Ultra-Relativistic Freeze-Out During Reheating Preprint: UMN–TH–4422/25, FTPI–MINN–25/04

Stephen E. Henrich, Mathieu Gross, Yann Mambrini, Keith A. Olive · 2025

Read Ultra-Relativistic Freeze-Out During Reheating Preprint: UMN–TH–4422/25, FTPI–MINN–25/04 by Stephen E. Henrich, Mathieu Gross, Yann Mambrini, Keith A. Olive (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04703.txt.

Introduction

Stephen Henrich and co-authors chart a forgotten way dark matter could have frozen out in a 2025 cosmology paper. After inflation, the universe reheated gradually, and particle physics during that window behaves oddly; the standard menus are particles freezing out while slow, or trickling in while barely interacting.

Ultra-relativistic freeze-out sits between them: dark matter decouples while still hot, then cools enough by the time structures form to fit observations, and production can even continue afterward. The viable parameter space is enormous, spanning masses and reheating temperatures across more than a dozen orders of magnitude. The sweet spot for interaction strength lands between the classic regimes.

Catalog record

CREATORStephen E. Henrich, Mathieu Gross, Yann Mambrini, Keith A. Olive
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE92 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04703

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ultra-Relativistic Freeze-Out During Reheating Preprint: UMN–TH–4422/25, FTPI–MINN–25/04 Stephen E. Henrich, Mathieu Gross, Yann Mambrini, Keith A. Olive Abstract We perform a thorough investigation of (ultra)relativistic freeze-out (UFO) during reheating. While the standard WIMP (non-relativistic freeze-out) and FIMP (freeze-in) paradigms have been explored in detail during the reheating epoch, UFO has not been systematically studied, despite the fact that it is operative in a broad region of parameter space. Although dark matter (DM) is “hot” at the time of relativistic freeze-out, we show that it can easily undergo enough cooling by the time of structure formation to be compatible with Λ \Lambda CDM. Unlike standard WIMP-like freeze-out, there can be significant out-of-equilibrium DM production after UFO, similar to the freeze-in mechanism. However, unlike freeze-in, UFO can accommodate much stronger couplings. The UFO parameter space consistent with Ω χ ​ h 2 = 0.12 \Omega_{\chi}h^{2}=0.12 is quite large, with DM masses spanning about 13 orders of magnitude ( 10 − 7 ​ GeV ≲ m χ ≲ 10 6 10^{-7}\text{ GeV}\lesssim m_{\chi}\lesssim 10^{6} GeV), reheating temperatures spanning 17 orders of magnitude ( 10 − 2 ​ GeV ≲ T RH ≲ 10 15 ​ GeV 10^{-2}\text{ GeV}\lesssim T_{\rm RH}\lesssim 10^{15}\text{ GeV} ) and Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) effective interaction scales spanning 11 orders of magnitude ( 10 3 ​ GeV ≲ Λ ≲ 10 14 ​ GeV 10^{3}\text{ GeV}\lesssim\Lambda\lesssim 10^{14}\text{ GeV} ). Interestingly, the most suitable range of couplings for UFO lies precisely between the typical couplings for WIMPs and FIMPs, rendering UFO quite attractive from the standpoint of detection. Particle physics models that are easily amenable to UFO include heavy vector or scalar portal interactions, along with nonrenormalizable effective interactions. Finally, we show there is a distinction between UV UFO and IR UFO, where the relic abundance for the former is sensitive to the freeze-out temperature, while the abundance for the latter is sensitive to the DM mass and the reheating temperature but insensitive to the freeze-out temperature. I Introduction The origin, identity and experimental signature of dark matter (DM) are all unknown. Of course the three are all inter-related, as the identity of DM would specify its interactions with the Standard Model (SM) and clarify its origin and strategy for detection. Concerning the origin of DM in the early universe, a distinction has been made made between the so-called freeze-out (FO) and freeze-in (FI) mechanisms. In the former, the interactions of the DM, although weak, are strong enough to bring it into equilibrium; and the “WIMP miracle” yields the correct relic abundance thanks to the Boltzmann suppression of the non-relativistic DM number density with respect to the radiation number density while “freezing out” from the thermal bath. In the latter case, DM production occurs continuously but the DM never equilibrates with SM particles, due to the expansion rate of the Universe dominating over the DM production rate. The “FIMP miracle” is due to the fact that the relic abundance is independent of the DM mass for long-range interactions. Most studies of the