Experimental demonstration of a multi-particle collective measurement for optimal quantum state estimation
Arman Mansouri, Kyle M. Jordan, Raphael A. Abrahao, Jeff S. Lundeen · 2025
Read Experimental demonstration of a multi-particle collective measurement for optimal quantum state estimation by Arman Mansouri, Kyle M. Jordan, Raphael A. Abrahao, Jeff S. Lundeen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-04607.txt.
Introduction
Arman Mansouri and three co-authors test a joint measure on photon pairs in a 2025 paper. To read a quantum state's shape, the best plan may measure two parts at once, not one by one. A past design claimed that joint plan wins a state-guessing game outright, and this team built it in light.
Their rig joins two photons with a known clash effect, loss that bends by light's tilt, and plain turns. The joint plan matched or beat the best lone plan, and won more clearly once tool bias was counted. Full state reads also scaled near the best bound.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arman Mansouri, Kyle M. Jordan, Raphael A. Abrahao, Jeff S. Lundeen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-04607
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Experimental demonstration of a multi-particle collective measurement for optimal quantum state estimation Preprint: APS/123-QED Arman Mansouri, Kyle M. Jordan, Raphael A. Abrahao, Jeff S. Lundeen Abstract We experimentally demonstrate a two-particle collective measurement proposed as the optimal solution to a quantum state estimation game. Our results suggest that, in practice, the collective measurement strategy is at least as good as the best local approach, and it achieves a higher average fidelity when accounting for systematic errors. This photonic implementation uses a recently developed universal two-photon projective measurement based on Hong-Ou-Mandel interference, polarization-dependent loss, and unitary operations. We compare the performance to the case where the entangling component of the measurement is suppressed. We further apply the collective measurement to quantum state tomography, observing a near-optimal scaling of the infidelity with the total number of samples. Collective measurements probe many-body properties such as total spin or permutation symmetry rather than properties such as single-particle spin. They arise naturally in many-body systems, for instance in the study of ferromagnetism, where the macroscopic field is a collective effect of the many spins. Collective measurements are nonlocal in the sense that they project onto entangled states and, thus, they enable applications that are impossible within the paradigm of Local Operations and Classical Communication (LOCC). Probing collective properties provides optimal solutions to several parameter and state estimation problems in quantum information Holevo 1973 ; Massar and Popescu 1995 ; Vidal et al. 1999 ; Nagaoka 2005 ; Liang and Doherty 2006 ; Bagan et al. 2006 ; Tsang 2011 ; Muñoz et al. 2018 ; Wu et al. 2020 ; Conlon et al. 2023 ; Conlon et al. 2025 . However, the majority of implementations in state estimation and metrology have so far been focused on the use of local measurements, due to the practical challenges associated with the realization of collective measurements. Viable experimental methods for collective measurements will open up these optimal sensing and state estimation applications. An important and fundamental task in quantum information is quantum state tomography, which allows complete characterization of the state \rho of quantum systems through measurements on an identically prepared ensemble of size N_{\text{ens}} . This procedure involves the measurement of a set of observables sufficient for the complete determination of the density matrix, resulting in a state estimate \rho_{\text{est}} D’Ariano et al. 2003 . For a d -dimensional system, at least d^{2}-1 projection measurements are needed for a tomographic reconstruction. In practice, many samples need to be measured for each projection to reduce statistical uncertainty, meaning a large total number of samples are required for quantum state tomography. This poses a challenge for the efficient characterization of quantum systems. A common way to assess the efficiency of a state characterization scheme is to consider the scaling of the infidelity 1-F=1-\left[\text{Tr}\sqrt{\sqrt{\rho_{\text{est}}}\rho\sqrt{\rho_{\text{est}}}}\right]^{2} with the number of measured samples N_{\text{ens}} , which quantifies the error in the estimate \rho_{\text{est}} of the true state \rho . Tomographic scaling is important from a fundamental point of view, since it relates to how much information can be extracted. It is also significant when considering the practicality in experiments where the number of copies is limited. Through a calculation based on the quantum Fisher information matrix and the quantum Cramér-Rao bound, Gill and Massar showed that the optimal infidelity for the tomography of a pure one-qubit state scales as 1/N_{\text{ens}} Gill and Massar 2000 . Massar and Popescu discussed a related state estimation task, where N qubits polarized in \ket{\vec{n}} are