Summation formulas for Hurwitz class numbers and other mock modular coefficients

Olivia Beckwith, Nikolaos Diamantis, Rajat Gupta, Larry Rolen, Kalani Thalagoda · 2025

Read Summation formulas for Hurwitz class numbers and other mock modular coefficients by Olivia Beckwith, Nikolaos Diamantis, Rajat Gupta, Larry Rolen, Kalani Thalagoda (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-05574.txt.

Introduction

Olivia Beckwith and co-authors prove a summation formula for coefficients of mock modular forms in a 2025 mathematics paper. Mock modular forms are a modern extension of classic modular forms, with coefficients that encode deep counting data. One key family, Hurwitz class numbers, counts classes of quadratic forms.

Their formula gives weighted sums of the first stretch of coefficients in closed form. It adapts a classic identity for well-behaved series to the mock setting, using special L-functions built for the purpose. Applied cases include class numbers and coefficients of certain Eisenstein series. Those coefficients in turn equal special values of L-functions. Number theorists get a tool for exact sums where only estimates existed before.

Catalog record

CREATOROlivia Beckwith, Nikolaos Diamantis, Rajat Gupta, Larry Rolen, Kalani Thalagoda
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-05574

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Summation formulas for Hurwitz class numbers and other mock modular coefficients Olivia Beckwith, Nikolaos Diamantis, Rajat Gupta, Larry Rolen, Kalani Thalagoda Abstract . We prove a formula for weighted sums of the first n n coefficients of mock modular forms of moderate growth and apply it to Hurwitz class numbers and coefficients of negative half integral weight Eisenstein series, which take the form of certain quadratic Dirichlet L L -values. Our formula is a mock modular version of a Bessel-sum identity proved by Chandrasekharan and Narasimhan for Dirichlet series satisfying a functional equation. Our proof utilizes L L -functions for mock modular Eisenstein series defined by Shankadhar and Singh. 1. Introduction In this paper, we develop a new theory of summation formulas for a class of distinguished mock modular forms. To do so, we use ideas inspired by insights from an old paper of Chandrasekharan and Narasimhan [ CN61 ] and combine them with the modern toolkit of harmonic Maass forms. We will describe the general framework in Section 1.2 . Before this, we begin by describing two key applications of the general results which formed the primary motivation for writing this paper. 1.1. Motivating Example: Class Numbers Class numbers of imaginary quadratic fields have long been of central interest in number theory. First studied by Gauss through the lens of binary quadratic forms under the action of \mathrm{SL}_{2}(\mathbb{Z}) , the class number h(-D) quantifies the failure of the rings of integers in \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-D}) to have unique factorization. Gauss conjectured that h(-D)\rightarrow\infty as D\rightarrow\infty . Gauss’s conjecture was proven in general by Heilbronn [ Hei34 ] , which Watkins used to compute exact lists of discriminants with class numbers up to 100 [ Wat04 ] . As a sequence, the class numbers h(D) and variations of them, such as the Hurwitz class numbers H(n) (Sect. 6.1 ) have many interesting arithmetic and analytic properties. For example, they satisfy many beautiful recurrence formulas such as that of Hurwitz and Kronecker: \sum_{r\in\mathbb{Z}}H(4n-r^{2})+\lambda_{1}(n)=2\sigma_{1}(n). (1.1) Here \lambda_{1}(n):=\sum_{d|n}\min(d,n/d) , and \sigma_{k}(n):=\sum_{d|n}d^{k} . A natural question, of central interest in analytic number theory, is to ask for good bounds on class numbers. That is, how precise can one make Heilbronn’s theorem? In [ Sie35 ] , Siegel gave a celebrated first answer to this question by proving the ineffective bound h(-D)\geq c(\varepsilon)D^{\frac{1}{2}-\varepsilon} (for D>0 sufficiently large). On the other hand, Goldfeld, Gross, and Zagier [ Gol85 ] proved the effective bound: h(-D)>\frac{1}{7000}\left(\log D\right)\prod_{\begin{subarray}{c}p\mid D\\ p\neq D\end{subarray}}\left(1-\frac{[2\sqrt{p}]}{p+1}\right). As one can see, there is a large gap between what is asymptotically true and what can be proven effectively. Thus, as is typical in analytic number theory, many papers have studied asymptotics of sums and moments of class numbers. For example, Wolke [ Wol72 ] proved that for all \alpha,\varepsilon>0, there is a constant c(\alpha) such that \sum_{n\leq X}h(-n)^{\alpha}=c(\alpha)X^{1+\frac{\alpha}{2}}+O_{\alpha}(X^{\frac{3}{4}+\frac{\alpha}{2}+\varepsilon}). Another important recent result is due to Walker [ Wal24 ] , who proved that \sum_{n\leq