Evolution of Mass, Charge, and Angular Momentum in Black Hole Evaporation: a Comparative Analysis

Christopher Ewasiuk, Stefano Profumo · 2025

Read Evolution of Mass, Charge, and Angular Momentum in Black Hole Evaporation: a Comparative Analysis by Christopher Ewasiuk, Stefano Profumo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04812.txt.

Introduction

Christopher Ewasiuk and Stefano Profumo compare how black holes evaporate in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. Black holes slowly lose mass by radiation, and spinning or charged ones also shed spin and charge. The team computes detailed emission factors for the three classic black hole types.

They track how mass, charge, and spin evolve relative to each other during evaporation. Adding particle types beyond the known set can change the hierarchy, and can even let effective charge grow for a time. Pair creation in strong fields and spin-boosted emission also shape the process for charged, spinning holes. The authors say these effects must be counted in models of black hole lifetimes.

Catalog record

CREATORChristopher Ewasiuk, Stefano Profumo
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04812

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evolution of Mass, Charge, and Angular Momentum in Black Hole Evaporation: a Comparative Analysis Christopher Ewasiuk, Stefano Profumo Abstract We present a comprehensive comparative analysis of the evaporation dynamics of Schwarzschild, Kerr, and Reissner-Nordström black holes, focusing on the evolution of their mass, charge, and angular momentum, using detailed calculations of the corresponding Page factors. We investigate the evolution of black holes during the evaporation process, emphasizing how these quantities evolve relative to one another. Our study incorporates the effects of greybody factors, near-extremal conditions, and the introduction of additional particle species beyond the Standard Model. We demonstrate that the addition of particle degrees of freedom may significantly alter the evaporation hierarchy, potentially leading to scenarios in which the effective black hole charge increases during evaporation. Additionally, we examine the impact of Schwinger pair production and of super-radiance on charged, spinning black hole evaporation. These findings offer new insights into the complex interplay between different black hole parameters during evaporation and highlight the importance of considering additional particle species in the process. \DeclareGraphicsRule *mps* I Introduction Black hole evaporation, driven by Hawking radiation, has been a central topic of interest in theoretical physics since its theoretical discovery. When a black hole emits thermal radiation due to quantum effects near its event horizon, it loses mass, and, depending on its type and initial conditions, additional otherwise classically conserved quantities such as angular momentum and charge [ 1 , 2 ] . Understanding the dynamics of mass, angular momentum, and charge loss during black hole evaporation has profound implications for quantum mechanics, thermodynamics, and the information paradox. The hierarchy by which black holes “dis-charge” mass, charge, and angular momentum is the topic of the present study. In this context, Page factors, introduced in Ref. [ 2 , 3 ] , provide a quantitative framework for describing the rates of energy, angular momentum, and charge loss due to Hawking radiation. These factors have been crucial in analyzing the distinct evaporation dynamics of different black hole types, including Schwarzschild, Kerr, and Reissner-Nordström (RN) black holes, under the semi-classical approximation. While the semi-classical framework assumes a fixed background metric with quantum mechanical evolution of matter and radiation fields, it successfully describes the evaporation process of large-enough black holes, where back-reaction effects are negligible [ 1 ] . I-A Black Hole Types and Evaporation Mechanisms Black holes are classified based on their properties of mass ( M ), angular momentum ( J ), and charge ( Q ). The simplest case, the Schwarzschild black hole, is both non-rotating and uncharged. During its evaporation, only mass is lost through isotropic thermal radiation [ 2 ] . Kerr black holes, however, are rotating, and the presence of angular momentum introduces anisotropic emission due to frame-dragging effects, significantly affecting the evaporation dynamics. In contrast, RN black holes are charged but non-rotating, with charge loss occurring preferentially due to the emission of oppositely charged particles [ 3 ] . For Kerr black holes, typically angular momentum is lost much faster than mass through the emission of higher-spin particles, leading to a “spin-down” process toward a Schwarzschild-like state [ 2 , 4 , 5 ] . Similarly, in the case of RN black holes, charge is typically dissipated on much shorter timescales than mass, due to the strong, fast emission of charged particles when the latter are thermodynamically available (i.e. when their mass is around, or below, the hole’s temperature) [ 3 , 6 ] . Both systems, however, exhibit unique pathways of evolution before settling into nearly neutral, non-rotating configurations. Additionally, assumptions on the existence of degrees of freedom beyond the “Standard Model” (SM) of particle physics is crucial to the validity of the pattern described above. The evaporation process is further modified by greybody factors, which describe deviations from an ideal blackbody spectrum caused by the scattering of radiation in the curved black hole spacetime [ 7 , 8 ] . These factors play a significant role in determining the emission rates and partitioning of energy across particle types and modes. I-B Comparative Analysis of Evaporation Dynamics Although much progress has been made in studying the evaporation dynamics of Schwarzschild, Kerr, and RN black holes independently, a systematic comparative analysis using Page factors across these black hole types is relatively sparse. For instance, studies show that Schwarzschild black holes evaporate the slowest due to their isotropic Hawking radiation [ 2 , 9 ] . Kerr black holes lose angular momentum several times faster than mass and exhibit superradiance effects that enhance the emission of energy from their ergoregions [ 4 , 9 ] . RN black holes lose charge rapidly, which suppresses following radiation owing to the Coulomb potential barrier induced by charge [ 3 ] . Numerical and analytical results suggest that charged black holes with high charge-to-mass ratios ( Q/M ) exhibit phenomena such as Schwinger pair production and quantum charge fluctuations near their event horizons [ 8 , 6 ] . In extremal cases (e.g., Kerr or RN black holes near their physical limits), the surface gravity approaches zero, resulting in vanishing thermal emission under the semi-classical approximation, though quantum corrections modify this behavior [ 10 , 11 ] . As we discuss below, super-radiance – the accumulation of light bosons effectively orbiting, in a “gravitational atom” guise, the black hole – also leads to anomalously fast shedding of angular momentum for certain combinations of angular momentum and boson-black hole masses. Fig. 1: Comparison of the output of the BlackHawk code and our use of the Geometric Optics approximation for h(M,Q^{*}) and f(M,Q^{*}) . All panels show BHs with masses 10^{17} g and effective charge Q^{*}=0.9 I-C Motivation and Open Problems Despite the availability of detailed studies on the evaporation dynamics of specific black hole types, significant gaps remain in comprehensively understanding how mass, angular momentum, and charge evolve comparatively across Schwarzschild, Kerr, and RN black holes. Existing work typically focuses on individual evaporation characteristics or broader formulations of Hawking radiation but often lacks explicit integration of these findings into a unified framework for comparative analysis. Key questions include: • How do Page factors for energy, angular momentum, and charge loss differ quantitatively across Schwarzschild, Kerr, and RN black holes during evaporation? • What are the relative timescales for the loss of conserved quantities, and how do greybody factors influence these dynamics? • How do near-extremal conditions (e.g., high a/M or Q/M ) modify the evaporation process for rotating or charged black holes? • How does the presence of additional degrees of freedom to the standard model of particle physics changes the standard picture? • What other possible mechanisms can alter the relative loss rates of charge, angular momentum and mass? In what follows we quantitatively address all of the questions listed above. The structure of the remainder of this study is outlined below. The following section describes the Page factor evolution for light BHs. We outline the general procedure we follow to compute time evolved factors, considering both the spinning and charge evolution of these factors. We also include the effects of additional dark degrees of freedom on parameter dissipation. In Section IV we discuss the results of prior studies, and how the relative dissipation

Read the complete text