Qualia & Natural Selection
Ryan Williams · 2025
Read Qualia & Natural Selection by Ryan Williams (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-05480.txt.
Introduction
Ryan Williams asks what natural selection can and cannot shape about conscious experience. Qualia, the felt qualities of experience such as the redness of red, may or may not march in step with the physical structures that carry them. His 2025 paper builds information measures for how tightly structure and quality determine each other, a fidelity between the two domains.
Those fidelity measures are then fed into the Price equation, the bookkeeping identity of evolutionary change. The result is a set of formal bounds: conditions under which selection acting on structure can reliably move qualities, and limits on that transmission. Williams also examines how higher-order structures pass between the domains. A companion paper places the results in wider philosophical context. The work gives consciousness theories a set of hard constraints to answer to, rather than another verbal position.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ryan Williams |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-05480
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Qualia & Natural Selection Ryan Williams Abstract This paper explores foundational questions about the relationship of qualia to natural selection. The primary result is a derivation of specific formal conditions under which structural systems subject to natural selection can convey consistent effects in an associated qualitative domain, placing theoretical and empirical constraints on theories of consciousness. In order to achieve this result, information-theoretic measures are developed to quantify the mutual determinability between structure and quality, quantifying fidelity between the two domains. The fidelities represented by that space are then incorporated into the Price Equation to yield key bounds on the transmission of selective effects between domains. Finally, transmission of higher-order structures between domains is explored. Placement within a broader philosophical context can be found in the companion paper Structure & Quality . 1 1 1 Williams, 2025 One-Page Summary: Qualia & Natural Selection Formal Constraints on the Evolution of Consciousness Ryan Williams [email protected] Overview. This paper establishes new quantitative methods for investigating the evolution of qualia. Using information-theoretic measures and the Price Equation, it derives a novel criterion—called the Qualitative Selection Limit (QSL)—for evaluating whether natural selection on a physical system may be effectively transmitted into a qualitative domain. Setup. We define a mapping \phi\mathrel{\mathop{\ordinarycolon}}S\rightarrow Q , from structure S to qualitative space Q , with a fidelity measure \hat{s}=\eta_{q\mid s}=\sqrt{\frac{\mathrm{Var}(\mathbb{E}[\phi(s)])}{\mathrm{Var}(q)}.} This fidelity expresses how determinable qualitative traits are from knowledge of structural traits. Price Equation for Qualia. The Price Equation, applied to qualia can be written as: \Delta\bar{q}=\mathrm{Cov}(w_{i},q_{i})+\mathbb{E}[w_{i}\Delta q_{i}]. By decomposing q=\bar{\phi}(s)+\epsilon , with \bar{\phi}(s) representing the portion of q that can be determined via correlation with s , we show that: |\rho_{w,q}|\leq\hat{s}\cdot|\rho_{w,s}|, where \rho is a the Pearson correlation coefficient. In other words, selective pressures on q are bounded by its fidelity to the domain of selection. Qualitative Selection Limit (QSL). Taking into account other transmission effects from the Price Equation, selection becomes ineffective in the qualitative domain when: \frac{\mathrm{mutation}}{\mathrm{selection}}\gg\mathrm{fidelity}\quad\text{ i.e. }\quad\left|\frac{\mathbb{E}[w_{i}\Delta q_{i}]}{\sqrt{\mathrm{Var}(w_{i})\mathrm{Var}(q_{i})}}\right|\gg\hat{s}. This yields a natural threshold: low-fidelity mappings prevent selection from shaping qualitative traits. Simulation Results. Experiments confirm QSL behavior across generations: low-fidelity systems show divergence between s and q , even under selection. High noise in \phi (i.e. \hat{s}\approx 0 ) causes drift in quality q despite convergence between the structure s and fitness w . Natural Selection Overwhelmed By Mutation Exceeds QSL Rebound Selection Blue = Structural System Red = Qualitative System Yellow = Fitness Implications. QSL imposes theoretical and empirical constraints on viable structure–quality mappings in any theory of consciousness compatible with natural selection. The framework generalizes to any trait pairs mediated by imperfect mappings; the results are not limited to qualia. Placement within a broader philosophical context can be found in the companion paper Structure & Quality . It remains an open question what role our qualitative experience plays in our own function as organisms, and by extension, what role those qualia might play in the principles of self-organization—including natural selection— that gave and give rise to sentient beings. 2 2 2 Chalmers, 1995 , Hoffman, 2015 The essential difficulty is this: Even if we take it as given that the world is somehow possessed of an essentially qualitative character, why should that qualitative character manifest in a way that is functionally relevant for higher organisms? 3 3 3 Lacalli, 2021 , Lacalli, 2024 Even if we assume it to be a rather indirect relationship, it is hard to doubt that our perceptions recapitulate some analogous structure within the world. If we further consider the apparent role that our planning, deliberations, and desires have on our own behavior, we find ourselves situated in a place where qualitative aspects of our experience both cause and are caused by (in some broad sense of the notion “cause”) structural features of the world. This situation demands an explanation. We could easily imagine a world which was essentially qualitative in character, but in which the structure of its qualities bore no relation to the specific concerns of higher organisms—enormous orchestras of the stuff of the world, each organized to serve the function of its own autopoiesis. In this easily-imaginable scenario, every electron, quark, or other quantum of activity might be the manifestation of some qualitative property (the color red or the smell of coffee). But we would find no coherence between these atoms of quality, only a radio static of incoherent sensations, appearing and then gone again as quickly as they came. No permanence, no coherence, no function. This paper explores fundamental questions related to this situation: 1. Can we quantify relationships between structure and quality? 2. Do any of these relationships have the property that selection on a purely structural basis would produce a bias towards certain qualitative states? 3. How can higher-order structures convey from the structural domain into the qualitative domain and vice versa? Background In this first section, we will provide some basic philosophical background about what we mean by the terms structure and quality . Further discussion can be found in the companion article Structure & Quality . What Are Structure & Quality? We will use the term structure , largely interchangeably with the terms functional , relational , and quantitative . Collectively these all refer to properties that have to do with the arrangement, measure, or relation of things, but disregard their intrinsic nature. For instance, Newton’s equations tell us approximately how matter will move under appropriate macroscopic circumstances. The movements, measurements, distances, speeds, etc. which can be characterized by abstract mathematical or computational devices will fall under this structural category. Qualitative properties, on the other hand, have some ineffable factor, which can only become manifest in things which exhibit those qualitative properties in their own existence. To us, these are largely known as sensations and are sometimes referred to as qualia. These are characteristics like the experienced scent of freshly baked bread or the greenness of a tree. For the purposes of this paper, we will suppose that there is no way that one can derive qualitative properties by principle from structural properties alone. Instead we assume that we can only specify the relationships between structure and quality, without supposing any necessary connection between them. This is exactly the condition we find ourselves in regarding fundamental questions of ontology under normal circumstances of scientific investigation. We continually produce more powerful descriptions of nature, but none that hold out of necessity from first principles. So we have ever more exact specifications of how an electron behaves, but at bottom no indication why there need be electrons at all. (And if there were a reason discovered why there were electrons, that explanation would then be in need of an explanation of its own.) In the same way, we will give descriptions of structure, and we will give descriptions of how qualities correlate with that structure, and even descriptions of how the correlations might have correlations. But ultimately, we have taken it for granted that there are qualities there to describe—no further explanation feigned. We will aim to show persuasively that no such derivation is necessary to establish the functional connection to qualitative properties that is necessitated by natural selection and other principles of self-organization. Informatics We take any given model of