Cell size heterogeneity controls crystallization of the developing fruit fly wing
Kartik Chhajed, Franz S. Gruber, Raphaël Etournay, Natalie A. Dye, Frank Jülicher, Marko Popović · 2025
Read Cell size heterogeneity controls crystallization of the developing fruit fly wing by Kartik Chhajed, Franz S. Gruber, Raphaël Etournay, Natalie A. Dye, Frank Jülicher, Marko Popović (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-05437.txt.
Introduction
Kartik Chhajed, Franz Gruber, Raphaël Etournay, Natalie Dye, Frank Jülicher, and Marko Popović wrote a 2025 paper on how cells arrange themselves in the growing wing of a fruit fly. Young wing tissue starts with cells packed in a jumbled way. Later the packing turns neat and regular, like tiles. Past work credited the flow of the tissue for that change.
The team show that variety in cell size can drive the change on its own. Even when tissue flow was blocked, the packing still became regular. In their computer model of cell sheets, raising the spread of cell sizes pushed the tissue from jumbled to ordered. The finding adds a simple control knob for how living sheets organize, which matters for growth and wound repair.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kartik Chhajed, Franz S. Gruber, Raphaël Etournay, Natalie A. Dye, Frank Jülicher, Marko Popović |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 127 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-05437
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cell size heterogeneity controls crystallization of the developing fruit fly wing Kartik Chhajed, Franz S. Gruber, Raphaël Etournay, Natalie A. Dye, Frank Jülicher, Marko Popović Abstract A fundamental question in biology is to understand how patterns and shapes emerge from the collective interplay of large numbers of cells. Cells forming two-dimensional epithelial tissues behave as active materials that undergo remodeling and spontaneous shape changes. Focusing on the fly wing as a model system, we find that the cellular packing in the wing epithelium transitions from a disordered packing to an ordered, crystalline packing. While previous studies propose a role of tissue shear flow in establishing the ordered cell packing in the fly wing, we reveal a role of cell size heterogeneity. Indeed, we find that even if tissue shear have been inhibited, cell packings in the fruit fly wing epithelium transition from disordered to an ordered packing. We propose that the transition is controlled by the cell size heterogeneity, which is quantified by the cell size polydispersity. To explore the role of cell size polydispersity in controlling cellular packings, we implement polydispersity in a vertex model of epithelial tissues. Through numerical simulations of this model, we show that there is a critical value of cell size polydispersity above which cellular packings are disordered and below which they form a crystalline packing. By analyzing experimental data, we find that cell size polydispersity decreases during fly wing development. The observed dynamics of tissue crystallisation is consistent with the slow ordering kinetics we observe in the vertex model. Therefore, although tissue shear does not control the transition, it significantly enhances the rate of tissue-scale ordering by facilitating alignment of locally ordered crystallites. Our results identify cell size heterogeneity as a control parameter, in both the vertex model and the fruit fly wing epithelium, controlling the transition between ordered and disordered cellular packings. I Introduction During the development of an organism from a fertilized egg, complex pattern and structure morphologies emerge reliably from the collective interplay of many cells. Tissue morphology is characterized by cell shape and geometries of cell packings. In order to achieve specific functions, some of them have to be regularly organized. Examples are the regular hexagonal organization of insect ommatidia [ 17 ] , the regular arrangements of mechanosensitive hair cells in the mammalian and avian inner ear organ [ 66 , 61 ] , the periodic emergence of somites defining the segmented body plan of vertebrate animals [ 20 , 4 , 56 , 63 ] , and the oriented and regular arrangement of wing hairs in the fruit fly wing [ 31 , 15 , 14 , 11 ] . Regular structures typically involve biochemical patterning systems that guide cell behaviors and properties. Examples include digits formation [ 55 , 50 ] , hair follicles [ 65 ] and bird feathers [ 62 ] . However, it remains an open question how to achieve the regular patterning of cells, which are soft deformable objects of different sizes. In non-living systems, such questions have been addressed in the context of order-disorder transitions in particle arrangements. Equally sized particles tend to crystallize at a high density. Crystallization in three dimensions is a first order phase transition between a disordered liquid and a crystal with long range translational order. However, in two dimensions melting can occur through two separate transitions. First, a solid with a quasi-long ranged translational order transitions to a hexatic liquid crystal, losing the translation order through unbinding of dislocation defects, which still preserve orientational order. Second, the orientational order of the hexatic is lost through unbinding of disclination defects, and the system becomes an isotropic liquid. This scenario has been termed KTHNY theory of two-dimensional melting [ 41 , 53 , 75 ] . Crystallization is also affected by the polydispersity in particle sizes [ 54 , 27 , 64 ] , where increasing the heterogeneity of the particle sizes leads to a melting transition with an intermediate hexatic phase. Polydispersity has also been shown to induce non-trivial distributions of polygon side number in models of two-dimensional foams [ 29 , 23 , 22 , 43 ] . Crystallization has also been discussed in the context of two-dimensional epithelial tissues. Vertex models can capture the geometry and mechanics of cellular packings in epithelia, describing cells as soft polygons tiling a plane [ 36 , 37 , 35 , 52 , 10 , 57 , 26 , 38 , 33 , 34 , 68 , 45 , 72 , 12 , 28 , 5 , 18 , 42 ] . Such models can have a hexagonal lattice as a ground state when cells are of uniform size. These models can also capture non-equilbrium conditions, such as active noise and active cellular processes, that exist in biological tissues. Order-disorder transitions have been described as a function of a preferred cell shape parameter [ 26 , 68 , 5 ] , of a temperature parameter [ 44 , 21 ] , of active noise magnitude [ 6 , 58 , 2 , 3 ] , of cell division frequency [ 71 , 13 ] , and as a result of jamming of cell nuclei [ 51 , 40 ] . However, in a growing tissue, where cells divide and grow over time, the assumption of uniform cell sizes is not fulfilled, which can affect the cellular packing [ 7 ] . The role of cell size heterogenetiy in the organization of epithelial tissues is still not understood. During pupal development of the fruit fly D. melanogaster , cellular packing in the wing tissue has been reported to become increasingly hexagonal [ 15 , 14 , 11 ] . It has been suggested that large scale tissue ordering emerges due to tissue shear flows [ 69 ] , which have been quantified and related to orientational order of cell polarity [ 1 , 47 , 25 ] . In this work, we first quantify the structural order of cellular packing in the emerging fly wing during pupal development. We find that both local and tissue scale order appear and increase over time, and we discuss mechanical and genetic perturbations of the tissue that can obstruct ordering. This motivates a numerical study of cellular packing in epithelia, described by a vertex model that takes into account both mechanical noise and cell size polydispersity and predicts a phase diagram of solid and liquid phases. The cellular packing in the fly wing tissue does not reach a steady state. Therefore, we also study transient ordering kinetics in the vertex model to interpret the experimental observations. Finally, we quantify cell size polydispersity in fly wing and find a reduction of cell size polydispersity over time. Based on analysis of our model simulations, we conclude that the reduction of polydispersity controls the crystallization in the pupal fly wing. II Cellular packing of the fly wing crystallizes during pupal development The developing wing of the fruit fly D. melanogaster was previously recorded using large-scale time-lapse video microscopy of fluorescently labeled E-cadherin molecules that reveal the outlines of individual cells. All visible cell outlines were segmented and their geometric centers were recorded. Furthermore, the temporal resolution of around