QNM orthogonality relations for AdS black holes
Paolo Arnaudo, Javier Carballo, and Benjamin Withers · 2025
Read QNM orthogonality relations for AdS black holes by Paolo Arnaudo, Javier Carballo, and Benjamin Withers (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04696.txt.
Introduction
A black hole rings when struck, and its tones fade as they leak to the far edge of its curved space. Paolo Arnaudo, Javier Carballo, and Benjamin Withers ask when two such tones count as square in a 2025 study, for holes whose space cups in at the edge. Square pairs are the base that lets a ring be built tone by tone.
Their square rule starts from the plain pair sum, bent by a flip that turns right modes to left ones. The path of the sum runs on a bent line in the deep plane that skirts the tones' branch cuts. That same path ties two copies of the twin heat tale, and to the twin cone worm path.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paolo Arnaudo, Javier Carballo, and Benjamin Withers |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04696
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
QNM orthogonality relations for AdS black holes Paolo Arnaudo, Javier Carballo, and Benjamin Withers Abstract We present orthogonality relations for quasinormal modes of a wide class of asymptotically AdS black holes. The definition is obtained from a standard product, modified by a CPT operator and placed on a complex radial contour which avoids branch points of the modes. They are inspired by existing constructions for de Sitter and Kerr spacetimes. The CPT operator is needed to map right eigenfunctions of the Hamiltonian into left eigenfunctions. The radial contour connects two copies of the dual QFT on a thermal Schwinger-Keldysh contour, making contact with real-time holography and the double cone wormhole. 1 Introduction Quasinormal modes (QNMs) provide a universal characterisation of the decay of black holes towards equilibrium at asymptotically late times. This makes them an invaluable tool in the theoretical study and gravitational wave observations of dynamical black holes. Their decay is due to a dissipative linear-response process in which energy falls through \mathcal{H}^{+} or is radiated to \mathcal{I}^{+} . However, this dissipative process means that QNMs are not orthogonal to each other in any standard way. Despite this, orthogonality relations between de Sitter static patch QNMs have been constructed by applying suitable discrete symmetry operations to the Klein-Gordon product Jafferis:2013qia , building on Witten:2001kn ; Bousso:2001mw ; Ng:2012xp . Here the radial integral in the product avoids QNM singularities by appropriate i\epsilon insertions. See also Crawley:2021ivb ; Cotler:2023qwh for analogous constructions in celestial holography. More recently, a similar construction was presented for Kerr spacetimes, employing \mathcal{T}\varphi -reflections Green:2022htq with applications in Cannizzaro:2023jle . In this construction the approach begins with a radial integral which is divergent, and then regulated PhysRevA.49.3057 ; Ching:1995rt . Relatedly, in London:2023aeo ; London:2023idh appropriate integral weights for orthogonality products were identified. In Zhu:2023mzv orthogonality relations for discretised systems are also constructed. Figure 1: Left: The complex radial contour \Gamma used in our QNM orthogonality product. The contour avoids branch point singularities of QNMs and anti-QNMs on the horizon. Right: The contour \Gamma on the maximally extended spacetime, connecting two copies of the QFT through Euclidean time translation by half the thermal circle, \beta/2 . Here the red line