On the Principle of Relativity of Inertia in both General and Entangled Relativities

2025

Read On the Principle of Relativity of Inertia in both General and Entangled Relativities (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04667.txt.

Introduction

Olivier Minazzoli writes in twenty twenty-five about the principle of relativity of inertia. He compares how that principle sits in two theories of gravity. One is general relativity, Einstein's well-known theory. The other is entangled relativity, a newer and leaner theory. The newer theory can recover both general relativity and standard quantum field theory in a set limit.

Entangled relativity also rules out spacetime with no matter in it at all. Minazzoli argues this makes the new theory a better fit for Einstein's own vision. He adds that its leaner form is a point in its favor under Occam's razor. Readers get a theory-level argument about what inertia should mean.

Catalog record

YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04667

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Principle of Relativity of Inertia in both General and Entangled Relativities E-mail: [email protected] Abstract Entangled Relativity is a novel theory of relativity that offers a more economical approach than General Relativity. It successfully recovers both General Relativity and standard quantum field theory within a specific (yet generic) limit. Furthermore, Entangled Relativity precludes the existence of spacetime devoid of the matter that permeates it. Consequently, I argue that Entangled Relativity is not only preferable from the standpoint of Occam’s razor, due to its economical nature, but it also aligns more closely with Einstein’s original vision for a satisfactory theory of relativity. \originalTeX † † authors: O. Minazzoli a,b, \from a Université Côte d’Azur, Observatoire de la Côte d’Azur, CNRS, Artemis, bd. de l’Observatoire, 06304, Nice, France. \from b Bureau des Affaires Spatiales, 2 rue du Gabian, 98000 Monaco. PACS: 01.65.+g; 04.50.Kd; 04.60.Gw 1 Introduction The principle of the relativity of inertia is one of the three foundational principles of Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity [ 1 ] . However, Einstein later acknowledged that General Relativity does not fully satisfy this principle [ 2 , 3 ] . This principle asserts that spacetime should be completely determined by matter, rather than being only partially influenced by it. Notably, it implies that spacetime cannot exist without the matter that generates it [ 1 , 4 ] . In other words, according to this principle, any theory allowing for the existence of classical vacuum solutions in spacetime should be considered invalid. Yet, General Relativity permits purely vacuum solutions, such as Minkowski, Schwarzschild, or Kerr spacetimes when the cosmological constant is set to zero, and de Sitter or Schwarzschild-de Sitter spacetimes when it is not. In this proceeding, after revisiting the issue within General Relativity, both in its historical context and in modern physics, I will present Entangled Relativity. I will explain why it aligns more closely with this principle and why it offers a more parsimonious formulation compared to General Relativity. 2 The relativity of inertia in General Relativity The principle of relativity of inertia, 1 1 1 First mentioned in [ 5 ] as ‘the hypothesis of the relativity of inertia’. which Einstein also named Mach’s principle in [ 1 ] , stems from the metaphysical assertion that motion can only be defined with respect to matter, rather than from space (or spacetime) itself, à la Newton . In other words, inertia is relative to surrounding matter fields, and not to an underlying absolute structure. As Norton writes, ‘‘The doctrine of the relativity of motion is attractive for its simplicity. According to it, the assertion that a body moves can mean nothing more than that it moves with respect to other bodies’’ [ 6 ] . The endeavor to satisfy this principle reflects Einstein’s engagement in a longstanding debate which, in some aspects, dates back to antiquity [ 7 ] , but gained prominence with Newton’s theory of gravitation. Newton proposed that dynamics should be defined with respect to an absolute space, which provides the framework for phenomena to occur. Conversely, Huygens and Leibniz argued that motion is relative between bodies, as opposed to being relative to an absolute structure. Mach revisited this debate, advocating for the relativity of motions, i.e., the relativity of inertia. Deeply influenced by Mach, 2 2 2 However, there is debate over whether Einstein fully grasped Mach’s philosophy and whether Mach and his pupil, Petzoldt, truly endorsed Einstein’s theory as genuinely Machian [ 8 , 9 ] . (From my perspective, what is most relevant is Einstein’s intuition, particularly during the period leading to General Relativity, rather than its alignment with the work of some contemporaries). Einstein thus proposed that a satisfactory theory of relativity should adhere to a principle of relativity of inertia. He writes: ‘‘The [ Entwurf ] theory sketched here overcomes an epistemological defect that attaches not only to the original theory of relativity, but also to Galilean mechanics, and that was especially stressed by E. Mach. It is obvious that one cannot ascribe an absolute meaning to the concept of acceleration of a material point, no more so than one can ascribe it to the concept of velocity. Acceleration can only be defined as relative acceleration of a point with respect to other bodies.’’ [ 10 ] . After finalizing the equations of General Relativity (including a cosmological constant), Einstein’s definition of the principle of the relativity of inertia is articulated in [ 1 ] as: ‘‘Mach’s principle. The G-field is completely determined by the masses of the bodies’, and Einstein completes further down in his manuscript by writing ‘‘With [this principle], according to the field equations of gravitation, there can be no G-field without matter. Obviously, [this principle] is closely connected to the spacetime structure of the world as a whole, because all masses in the universe will partake in the generation of the G-field’’. Although his understanding of what a principle of relativity of inertia could mean within the relativistic framework evolved with time [ 2 ] —with some confusion prior to 1915 between the principle of relativity ( covariance principle ) and the equivalence principle — the fundamental necessity for this principle, evidently, is that spacetime cannot exist without matter [ 2 ] . In Einstein’s own words: "[In] my opinion, the general theory of relativity is a satisfying system only if it shows that the physical qualities of space are completely determined by matter alone. Therefore, no g_{\mu\nu} -field must exist without matter that generates it.’’ [ 4 ] —see below for the context of this quote. Indeed, in a relativistic theory, inertia is defined by the spacetime metric. Therefore, if a relativistic theory permits vacuum spacetime solutions, it implies that inertia could, de facto, be defined without any matter field. This would therefore contradict Einstein’s original intention to relativize the motions of bodies in relation to each other, rather than with respect to an absolute spacetime structure. 2.1 The cosmological constant: While reading Einstein’s cosmological paper in isolation might lead one to conclude that he introduced the cosmological constant to enable a static universe, as is often suggested nowadays, placing the paper in the context of his other works reveals that Einstein’s true intent in adding a cosmological constant was to satisfy the relativity of inertia. In his cosmological paper, he asserts: ‘‘[In] a consistent theory of relativity there cannot be inertia relatively to ‘‘space’’ but only an inertia of masses relatively to one another’’ [ 11 ] . As Hoefer explains [ 2 ] , at that time, Einstein believed this requirement would impose two strong, albeit distinct, constraints on the theory and its acceptable solutions: 1. The universe should be finite and closed, to avoid boundary conditions without matter, thereby upholding Mach’s principle. This constraint serves as a criterion for selecting acceptable solutions among many that do not fulfill this requirement. 2. The theory should not permit solutions without matter. 3 3 3 Due to the page limit, I will not address the issue of vacuum solutions with singularities here. Unlike the first constraint, this is not about selecting potential solutions from a given theory, but a condition for the theory itself. The cosmological constant

Read the complete text