X}H(n)H(n+\ell)=\frac{\pi^{2}X^{2}}{252\zeta(3)}\left(2\sigma_{-2}(\ell/4)-\sigma_{-2}(\ell/2)+\sigma_{-2}(\ell_{o})\right)+O\left(X^{\frac{5}{3}+\varepsilon}+X^{1+\varepsilon}\ell\right), for any \varepsilon>0 \ell\in\mathbb{N} , and where \ell_{o} denotes the odd part of \ell . To give one more example, Ono, Saad, and Saikia [ OSS23 ] used formulas and asymptotic for moments of the form \sum_{s}H\left(\frac{n-4s^{2}}{4}\right)s^{2m} for non-negative integers m to study the distribution of values of Gaussian hypergeometric functions. This paper proves new analytic estimates for sums of class numbers by studying them from a mock modular standpoint. A hint of the modularity properties of H(n) is provided by ( 1.1 ); the right-hand side is essentially the n -th Fourier coefficient of the weight 2 (quasi)modular Eisenstein series E_{2}(\tau) while, in the left-hand side, we recognize a convolution of the generating function \mathcal{H}^{+}(\tau):=\sum_{D\geq 0}H(D) with the weight 1/2 Jacobi theta function \vartheta(\tau):=\sum_{n\in\mathbb{Z}}q^{n^{2}} . However, the modular objects involved are more complicated than classical holomorphic modular forms: 50 years ago, Zagier [ Zag75 ] proved that \mathcal{H}^{+}(\tau) can be “completed” by adding a non-holomorphic integral of \vartheta(\tau) to a function which transforms as a weight 3/2 modular form. In modern language, the Hurwitz class number generating function is a mock modular form , and it can be completed to give a harmonic Maass form (see Sect. 3 ). Here, we exploit this interpretation to study sums of coefficients of distinguished mock modular forms such as \mathcal{H}^{+}(\tau) . In particular, our main applications to class numbers can be found below in Theorems 6.3 and 6.4 . For example, Theorem 6.4 states the following. Theorem . Let H(n) denote the Hurwitz class number. For \rho>1 and \epsilon>0 , we have \displaystyle\frac{1}{\Gamma(\rho+1)}\sum_{n\leq x}H(n)(x-n)^{\rho}=\frac{\pi^{\frac{3}{2}}x^{\rho+\frac{3}{2}}}{24\Gamma\left(\rho+\frac{5}{2}\right)}+O(x^{\rho+1+\epsilon}). (1.2) This theorem corresponds to the case of weight 3/2 , and, in Section 6.2 , we prove its counterpart for positive half-integral weights (Theorem 6.7 ). Instead of Hurwitz class numbers, this involves explicit products of special vales of Dirichlet L -functions, which can be thought of as versions of the generalized Hurwitz class numbers (cf. [ BM24 ] , [ Mon25 ] ). In the next section, we will give an overview of the more general version of our results, and of the context within the theory of mock modular forms. 1.2. Summation formulas for mock modular forms The purpose of this paper is to prove a new class of “summation formulas,” from which the last theorem follows. Summation formulas are now essential tools in analytic number theory (see [ MS04 ] for a beautiful survey of their history and connection to modularity). An early example of such a formula is Voronoi’s enhancement of Dirichlet’s estimate for the number of divisors d(n):=\sigma_{0}(n) with the inclusion of test functions f(x) : \sum_{a\leq n\leq b}d(n)f(n)=\int_{a}^{b}f(x)(\log x+2\gamma)dx+\sum_{n\geq 1}d(n)\int_{a}^{b}f(x)\left(4K_{0}(4\pi\sqrt{nx})-2\pi Y_{0}(4\pi\sqrt{nx})\right)dx. (1.3) Here, \gamma is the Euler-Mascheroni constant, Y_{0} and K_{0} are the standard Bessel functions and the summation on the left-hand side is understood to be an average of the left and right-handed limits at points where f(n) is discontinuous. The added flexibility allowed by the test functions in this summation formula leads to power savings over Dirichlet’s estimate. Since then, summation formulas have been the focus of intense research from a variety of viewpoints one of the most important of which is based on the language of modular forms. However, as yet, they have not played a significant role in the theory of mock modular forms and harmonic Maass forms, and, here, we aim to rectify this. The systematic theory of mock modular forms was initiated by Zwegers [ Zwe02 ] , who solved an 80-year-old mystery about the modularity of Ramanujan’s mock theta functions. Important milestones in the development of the subject included Bruinier–Funke’s general theory of harmonic Maass forms [ BF04 ] , Bringmann–Ono’s application of the theory for the proof of the Andrews–-Dragonette conjecture [ BO06 ] , Bruinier–Ono’s applications to the vanishing of central L -values and L -derivatives of rational elliptic curves [ BO10 ] , Duke–Imamoğlu–Tóth’s deep connections to real quadratic class numbers [ DIT11 ] etc. Although these forms have many of the features of classical holomorphic and Maass wave forms such as a robust theory of differential and Hecke operators, some of the key features of classical modular forms were missing until recently. This included a systematic theory of L -series, which was significant because in the classical setting such L -series underlie most

Read the complete text