provided in each round, and a single guess \ket{\vec{n}_g} of the polarization vector is made Massar and Popescu 1995 . We describe two experiments on state identification, starting with the game addressed by Massar and Popescu, and later applying the collective measurement to quantum state tomography. Optimal Massar and Popescu game — The optimal measurement for the Massar and Popescu game is defined as one that, on average, maximizes the fidelity \mathcal{F}(\ket{\vec{n}},\ket{\vec{n}_g})=\absolutevalue{\braket{\vec{n}}{\vec{n}_g}}^{2} . The procedure is repeated many times, with \ket{\vec{n}} given according to some prior distribution P(\vec{n}) , e.g., randomly and uniformly distributed over the Bloch sphere. The average fidelity \bar{\mathcal{F}} can thus be written as Massar and Popescu 1995 ; Gisin and Popescu 1999 : \displaystyle\bar{\mathcal{F}} \displaystyle=\int P(\vec{n})\ d\vec{n}\sum_{g}P(g|\vec{n})\mathcal{F}(\ket{\vec{n}},\ket{\vec{n}_g}) (1) \displaystyle=\int P(\vec{n})\ d\vec{n}\sum_{g}P(g|\vec{n})\left(\frac{1+\vec{n}\cdot\vec{n}_{g}}{2}\right), where \vec{n} is the Bloch vector of the unknown state \ket{\vec{n}} , \vec{n}_{g} is the Bloch vector associated with the guessed state, and P(g|\vec{n}) is the probability of guessing \vec{n}_{g} when the true direction is \vec{n} . Massar and Popescu found that when the different directions \vec{n} are randomly and uniformly distributed over the unit sphere, i.e., P(n) is uniform, the optimal measuring strategy is to perform a collective measurement on the ensemble of N qubits. This strategy maximizes the average fidelity to \bar{\mathcal{F}}^{\text{Coll}}_{\text{GenMP}}=(N+1)/(N+2) Massar and Popescu 1995 . For the case of N=2 , an optimal measuring strategy is to measure a nondegenerate operator whose eigenstates are the following superpositions of the singlet state \ket{S}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(\ket{01}-\ket{10}) and product tetrahedron states \ket{\uparrow_{n_i}\uparrow_{n_i}} : \displaystyle\ket{\text{MP}_1} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2}\ket{S}+\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\ket{\uparrow_{n_1}\uparrow_{n_1}} (2) \displaystyle\ket{\text{MP}_j} \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{2}\ket{S}+\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\ket{\uparrow_{n_j}\uparrow_{n_j}},\quad j=2,3,4. In the Bloch sphere, the states \ket{\uparrow_{n_i}} are located on the surface of the sphere at the vertices of a tetrahedron and can be chosen as: \displaystyle\ket*{\uparrow_{n_1}} \displaystyle=\ket{0}; (3) \displaystyle\ket*{\uparrow_{n_j}} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\ket{0}+\sqrt{\frac{2}{3}}e^{i\alpha_{j}}\ket{1},\qquad j=2,3,4, with \alpha_{2},\alpha_{3},\alpha_{4}=0,\ 2\pi/3,\ 4\pi/3 . Upon performing this collective measurement and obtaining the outcome i (corresponding to \ket{\text{MP}_i} ), the tetrahedron state \ket{\uparrow_{n_i}} is chosen as the guess \ket{\vec{n}_g} . Projections onto \ket{\text{MP}_i} require collective measurements, since \ket{\text{MP}_i} is entangled, albeit non-maximally. The theoretical average fidelity of the Massar and Popescu game in different scenarios can be directly calculated from Eq. 1 . If the unknown states are distributed along random and uniform directions on the unit sphere, P(\vec{n})d\vec{n}=\sin\theta d\theta d\phi/4\pi and the average fidelity using the optimal collective approach is \bar{\mathcal{F}}^{\text{Coll}}_{N=2,\text{ GenMP}}=3/4=0.75 . We will refer to this case as the collective approach to the General Massar and Popescu (GenMP) game. The average fidelity using the best local approach is \mathcal{F}^{\text{LOCC}}_{{N=2},\text{ GenMP}}=\frac{1}{6}(3+\sqrt{2})\approx 0.7357 Massar 2000 . When the a priori distribution P(n)d\vec{n} is modified so that \vec{n} is restricted to being one of the tetrahedron states \ket{\uparrow_{n_i}} , we have what we refer to as the Tetrahedron Massar and Popescu (TetraMP) game. The collective approach to the TetraMP game gives an average fidelity of \bar{\mathcal{F}}^{\text{Coll}}_{N=2,\text{ TetraMP}}=5/6\approx 0.8333 . To the best of the authors’ knowledge, the optimal LOCC approach is not known for the TetraMP game. The theoretical fidelity bounds outlined above will serve as benchmarks for evaluating our experimental results. Implementation of the Massar and Popescu measurement — Attempts to implement the Massar and Popescu game have so far been limited to the use of photonic quantum walks, where various degrees of freedom of the same photon encode different qubits Hou et al. 2018 ; Zhou et al. 2023 . While this simulates the collective strategy using non-identical degrees of freedom of a single photon, such states have analogs in classical optics and cannot meaningfully violate Bell’s inequalities or be used for useful quantum computing. Instead, we begin with two identical photons, which are our two copies in the ensemble for the Massar and Popescu game. Our multi-particle implementation involves an entangling measurement of two-photon polarization states that combines Hong-Ou-Mandel (HOM) interference with polarization-dependent loss,