illustrates a singular past horizon on side 1, corresponding to the branch point singularities of QNMs on that side, avoided by the i\epsilon insertions. In this work, inspired by the above examples, we construct new orthogonality relations for QNMs of a wide class of asymptotically AdS black holes. Our orthogonality relation similarly employs discrete symmetry transformations to modify an existing inner product, and are defined on a complex radial contour. The contour encircles the QNM branch points on the horizon and connects two AdS boundaries, see figure 1 . Such contours naturally arise in the context of real-time AdS/CFT Herzog:2002pc ; Skenderis:2008dh ; Skenderis:2008dg ; Son:2009vu ; deBoer:2018qqm ; Glorioso:2018mmw ; Jana:2020vyx . In the bulk they can be interpreted as a slice of the maximally extended black hole spacetime, with appropriate i\epsilon insertions that avoid QNM singularities on the horizon. In the holographic dual they connect two copies of the boundary QFT on a thermal Schwinger-Keldysh contour. This contour also appears in the context of the double cone wormhole Saad:2018bqo . Let us first illustrate our results in the simple case of a Klein-Gordon scalar \Phi of mass m_{\Phi}^{2}=\Delta(\Delta-2) on the non-rotating BTZ black hole Banados:1992wn , ds^{2}=\frac{1}{z^{2}}\left(-(1-z^{2})dt^{2}+\frac{1}{(1-z^{2})}dz^{2}+d\varphi^{2}\right), (1) with AdS boundary at z=0 and event horizon at z=1 . The Klein-Gordon product defined on the contour \Gamma is given by \braket{a,b}_{\text{KG}}=i\int_{0}^{2\pi}d\varphi\,\int_{\Gamma}dz\,\frac{1}{z(1-z^{2})}\,a^{*}\overleftrightarrow{\partial_{t}}b, (2) where a^{*}\overleftrightarrow{\partial_{t}}b\equiv a^{*}\partial_{t}b-(\partial_{t}a^{*})b . This is the integral of the discontinuity of the integrand due to branch points in the fields. Given the Hamiltonian \mathcal{H}=i\partial_{t} , under ( 2 ) one has the following standard orthogonality relation between its left and right eigenfunctions, u_{i} and v_{j} respectively, \braket{u_{i},v_{j}}_{\text{KG}}\propto\delta_{ij}, (3) where \mathcal{H}v_{i}=\omega_{i}v_{i} , and \mathcal{H}^{\dagger_{\text{KG}}}u_{i}=\omega^{*}_{i}u_{i} , where \mathcal{H}^{\dagger_{\text{KG}}} denotes the adjoint under ( 2 ), i.e. \braket{\mathcal{H}^{\dagger_{\text{KG}}}a,b}_{\text{KG}}=\braket{a,\mathcal{H}b}_{\text{KG}} . This follows from \omega_{j}\braket{u_{i},v_{j}}_{\text{KG}}=\braket{u_{i},\mathcal{H}v_{j}}_{\text{KG}}=\braket{\mathcal{H}^{\dagger_{\text{KG}}}u_{i},v_{j}}_{\text{KG}}=\omega_{i}\braket{u_{i},v_{j}}_{\text{KG}}, (4) so that if \omega_{i}\neq\omega_{j} then \braket{u_{i},v_{j}}_{\text{KG}}=0 . Our orthogonality relation is inherited from the standard relation ( 3 ) by providing a mapping between left and right eigenfunctions. The key point is that \mathcal{H}^{\dagger_{\text{KG}}}=\mathcal{H} , which can be shown as follows. By using the equation of motion and integration by parts on the contour \Gamma one obtains \braket{a,\mathcal{H}b}_{\text{KG}}=\braket{\mathcal{H}a,b}_{\text{KG}}+\int d\varphi\left[\frac{1-z^{2}}{z}\left(b\partial_{z}a^{*}-a^{*}\partial_{z}b\right)\right]_{z=0-i\epsilon}^{z=0+i\epsilon}, (5) thus for normalisable perturbations, that is, a,b\propto z^{\Delta} as z\to 0 with \Delta>1 , the boundary terms vanish. Since \mathcal{H}^{\dagger_{\text{KG}}}=\mathcal{H} , any right eigenfunction is also a left eigenfunction, so we can put right eigenfunctions in both slots, \langle v_{i},v_{j}\rangle_{\text{KG}} , and still take advantage of ( 3 ). However, unlike ( 3 ), the matrix \langle v_{i},v_{j}\rangle_{\text{KG}} is not diagonal. 