaleron solution (symmetric under the full SU(2) custodial symmetry) remains valid and dominant, though with quantitatively different properties than assumed in earlier works. In this paper, we present an updated and comprehensive analysis of the electroweak sphaleron. We derive the full electroweak Lagrangian and classical field equations in their general form, without fixing a gauge or making the SU(2) spherical ansatz Ratra and Yaffe 1988 ; Akiba et al. 1988 . This provides a clear starting point and highlights all contributions (gauge, Higgs, and interactions) prior to fixing the gauge. Using a spherically symmetric SU(2) ansatz (justified by the small mixing angle approximation and consistent with lattice studies), we obtain detailed numerical solutions for the sphaleron profile functions with current values of the Higgs and W-boson masses. From this, we compute the sphaleron energy E_{\rm sph}\simeq 9.1 TeV, in agreement with Tye and Wong 2015 . We determine the static minimum-energy path in configuration space connecting the sphaleron to the vacuum. This one-dimensional “potential barrier” allows us to interpret the sphaleron as the peak of a potential V(N_{\rm CS}) , updating the classic barrier profiles of Akiba, Kikuchi, and Yanagida Akiba et al. 1988 . We then perform a linear stability analysis around the sphaleron, confirming a single negative eigenvalue \omega^{2}_{-}=-2.7m^{2}_{W} in the small-fluctuation spectrum. The corresponding eigenfunction is computed with analytical fits for its radial profile. Physically, this unstable mode corresponds to motion along the N_{\rm CS} direction: perturbing the sphaleron in this mode causes it to “decay” toward one of the vacua. The magnitude of the negative eigenvalue directly impacts the prefactor for the sphaleron transition rate in thermal environments, making this result particularly important for early Universe cosmology. More crucially, sphaleron transitions in the early Universe play a