FI/FO production mechanisms have been made in the context of a radiation domination era Chu:2011be , where the evolution of the Universe and the Hubble rate H are dominated by the thermal (SM) plasma. However, radiation domination occurs only after a phase called reheating, which generates the radiation bath. Assuming an early period of exponential expansion driven by the inflaton, the period of reheating begins when inflation ends, though the energy density of the universe is still dominated by the inflaton until the inflaton decays and radiation domination begins. If DM is produced during the period of reheating, the naive separation between FI and FO becomes much more complex, due to the specific evolution of the temperature, and as a consequence the interaction cross sections, with time. For example, the naive relations H(T)\sim\sqrt{\rho}\propto T^{2} , or T\propto a^{-1} , where a represents the cosmological scale factor, do not hold during reheating, while the radiation bath is being created Scherrer:1984fd ; Giudice:2000ex ; gkmo1 ; gkmo2 . Thermalization and the FO mechanism become strongly dependent on the evolution of the field dominating the energy density of the Universe, and more specifically on the shape of the inflaton potential after inflation. Recently, the FIMP scenario has been analyzed in this context HMO ; Bernal:2025fdr . In addition, non-relativistic WIMP-like freeze-out during reheating has also been considered Silva-Malpartida:2024emu ; Mondal:2025awq . However, the possibility of ultra-relativistic freeze-out (UFO) has been unexplored so far. Depending on the strength of the interaction cross section between the DM and SM, any one or several of these mechanisms may be responsible for the observed DM abundance. In particular, we will demonstrate here that, for many cross sections and reheating scenarios, UFO constitutes a large intermediate regime that lies between non-relativistic FO and FI. One of the central issues concerning the FIMP mechanism is the hypothesis that dark matter is not coupled directly to the inflaton, so that its production is secondary, requiring the presence of a thermal bath. This can be justified only if the branching ratio for inflaton decays to DM is sufficiently small BR_{\phi}^{\chi}\ll 10^{-9}T_{\rm RH}/m_{\phi} , where T_{\rm RH} is the reheating temperature and m_{\phi} is the inflaton mass kmo . Note that the branching ratio cannot be set to arbitrarily small values if the DM is coupled to the SM and the SM is coupled to the inflaton as dark matter will be produced radiatively in inflaton decays or through Bremstrahlung processes Mambrini:2022uol . Thus, when considering a FI mechanism it is necessary to include a more in-depth study of the post-inflationary reheating phase. In clear distinction to the classical non-relativistic FO mechanism where all prior history of the dark matter is erased by entering into thermal equilibrium, this is not the case for FI where initial conditions (and interactions) are crucial. It is possible, for example (as we will show in this paper), that DM enters into thermal equilibrium during the reheating process and freezes-out relativistically before the end of the reheating. This can lead to results that differ significantly from the well-studied case of relativistic freeze-out during radiation domination, which occurs for instance when SM neutrinos freeze-out at temperatures of order 1 MeV. Though our work is not sensitive to the details of the model of inflation, we will assume that after the period of exponential expansion ends, the inflaton begins a period of oscillations about the minimum of its scalar potential which we parameterize as V(\phi)=\lambda M_{P}^{4}\left(\frac{\phi}{M_{P}}\right)^{k},\quad\phi\ll M_{P}\,. (1) This occurs for example, in the class of models known as T-models Kallosh:2013hoa with a potential given by V(\phi)\;=\;\lambda M_{P}^{4}\left|\sqrt{6}\tanh\left(\frac{\phi}{\sqrt{6}M_{P}}\right)\right|^{k}\,. (2) Of primary importance to us here, is the value of k which determines the equation of state parameter w\equiv P_{\phi}/\rho_{\phi}=(k-2)/(k+2) during reheating. Here, P_{\phi} and \rho_{\phi} are the pressure and energy density of the inflaton condensate oscillating about the minimum of the potential at \phi=0 . The overall scale of the potential, determined by \lambda , is fixed by the normalization of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy spectrum and depends on k gkmo1 . Note that for k>4 , the evolution of the inflaton is subject to the effects of fragmentation Lozanov:2016hid ; Garcia:2023dyf which cause

Read the complete text