1 1 1 The vanishing of the Klein-Gordon norms (i.e. the diagonal entries of \langle v_{i},v_{j}\rangle_{\text{KG}} ) is precisely what permits complex eigenvalues even though \mathcal{H}^{\dagger_{\text{KG}}}=\mathcal{H} . The problem with using the Klein-Gordon norm for QNMs was pointed out before Jafferis:2013qia . Diagonalising the Klein-Gordon product leads us to our main definition, used throughout this work, \braket{a,b}\equiv\braket{\mathcal{CPT}a,b}_{\text{KG}}, (6) where \mathcal{C} denotes complex conjugation, \mathcal{T} denotes t\to-t , and in this particular case of BTZ, \mathcal{P} denotes \varphi\to-\varphi . The role of \mathcal{CPT} is to map an eigenfunction of \mathcal{H} with eigenvalue \omega into an eigenfunction with eigenvalue \omega^{*} , and hence \braket{v_{i},v_{j}}=\braket{u_{i},v_{j}}_{\text{KG}}\propto\delta_{ij} , as desired. This property of \mathcal{CPT} can be seen from the separated form of eigenfunctions and commuting \mathcal{CPT} with the equation of motion. Finally, in section 3 , we show that the regular, normalisable eigenfunctions of \mathcal{H} on \Gamma are the QNMs and anti-QNMs, completing the proof that ( 6 ) provides the desired orthogonality relations among these modes. We can also compute ( 6 ) on pairs of eigenfunctions to explicitly demonstrate their orthogonality. The BTZ QNMs \Phi_{nm}^{\pm}(t,z,\varphi) are given in ( 49 ), while the anti-QNMs \widetilde{\Phi}_{nm}^{\pm}(t,z,\varphi) are given in ( 52 ), related by \mathcal{CPT}\Phi_{nm}^{\pm}=\widetilde{\Phi}_{nm}^{\pm} . They are labeled by an azimuthal quantum number m , a parity sector \pm , and an overtone number n . The computation presented in appendix A shows, \displaystyle\braket{\Phi_{nm}^{\pm},\Phi_{n^{\prime}m^{\prime}}^{\pm^{\prime}}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{(2\pi)^{2}i(-1)^{n-1}\,n!\,\Gamma\left(\Delta\right)}{\Gamma\left(\mp im-n\right)\,\Gamma\left(n\pm im+\Delta\right)\,\left(\Delta\right)_{n}\,\left(\Delta\pm im+2n\right)}\,\omega^{\pm}_{nm}\,\delta_{mm^{\prime}}\,\delta_{nn^{\prime}}\delta_{\pm\pm^{\prime}},\qquad\; (7) \displaystyle\braket{\widetilde{\Phi}_{nm}^{\pm},\widetilde{\Phi}_{n^{\prime}m^{\prime}}^{\pm^{\prime}}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{(2\pi)^{2}i(-1)^{n-1}\,n!\,\Gamma\left(\Delta\right)}{\Gamma\left(\pm im-n\right)\,\Gamma\left(n\mp im+\Delta\right)\,\left(\Delta\right)_{n}\,\left(\Delta\mp im+2n\right)}\,\widetilde{\omega}^{\pm}_{nm}\,\delta_{mm^{\prime}}\,\delta_{nn^{\prime}}\delta_{\pm\pm^{\prime}}, (8) \displaystyle\braket{\Phi_{nm}^{\pm},\widetilde{\Phi}_{n^{\prime}m^{\prime}}^{\pm^{\prime}}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 0, (9) where \omega^{\pm}_{nm} and \widetilde{\omega}^{\pm}_{nm} are the associated eigenfrequencies ( 51 ), ( 55 ). The result demonstrates orthogonality between all modes, in accordance with the above proof. 2 2 2 Note here the important caveat that the m=0 modes have zero norm. This can be understood a degeneration between the orthogonal \pm sectors at m=0 . The layout of the rest of the paper is as follows. In section 2 we extend the BTZ example presented above to a general class of AdS d+1 black hole spacetimes, with general metric functions required to obey only certain properties. In particular we prove orthogonality of the regular, normalisable eigenfunctions of \mathcal{H} on \Gamma for this class of spacetimes. In section 3 we prove that the regular, normalisable eigenfunctions of \mathcal{H} on \Gamma are, indeed, just the QNMs and anti-QNMs of these general black holes. In section 4 we turn to explicit numerical evaluation of ( 6 ) with QNMs and anti-QNMs in the slots for Schwarzschild-AdS 4 , confirming the result. We